Cell tower regulations frustrate homeowners
Towers under 15 metres tall avoid municipal scrutiny
By Angela Gilbert, CBC News
Posted: Sep 26, 2012 5:29 AM ET
Last Updated: Sep 26, 2012 12:47 PM ET
Homeowners across Canada are discovering cellphone towers popping up in residential neighbourhoods that slip just under height regulations that would require the company to notify those living nearby.
Oakville, Ont., resident Lisa Guglietti was in the midst of building her dream home when the mother of three noticed eight cellular network antennas strapped to the chimney of a Bell Canada building, a short distance from her son's bedroom.
"We were surprised that we weren't notified," she said. "We asked some of the neighbours. None of the neighbours had any clue that these cellular antenna had been put up."
Under federal regulations, cellphone companies must notify the municipality for towers at least 15 metres high, but many new installations are coming up short of the limit, at just 14.9 metres. Homeowners say the rule undermines their ability to weigh in on installations in the community.
Though the antennas are an eyesore, Guglietti's primary concern is possible health effects.
Experts disagree on the impact caused by cell towers. The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies radiofrequency electromagnetic fields, which are emitted by wireless phones and cell towers, as a possible human carcinogen.
Health Canada states that radiofrequency fields given off by cellphone towers are safe as long as the facility adheres to federal regulatory requirements limiting human exposure.
In an email to CBC News, a Bell spokesperson wrote that all its sites, including the Oakville, Ont., one near Guglietti's house, "meet or exceed all federal safety and other operating requirements."
City councillor struggles with issue
In June, construction began on a 14.9-metre cellphone tower in a Barrie, Ont. neighbourhood that triggered a backlash over potential health concerns for those living across the street and students walking to nearby schools.
"Telecommunications companies are able to come in and put these things basically wherever they want: as close to any residents, as close to any schools, and as close to any community centre they want," Barrie, Ont. city councillor John Brassard told CBC News.
"Why not make it 14.99 metres?" he asked.
Since the incident, the Barrie city councillor has begun working to change federal regulations to give Canadians a voice over the placement of cell towers in their neighbourhoods.
"Authority and a large part of that decision making should be made by the municipality and in consultation with Industry Canada. Not just Industry Canada alone."
Government, company response
CBC News requested government data on the number of towers under 15 metres erected across Canada, but Industry Canada said the department doesn't keep a database of that information.
In the last year, Ottawa has collected about $582 million in revenue from telecommunications companies rolling out their networks of cell towers.
Industry Canada told CBC News that companies are required to consult with the municipality and public before installing antenna towers, unless the towers fall within a certain height.
"Certain installations, including towers less than 15 metres, generally have minimal local impact and so may be excluded from municipal consultation," an Industry Canada spokesperson said in a written statement to CBC News.
After discovering the cell antennas on the large brick building next door to her new house, Guglietti contacted the federal agency.
An Industry Canada official responded in an email to Guglietti on June 8, 2012 that "given that the installation at the Bell central office building on Balsam Street complies with all procedural and technical requirements, Industry Canada is not in a position to order Bell to relocate the facility."Cell tower antennas were strapped to a chimney that was 13 metres away from the bedroom of Lisa Guglietti's son. (Angela Gilbert/CBC)
Guglietti also contacted Bell Canada, which owns the building next door, and says she was initially told it would try to find an alternative location. However, the eight cell antennas remain attached to the chimney next door.
'Don't want to be a guinea pig'
The scientific uncertainty over the health impact of cellphone towers doesn’t sit well with Guglietti.
“I'm supposed to be OK with that?" asked Guglietti. "I'm supposed to have my son exposed to these frequencies day in and day out and I have to wait. Maybe in 10 years from now I'm going to find out, 'Oh yeah there is, there can be health hazards in living so close to a cell tower.' "
"I don't want to be a guinea pig," said Guglietti.
A Bell spokesperson said in an email to CBC News that cellphone towers are being installed to meet customer demand.
Guglietti said she's certain other homeowners are dealing with similar concerns.
"I need to protect myself and I need to protect my family. I'm a mother and I'm sure anyone would do the same thing in our situation.”
If you have any information on this story, or other cellphone tower stories, please contact us at email@example.com.
Latest Toronto News Headlines
- Somali community claims police brutality in Dixon raids
- Outraged Somali-Canadian community members are accusing police and tactical squads of racial profiling and unnecessary abuse of innocent residents during last week's Project Traveller raids in the west end. more »
- Former McGuinty staffer grilled about gas plants
- A former top aide to ex-premier Dalton McGuinty fended off allegations today that senior Liberal staffers were directed to delete emails about two cancelled Toronto-area power plants as part of a cost coverup. more »
- Chrysler agrees to recall 2.9 million Jeep SUVs in U.S., Canada
- Chrysler avoided a showdown with U.S. government safety regulators Tuesday, agreeing to recall 2.7 million older Jeep Grand Cherokee and Liberty SUVs in the U.S. and 180,000 in Canada that could be at risk of a fuel tank fire. more »
- Experimental drug shows promise in treating breast, ovarian cancer
- Canadian-U.S. team of researchers has developed a new 'sharp-shooter' drug they hope will be a breakthrough in treating several types of cancer. more »
Top News Headlines
- TV chef Nigella Lawson's husband cautioned by police for assault
- Prominent British art collector Charles Saatchi has admitted assault and accepted a police caution after published photos showed him grasping the throat of his wife, celebrity chef Nigella Lawson. more »
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the other G8 leaders reach a seven-point plan aimed at stopping the conflict in Syria, wrapping up a two-day summit in Northern Ireland following talks on trade, tax evasion, poverty and terrorism. more »
- In Bangladesh's garment trade, empowerment comes at $20 a week
- The pay is laughable by Western standards, and the shantytowns of Dhaka offer a difficult life. But the surge of mostly young women into the country's increasingly important clothing industry is having a profound change on this largely Islamic society, Margaret Evans writes. more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford needs security, brother says
- Former McGuinty staffer grilled about gas plants
- Toronto's Dufferin Street named worst Ontario road again
- Rob Ford on having drink thrown at him: 'That hurt, man'
- Hundreds mourn crew killed in Ornge air ambulance crash
- Union Station revamp won't be complete until 2016
- More suspects sought in Project Traveller gang probe
- Toronto couple's Star Wars wedding shot goes viral
- Masonic Temple in Toronto sold to IT firm for $12.5M