Collapsed mall waterproofing called into question
Company that provided concrete slabs says it isn't responsible for waterproofing methods
Posted: Mar 7, 2013 8:46 AM ET
Last Updated: Mar 7, 2013 1:01 PM ET
An executive of the company that supplied the roof-decking of the ill-fated Algo Centre Mall in Elliot Lake, Ont., says salts are damaging to concrete but said waterproofing the material is strictly out of the firm's hands.
Doug Harman said Coreslab Structures makes no recommendations about waterproofing its product either.Douglas Harman, vice president of Coreslab, the company that made the concrete slabs for the roof at the Algo Centre Mall, said the firm isn't responsible for waterproofing methods. That responsiblity rests with the architect, he said. (Supplied )
Harman made the statement Thursday during the public inquiry into last June's collapse of the mall's roof-top garage that killed two women. He said waterproofing is up to the project architect or engineering team.
Coreslab made the precast hollow concrete slabs three decades ago that ultimately fell. Investigators believe water and salt penetration rusted out a critical weld on the underlying support structure.
Harman said he wasn't with the company in 1979 when the Algo Center Mall was built, but noted not much has changed in its product since. CoreSlab installs the concrete, but it isn't responsible for waterproofing methods.
The inquiry heard more details about the building's roof from both Harman and Dave Monroe, whose companies or products were involved in the construction of the roof at the mall.
Monroe is the former vice president of Harry S. Peterson, which provided the Algo Centre Mall roofing system. Harman is vice president and general manager of Coreslab, which supplied the concrete slabs for the parking deck.A woman checks out the damage after the roof collapsed at the Algo Centre Mall in Elliot Lake, on June 23, 2012. The partial collapse prompted a local state of emergency. Two women died in the incident. (Cora Richer/The Canadian Press)
The structural engineer who oversaw the building of the mall more than 30 years ago said Wednesday it was the worst construction work he has seen in his career — yet he still gave the project his seal of approval.
John Kadlec was the second witness to speak during the public inquiry being held in the community.
Kadlec said he saw evidence of shoddy workmanship from the time the mall was built in 1978 and noted the mall was built using crooked columns and rusted steel beams.
He said he tried to bring the issues to the attention of the mall owner and architect, but was "ignored."
Inquiry lawyer Joseph Bisceglia jumped on that during cross-examination. "It's your stamp that's going on the drawing, it's your stamp that's going on the certificate, that everything is fine,” he said.
Kadlec concurred, adding that, even after he approved the Elliot Lake mall, he knew there were problems.
"I knew there was leaking, but I didn't know nothing had been done,” he said.
Kadlec also said he helped design the Algo Centre Mall, without seeing the site or knowing what materials would be used.
He said he opposed putting the parking on the roof, which is where the fatal collapse happened.
Schedule of testimony:
Commissioner's opening remarks; preliminary matters
Dale Craig, expert, engineer J.L. Richards, overview of the construction of a building and state of the art in roofing at time of construction
|March 6||John Kadlec, partner at Beta Engineering, structural engineer during construction of Algo Centre Mall|
Dave Monroe, former vice president of Harry S. Peterson, Algo Centre Mall roofing system
Doug Harman, vice president and general manager, Coreslab, supplied concrete slab
|March 8||Henry Jasskelainen, former supervisor of Harry S. Peterson, installed roofing system and conducted repairs|
|March 11||James Keywan, architect, retained by Algoma Central Properties for the design of the Algo Centre Mall|
|March 12 & 13|
Barbara Fazekas, former chief librarian, Elliot Lake Public Library
Rod Caughill, former development supervisor, Algoma Central Properties
|March 14||Domenic Dell'Aquilla (Trow), engineer, hired by Algoma Central Properties|
Latest Sudbury News Headlines
- Avoid tragedy with working CO detector: fire official
- As more Sudbury area residents head out to recreational properties this time of year, the Greater Sudbury Fire Services says failing to have a working carbon monoxide detector at camp could result in tragedy. more »
- Redefining 'local' food sits well with Sudbury advocate
- The head of a local food co-operative in Sudbury is glad to hear the federal government is changing the way it defines local food. more »
- Deal to protect boreal forest caribou fails
- Three years of negotiations between Resolute Forest Products and environmental groups aimed at protecting parts of Canada's boreal forest have ended in failure, with talks breaking down over how much land to set aside for conservation. more »
- Hwy 69 blasting to slow drivers south of Sudbury
- Blasting along Highway 69 could cause traffic delays this summer as work crews begin to widen another 28 km of highway to four lanes. more »
Top News Headlines
- Video forensics: How easy would it be to fake a Rob Ford video?
- Two media outlets reported last week that they had seen a cellphone video of Mayor Rob Ford allegedly smoking crack, a claim that has gone global. If a video does surface, how easy would it be to determine its authenticity? CBC News asked video forensic analyst David McKay. more »
- Oklahoma residents begin to return home after deadly tornado
- Rescue workers raced to complete the search for survivors and the dead in the Oklahoma City suburb where a mammoth tornado destroyed countless homes, cleared lots down to bare red earth and claimed 24 lives, including those of nine children. more »
- Xbox One: A closer look
- The design, performance, Kinect camera, controller, requirements and limitations of Microsoft's Xbox One get a critical look. more »
- Boil water advisory in effect across Montreal
- A boil water advisory is in effect for much of Montreal, including all areas south of the Métropolitaine, from LaSalle to Pointe-aux-Trembles and including the borough of Anjou. more »