Prostitution laws stand for now in Ont.
Last Updated: Thursday, December 2, 2010 | 3:23 PM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Terri-Jean Bedford, left, and Valerie Scott, shown in 2009, along with a third woman, launched a constitutional challenge of Canada's anti-prostitution laws. (Michael Turshic/CBC) The Ontario Court of Appeal has ruled that Canada's prostitution laws will stay in place for at least several more months, pending an appeal of a landmark ruling.
The court ruling on Thursday means that three laws — communicating for the purpose of prostitution, keeping a common bawdy house and living off the avails of prostitution — will continue to be valid.
The decision extends the stay until April 29, putting pressure on the government to expedite the appeal.
Lawyer Alan Young, who represented the sex trade workers who fought the laws, said outside the court on Thursday that the appeal "must be heard before April 29."
"This is simply an interim measure," he said, because there has never been a situation in Canada where there has been a "complete regulatory void in terms of the sex trade."
Young said that as far as he was concerned the April 29 limit was unnecessary.
"We are ready to argue this tomorrow," he said.
"I do believe when the dust settles [the lower court] decision will be upheld both by the Ontario Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court of Canada," said Young.
Justice Marc Rosenberg, in his ruling, said it would be harmful to the public interest to have the lower court ruling come into effect immediately.
Federal Justice Minister Ron Nicholson said in Ottawa that he believes the laws are constitutional and that "the provisions denounce and deter the most harmful and public aspects of prostitution."
Nicholson said he expects the appeal will be heard before April 29.
Lawyers for the province and the federal government asked for the stay, saying that without it Canada would be plunged into an unprecedented social experiment because Parliament didn't have time to craft alternative legislation.
Earlier in 2010, an Ontario Superior Court judge struck down the three laws.
Justice Susan Himel ruled the laws were unconstitutional because they prevented sex trade workers from protecting themselves by doing business in their homes.
Himel said in her ruling that the current laws "contribute to the danger faced by prostitutes."
Dominatrix Terri-Jean Bedford, Valerie Scott and Amy Lebovitch had argued that the three laws forced them from the safety of their homes to face violence on the streets.
The women asked the court to declare legal restrictions on their activities a violation of charter rights of security of the person and freedom of expression.
Young said the laws as they stand right now mean "bad laws will continue to be under-enforced" and they need to be taken off the books right away.
Corrections and Clarifications
- An earlier version of this story said Ontario's prostitution laws would stay in place pending an appeal. In fact, the laws in question are part of Canada's Criminal Code. Dec. 2, 2010 | 2:22 p.m. ET
Share Tools
Latest Toronto News Headlines
- Brampton man charged in wife's slaying
- Peel Regional Police have charged a man with second-degree murder after his wife was found dead in a Brampton home Monday morning. more »
- Driver dies after vehicle struck by tire on Highway 400
- A male driver has died from injuries he sustained in an accident involving a flying tire on Highway 400 on Monday morning. more »
- Toronto could set heat record on Monday
- The heat and humidity are descending on Toronto, with Environment Canada issuing a special weather statement, advising people to take care as the temperature soars to near 33 C. more »
- Toronto archbishop opposes gay-straight alliance bill
- The Archbishop of Toronto spoke out against the Ontario government's plan to introduce anti-bullying legislation that would allow anti-homophobic clubs to be called 'gay-straight alliances.' more »
Top News Headlines
- B.C. police shooting video sparks calls for new probe
- Amateur video of the shooting of a mentally ill Vancouver man five years ago has prompted calls for B.C.'s police complaint commissioner and the Criminal Justice Branch to take another look at the case. more »
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- A Japan-bound Air Canada Boeing 777 jet had to make an emergency landing at Toronto's Pearson airport on Monday, after one of its engines failed. more »
- CP Rail union, Tories battle over collective bargaining
- The federal Conservatives defended their plan to force striking Canadian Pacific Railway employees back to work as a way to keep the economy on track, while the union representing 4,800 workers said their collective bargaining rights are under attack. more »
- Bullyproof: One classroom confession
- Chadia became physically scarred after incessant teasing. Her story is one of 150 gathered in a video confessional booth at a Quebec school. more »
- 'Engine shutdown' forced Air Canada jet to land
- Canadian Everest climber's body recovered
- Driver dies after vehicle struck by tire on Highway 400
- Brampton man charged in wife's slaying
- Toronto could set heat record on Monday
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford 'not even dieting anymore'
- Man hits car driven by nun, has iPhone stolen
- Toronto archbishop opposes gay-straight alliance bill
- Truck dangles on overpass after 401 crash in Ajax

