Toronto G20 policing too aggressive, judge says
CBC News
Posted: Aug 12, 2011 5:56 PM ET
Last Updated: Aug 12, 2011 7:41 PM ET
Related
Related Links
A Toronto judge has blasted police tactics during last year's G20 summit.
Lawyers defending some of the people charged with offences in connection with last year's summit say a Toronto judge's ruling this week is going to have "an enormous impact" on their cases.
The case in question involved Michael Puddy, who took part in a demonstration on Saturday June 26, at the corner of Spadina Avenue and Queen Street West.
Puddy was on his way to a concert when he decided to join the peaceful protest.
Minutes later he had been pushed to the ground and cuffed with plastic restraints. He was held in custody for two days.
Police testified Puddy had a 15-centimetre knife attached to his belt.
Puddy, 32, from London, Ont., was eventually charged with obstructing police, concealing a weapon and possession of a prohibited weapon.
The first two charges were dismissed three months ago. On Thursday Puddy was found not guilty on the third charge.
His lawyer, Adam Goodman, said Puddy had "no intention to obstruct the police or cause any trouble," yet he was arrested.
The arrest of a man during last year's G20 summit in Toronto was 'completely unjustified,' a judge says. (Kimberley Gale/CBC) Justice Melvyn Green accepted Puddy's defence that he was not carrying the knife as a weapon and further ruled that since the arrest was illegal, so too was the search that uncovered the knife.
Puddy's arrest, he wrote, was "completely unjustified."
Green's judgment caused a stir because of its harsh criticism of police tactics. He said police officers acted as the aggressors that evening.
"The only organized or collective physical aggression at that location that evening was perpetrated by police each time they advanced on demonstrators," Green wrote.
He went on to say that the "zealous exercise of police arrest powers in the context of political demonstrations risks distorting the necessary if delicate balance between law enforcement concerns for public safety and order, on the one hand, and individual rights and freedoms, on the other."
Defence lawyer Howard Morton, who has two clients still facing G20 charges, said he thinks the ruling is "going to have an enormous impact."
"For the first time we have the outrageous conduct of the police that weekend being examined in a judicial setting in a criminal trial," said Morton.
"The judge called it what it was, outrageous police conduct."
Lawyers say the Ontario Court of Justice ruling will not set a precedent, but it will help to bolster defence arguments in future cases.
Share Tools
Latest Toronto News Headlines
- Toronto police name man arrested in abduction case
- Toronto police have released the name of a man charged with the alleged abduction and sexual assault of a child on Boxing Day. more »
- DeRozan leads Raptors past Pistons
- DeMar DeRozan scored 23 points and the Toronto Raptors defeated the Detroit Pistons 103-93 on Wednesday to end a four-game losing streak. more »
- Mississauga house collapses during renovation
- A renovation crew escapes unharmed after the 70-year-old Mississauga building they were working on suddenly collapses. more »
- Trial begins in death of Ontario girl, 13
- The trial for two people accused in the 2008 killing of a 13-year-old Mississauga girl whose body was later found stuffed in a garbage bag began Wednesday in Brampton, Ont. more »
Top News Headlines
- Target set to alter Canadian retail landscape
- The buzz surrounding Target Corporation's move into Canada could quickly turn into a backlash if the U.S. retailing giant can't deliver quality goods at prices similar to what it charges south of the border, experts say. more »
- Graham James apologizes to sex-abuse victims
- Graham James, the former junior hockey coach and convicted sexual abuser whose victims included ex-NHLers Theoren Fleury and Sheldon Kennedy, has told a courtroom: "For my behaviour, I am deeply sorry.… Parents expected sons to be safe; not all were." more »
- Santorum, Romney spar in Republican debate
- Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum swapped accusations about spending and taxes Wednesday night in the 20th and possibly final debate of the roller-coaster race for the Republican presidential nomination. more »
- U.S. base in Afghanistan attacked over Qur'an burning
- Afghan police are firing shots into the air to disperse hundreds of protesters who are trying to break into an American military base to vent their anger over the Qur'an burning incident. more »
- Trial begins in death of Ontario girl, 13
- Maid of the Mist loses Niagara Falls contract
- Ontario to scale back 'secret law' used at G20
- Mississauga house collapses during renovation
- Toronto police name man arrested in abduction case
- Slain brothers possibly lured, cousin says
- Horse racing industry fears end of slot revenue
- Toronto brothers charged in barber's killing
- Ultimate Tazer Ball combines shock and soccer

