Milton, Ont., garbage man accused of padding truck's weight with snow

Halton Region is defending a private company after one of its employees was recorded on video shovelling snow into a truck - allegedly adding weight for a bigger pay day.

Employee recorded allegedly trying to add weight to load, earning more for Miller Waste Systems

Footage of this garbage man shovelling snow into his truck sparked allegations he was trying to pad the vehicle's weight, earning more money for the private company that collects waste in Milton. (Anna O'Sullivan/Facebook)

A garbage collector who was seen shovelling snow into his truck while also picking up waste was apparently not performing a good deed.

Anna O'Sullivan of Milton, Ont., posted video to Facebook on Monday of what she thought was a nice gesture. The 30-second clip shows an employee of Miller Waste Systems shovelling snow from the front of her house.

"Along with picking up the usual bag of garbage, they also picked up the excess snow that was beside the curb," O'Sullivan wrote, adding the hashtag #ilovemilton. 

But the conversation online soon turned to allegations that the worker was padding the weight of his truck, because Miller is paid by the tonnage of the waste it collects. 

The Halton Region government launched an investigation. 

If they dump it on the floor and it's full of snow … we know that trick.— Jim  Harnum , commissioner of public works for  Halton  Region

Jim Harnum, commissioner of public works for Halton Region, told CBC News officials "knew exactly" what the worker was doing once they saw the video. 

The region is "not paying for anything that truck did that particular day," he said. 

The company is also facing a fine or damages, he added. 

Harnum said the region has a good relationship with Miller, whose contract is worth some $13 million a year. It has collected garbage there since 2008. 

He said what happened in Milton appears to be an isolated incident, adding that the garbage collection system is designed to spot cheating. Collection is monitored on the street by supervisors and checked by spotters once it's dropped off at transfer stations, he said. 

Jim Harnum, commissioner of public works for Halton Region, says the garbage collection system is designed to spot cheating. (CBC)

"If they dump it on the floor and it's full of snow, or if it's soaking wet — we know that trick and we would reject the load," he said. 

"We haven't seen that … so we think this is an isolated incident." 

He said officials are also checking that truck's records for the last two years for any "anomalies."

Milton Mayor Gordon Krantz, who sits on the Halton regional council, said the matter should be discussed at the next council meeting, but added that Miller "has done an outstanding job" with its contract. 

"There needs to be a little homework done on this," he said. "The taxpayers of Halton deserve it."

Halton Region recently renewed its contract with Miller for another eight years. The company has not responded to interview requests.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.