Bad-driving snitch line targeting seniors prompts police apology
Phone hotline in Sudbury, Ont., called 'abuse of a public service'
Posted: Feb 22, 2013 8:54 AM ET
Last Updated: Feb 22, 2013 1:31 PM ET
Police in Sudbury, Ont., wanted the phone to ring on a hotline to report bad driving by older people, but now officers are dealing with calls from angry seniors.
Getting people to call the Crime Stoppers tip line stems from a safe-driving task force launched at the end of January by the Greater Sudbury Police, the OPP and other community groups.
It was set up for people to call and anonymously report sightings of people who appear to be driving dangerously, but police recently put an emphasis on reporting older drivers. Police say the number of seniors getting into collisions is almost on par with those of drivers aged 24 and under.Darleene McCormack, a 67-year-old Sudbury, Ont., driver, reacted to a new tip line by saying she would be shocked if a police officer showed up at her door to talk about her driving. (Hilary Duff/CBC)
A plainclothes police officer would then be sent to the home of a senior driver reported on the tip line to talk about any issues and offer help.
Police said it's part of an effort to encourage proactive discussion with seniors about when it may be appropriate for the elderly to stop driving.
But for Sudbury seniors like Darleene McCormack, having a police officer show up at her front door is anything but proactive.
"So it would be a fear factor of, 'What happened? Why is the policeman here?' And then, when the policeman says it's about my driving, I would probably be very shocked,” she said.
McCormack, 67, said she's appalled the task force is focusing on just older people.
‘Hearts were in the right place’
But Greater Sudbury police Chief Frank Elsner said that was never the intent, and the initiative was meant to give families a much-needed tool to have the unsafe driving talk with their loved ones.Sudbury police Chief Frank Elsner says the tip line was meant to give families a tool to have the unsafe driving talk with loved ones. (CBC)
"The vast majority of complaints we get, not through the tip lines, but just directly to us, are from family members that do not want to have that very difficult conversation with their mother or father,” he said.
“So we get the call and then we're the bad guy."
Elsner said he’s sorry the messaging for the campaign offended some seniors.
"Our hearts were in the right place, it had nothing to do with targeting anybody, any specific segment of our population,” he said, noting that police home visits are not enough for an officer to take away a person's licence.
"We would have a better and more thoughtful approach to dealing with those individuals, and not from an enforcement policing perspective. And unfortunately, the way that the message got rolled out, it was the exact opposite. And for that, I'm very sorry."
‘Many poor drivers on the road’
McCormack said having people calling in reports on seniors is cruel.
"[I’m] totally appalled that they would focus in on one group when there's so many poor drivers on the road,” she said.Susan Eng, vice-president of CARP, says the association is strongly opposed to the tip line, which basically rats people out. (CARP)
National seniors’ advocacy group CARP said calling Crime Stoppers is too much like ratting people out.
"To report on your own relative because you think they shouldn't be driving seems to be virtually an abuse of a public service,” said CARP vice-president Susan Eng.
“I would hope that the police officers would have a lot more to do with their time."
Elsner said the original intent was to expand this task force across the province, but now he's not sure that's still the plan.
He added people can call Crime Stoppers to report dangerous driving — whether the person behind the wheel is 18, or 80.
"What we want to make sure is that the specific individual driver is the one that we focus on and not that we start broad sweeping various segments of our population."
Latest Sudbury News Headlines
- Sudbury Red Cross needs help
- The forest fire season is just around the corner and the Canadian Red Cross in Sudbury says it is preparing for what may come. more »
- Manager of collapsed Ontario mall admits lying to tenants
- The inquiry into the deadly collapse of the roof at Algo Centre mall in Elliot Lake, Ont., hears about altered documents and questionable repairs to the structure in the years leading up to the June 2012 tragedy. more »
- Man killed at Sudbury metal plate shop
- Greater Sudbury Police, the Ministry of Labour and the Coroner's Office are investigating a death at a business in Lively after a metal plate crushed a worker. more »
- Rising water levels keeps Wawa residents on alert
- People in Wawa are keeping a close eye on the skies today now that a flood warning is in effect for the Michipicoten River watershed. more »
Top News Headlines
- 2nd suspect in Tim Bosma murder case to plead not guilty
- The lawyer for Mark Smich says the Oakville, Ont., resident will plead not guilty to first-degree murder in the death of Tim Bosma, the Hamilton man who disappeared earlier this month after taking two men on a test drive of his truck. Smich was charged today, after Dellen Millard of Toronto was also charged with first-degree murder. more »
- U.K. attack suspects were focus of past security probes
- WARNING: This story contains graphic content. Two men accused of butchering a British soldier had featured in previous investigations by security services, a British official said, as investigators tried to determine whether the men were part of a wider radical Islamic plot. more »
- Neil Macdonald: Harper no Obama when it comes to dealing with scandals
- Beset by three so-called scandals at the moment, Barack Obama has been meeting his accusers and the press head on, Neil Macdonald writes. The same cannot be said for how Stephen Harper operates. more »
- Rob Ford: Councillors, media want answers on crack issue
- Newspaper editorials and commentators are expressing frustration over Toronto Mayor Rob Ford's silence on allegations he was captured on video smoking what appears to be crack cocaine. more »