Ontario urged to review all pediatric autopsies since 1981
Last Updated: Thursday, March 27, 2008 | 12:55 PM ET
The Canadian Press
Ontario is being urged to review all pediatric autopsies performed in the province that resulted in criminal convictions since 1981 in the wake of the "dreadful" work performed by disgraced pathologist Dr. Charles Smith.
A public inquiry probing a series of mistakes by Smith that sent innocent people to jail has been looking at his work from 1992 to 2002, and an internal review of Smith's earlier cases from 1981 to 1991 continues.
But lawyers representing a number of people who were convicted on evidence given by Smith say the province needs to go further, in part because Smith consulted in many cases in which his involvement was likely never recorded.
In a written submission to the inquiry, the group says the number of cases could be as high as 300, but notes that an expert panel has already examined 45 of them.
The Association in Defence of the Wrongly Convicted and lawyers representing William Mullins-Johnson are also calling on the province to review all previous "shaken baby" and fatal child head injury cases that ended in criminal convictions.
Earlier on Thursday, Smith said it would be "unfair" for a public inquiry to find he was solely responsible for any alleged miscarriages of justice that may have resulted from his work.
Smith says he made "significant" errors in only five of the 19 child-death cases examined by an Ontario public inquiry into pediatric forensic pathology.
He also says mistakes he made in three cases -- one of which wrongly sent William Mullins-Johnson to jail for the death of his four-year-old niece -- were also made by other pathologists.
Smith's claims are contained in a written submission released Thursday by the Goudge inquiry, which is expected to deliver its final report April 25.
The pathologist also admits he gave evidence that was "confusing, unscientific or overly dogmatic" in five cases.
But he says most of his errors in court were the result of an "adversarial" justice system, a lack of formal training and a culture that allowed "more expansive" testimony.
Share Tools
Latest Toronto News Headlines
- Air Canada confident it can reach deal with pilots
- Travellers flying Air Canada can keep booking their flights as negotiations continue with a new federally appointed mediator to help resolve an ongoing contract dispute between the airline and its pilots. more »
- Lin, Knicks stun Raptors with rally
- Jeremy Lin, the NBA phenomenon who went from a seldom-used player to the league's hottest story in the span of a week, drained a three-point shot with 0.5 seconds on the clock to lift the New York Knicks to their sixth consecutive victory, 90-87 over the Toronto Raptors. more »
- Woodbridge family uses social media in search for transplant
- A 22-year-old Woodbridge, Ont. woman and her family are searching desperately for a bone marrow transplant that could save her life, Marivel Taruc reports. more »
- Nexus cards now let U.S.-bound fliers fast-track screening
- Travellers under Canada's Nexus program will be able to use their cards in new, faster security lines when flying to the United States from eight cities starting Wednesday, Transport Minister Denis Lebel says. more »
Top News Headlines
- Air Canada confident it can reach deal with pilots
- Travellers flying Air Canada can keep booking their flights as negotiations continue with a new federally appointed mediator to help resolve an ongoing contract dispute between the airline and its pilots. more »
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- Four former B.C. attorneys general are joining a coalition of health and justice experts calling for the legalization of marijuana. more »
- Whitney Houston's funeral to be held Saturday
- Pop star Whitney Houston's funeral service will be held Saturday in the New Jersey church where she first showcased her singing talents as a child. more »
- CN blamed for fatal train derailment in Illinois
- CN is being blamed for a 2009 train derailment in Illinois, in which several cars went off the tracks and caught fire, killing one person and injuring seven others. more »
- Mandatory gun sentence struck down by Ontario judge
- Ontario 'confinement room' arrest made
- Toronto NBA fans prepare for 'Lin-sanity'
- Fords plan 'Save Our Subways' campaign
- McGuinty hints at pay freeze for public sector execs
- Ban Wi-Fi in classroom, Ontario teachers union urges
- CBC digital music service launched
- Ultimate Tazer Ball combines shock and soccer
- Ontario government to sell LCBO headquarters

