Elliot Lake inquiry may be complicated by criminal probe
Public inquiry and criminal probe to proceed simultaneously
The Canadian Press
Posted: Jul 12, 2012 10:01 AM ET
Last Updated: Jul 12, 2012 6:33 PM ET
A public inquiry into a deadly mall collapse in the northern Ontario community of Elliot Lake could be complicated by a criminal investigation that's currently underway, experts say.
The public inquiry is expected to begin in the next two months, which means it would likely take place at the same time as the criminal probe.
A $30-million lawsuit related to last month's collapse has also been launched that names the mall owner, the city and the provincial government.
There's no legal prohibition against it, but "issues can arise" when both an inquiry and a criminal probe proceed simultaneously, said Brendan Crawley, a spokesman for the Ontario Ministry of the Attorney General.
"As a result, the commissioner conducting the inquiry will typically take care to make sure that the inquiry does not interfere with other proceedings, including criminal or regulatory matters," he said in an email.
Past inquiries affected
Inquiries proceeding alongside police probes have been affected by the criminal investigations in the past.
Lawyer Peter Wardle, who represented victims at the Ontario inquiry into the work of disgraced pathologist Charles Smith, said two inquiries in the 1990s were derailed due to concerns about fair trial rights when there were parallel criminal investigations.
In 1990, the Supreme Court of Canada shut down the Patti Starr inquiry in Ontario, which lawyers argued violated the rights of the individuals whose actions it was examining.
The court said that inquiry served as a "substitute police investigation" into a specific allegation of criminal conduct by Starr. They ruled that the inquiry exceeded the province's jurisdiction because the terms of reference were almost identical to the criminal charges.
"The Supreme Court of Canada did not hold that you couldn't have a criminal investigation and a public inquiry at the same time," said Ronald Foerster, who was a junior lawyer on the government side of that inquiry.
"You just couldn't have them at the same time if they were exactly the same."
An inquiry into the 1992 Westray mining disaster in Nova Scotia was also delayed due to concerns about the fair trial rights of senior Westray Coal employees.
A judge ruled that the inquiry was unconstitutional, but the decision was overturned in 1993 by the province's top court.
However, it ruled that the inquiry could only continue once all charges went through the court system.
It's impossible to know whether the Elliot Lake inquiry will run into similar difficulties because its terms of reference have not yet been determined, Foerster said.A shrine sits in memory of Doloris Perizzolo, 74, and Lucie Aylwin, 37, who were killed when a portion of the Algo Centre Mall roof caved-in June 23 and plummeted into the shopping centre. A total of 20 others were injured. (Yvon Theriault/CBC)
Doloris Perizzolo, 74, and Lucie Aylwin, 37, were killed and 20 others injured when a portion of the Algo Centre Mall roof caved in June 23 and plummeted into the shopping centre.
Inquiry can’t recommend criminal charges
Ontario Attorney General John Gerretsen said the public inquiry — which was called before the Ontario Provincial Police announced its investigation — will probe the events leading up to the tragedy and review the emergency response to the disaster.
He said it may also raise questions about the role private owners play in maintaining their properties.
A prominent Ottawa judge, Justice Paul Belanger, will lead the inquiry.
Inquiry commissioners are usually directed not to make any conclusions or recommendations on criminal charges or civil liability.
"Presumably, they won't name any individuals and it will be much broader than any criminal act that may be involved," Foerster said.
If a person who's under investigation by police testifies at an inquiry, that evidence cannot be used against them in any future court proceeding, including a criminal trial, Foerster said.
"Having said all of that, the reality is that it is at a public inquiry, their testimony will go out there, so people will know about it," he said. "It's just that their specific words can't be used against them in a future trial."
It is possible for a potential juror in a future criminal trial to hear that evidence through media reports, he acknowledged. But they'll be instructed to disregard it at trial.
To avoid problems involving the right to a fair trial, the public inquiry can wait until the criminal process is resolved — as was done in British Columbia in the Robert Pickton inquiry, Wardle said.
Commissioners can also hold portions of inquiries in private. Such was the case during the Maher Arar inquiry when matters of national security were involved, Foerster said. But that's not the case in the Elliot Lake probe.
There are ways that an inquiry could be held in private, but that decision is entirely up to the commissioner, he said.
"While there are ways of doing it," he said. "It can — depending on the circumstances — be quite difficult to do."
Latest Sudbury News Headlines
- High water levels worries Sudbury canoe club
- A Sudbury canoe club instructor says high water levels on Ramsey Lake are causing problems, even though the city says it would rather see water levels higher than lower ones. more »
- Sudbury residents paying for shingles vaccine
- Demand for the shingles vaccine is on the rise in Sudbury, as people try to prevent the agonizing rash. more »
- Shelter website aims to match lost pets with owners
- The Rainbow District Animal Shelter has created a new lost and found page for pets on its website, in an attempt to match lost pets with their owners more quickly. more »
- Half of First Nations children live in poverty
- Half of status First Nations children in Canada live in poverty, a troubling figure that jumps to nearly two-thirds in Saskatchewan and Manitoba, says a newly released report. more »
Top News Headlines
- Sopranos star James Gandolfini dies in Italy
- James Gandolfini, whose portrayal of a brutal, emotionally delicate mob boss in HBO's 'The Sopranos' helped create one of TV's greatest drama series and turned the mobster stereotype on its head, died Wednesday in Italy. He was 51. more »
- B.C. First Nation sets fires to save bison
- A First Nation band is reviving the age-old practice of controlled burning in order to improve the health of forests and restore the population of the wood bison in a corner of northeastern B.C. more »
- Canada buys rare War of 1812 collection for $573K
- The government of Canada was the winning bidder for a large collection of letters, maps and other papers that once belonged to Sir John Sherbrooke, the lieutenant-governor of Nova Scotia who conquered Maine for the British during the War of 1812. The collection sold for $573,000 at auction in London. more »
- Bob Rae quits as MP in 'very emotional' decision
- Bob Rae, who has represented the Toronto Centre riding for the Liberals since 2008, is stepping down as a Member of Parliament to devote more time to his work as a negotiator for First Nations in Northern Ontario. more »