Snow-clearing firm Carillion probed over poor road conditions in Peel, Halton

A company already facing $900,000 in fines for failing to clear Ontario highways in 2014 is under investigation again by the Ministry of Transportation after a series of accidents in Peel and Halton regions on New Year's Day.

Ministry checking whether QEW, parts of Hwy 401, 403 & 427 properly salted

Ontario's ministry of transportation is checking when Carillion Canada dispatched salt spreaders on the Queen Elizabeth Way and on sections of Highways 400, 401, 403, 410 and 427 during a Jan. 1 storm.

A company already facing $900,000 in fines for failing to clear Ontario highways in 2014 is under investigation again by the Ministry of Transportation after a series of accidents in Peel and Halton regions on New Year's Day.

The ministry is checking to see exactly when Carillion Canada dispatched salt spreaders and how much salt was applied on the Queen Elizabeth Way and on sections of Highways 400, 401, 403, 410 and 427 during a Jan. 1 storm.

About 20 accidents were reported on highways west and north of Toronto that day, and the ministry says the "weather-related" mishaps were a factor in deciding to conduct a full review of Carillon's actions.

Carillion, which has 6,000 employees in Canada and 40,000 worldwide, was awarded eight of Ontario's 20 road maintenance contracts, worth a total of $87 million per year.

The company is still fighting the fines levied by the ministry for failing to properly clear the QEW of snow and ice during storms in November and December 2014.

A Transportation Ministry spokesman says talks with Carillion on the size of the fines are continuing, and mediation or even litigation could be needed to reach a final agreement.

Transportation Minister Steven Del Duca said the investigation into the 2014 storms found Carillion was late in deploying snow clearing and de-icing equipment, and did not apply enough salt on the highway.

"I take my responsibility with winter driving safety very seriously and, as keeping Ontario's roads safe is a shared responsibility, I expect all of our contractors and their employees to do the same," Del Duca said in a statement.

The opposition parties say the Liberal government lowered standards for road maintenance contracts in 2009 to reduce costs, which they blame for dangerous driving conditions during the winter months.

"The Liberals were caught last year lowering safety standards on our highways just to save a few bucks," said Progressive Conservative transportation critic Michael Harris.

"We now know that the Liberals' mismanagement has created even more dangerous driving conditions on the winter roads, putting the lives of motorists at risk."

Ontario's auditor general reported last year that the government did save money on winter road maintenance after 2009, but at a cost that included taking twice as long to clear highways of snow or ice than it did previously, nearly five hours in some cases.

The auditor also reported the government had waived $4.8 million of $13.3 million in fines levied against contractors in the winter of 2013-14.

The New Democrats asked the government to release all the non-compliance reports on all road maintenance contractors, and the results of the latest investigation into Carillion.

"Last year, Ontario's auditor-general reported that private road maintenance companies are using less salt and de-icing fluid," said NDP transportation critic Wayne Gates. "So far, it looks like the ministry hasn't solved the problems."

The Liberal government came under fire after admitting some of the companies awarded road maintenance contracts did not have the equipment to do the job.

The government says ministry staff reviewed the readiness of all the road maintenance contractors' equipment and availability of their operators before this winter to avoid any repeats of the problems from early last winter.

Carillion did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the latest investigation or its fight against the $900,000 in fines imposed in 2014.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.