Does no NHL season mean others can go for the Stanley Cup?
CBC News
Posted: Nov 13, 2012 12:57 PM ET
Last Updated: Nov 13, 2012 2:43 PM ET
The NHL lockout is nearing its third month with the prospects of a season dwindling, but some say there's no reason Canadians have to go without a chance to see the Stanley Cup awarded this year.
Since Canada's then Gov. Gen. Lord Stanley of Preston awarded the Cup to the people of Canada in 1893, it has been the definitive symbol of hockey greatness.
Since 1926, it has been exclusively awarded to the NHL team that wins the playoffs each season. But as a landmark 2006 court decision made clear, there's no reason that has to be the case.
The Cup's charter says it "shall be awarded yearly to the best team in the Dominion," but in fact, it is managed by two trustees, who have always decided to award it to the NHL's playoff champion.
Toronto lawyer Tim Gilbert won that court case on behalf of some recreational hockey players, who didn't appreciate that the NHL seemed to be holding the Cup hostage during the league's last lockout in 2004.
"The attitude of the trustees was that the NHL owned the Cup," he told CBC's Lang & O'Leary Exchange recently. "That raised the ire of fans.
"It is owned by the trustees for the benefit of hockey — for the benefit of everyone, generally — and that point was forcefully made by way of a lawsuit," Gilbert said.
The outcome of the landmark ruling was that the trustees and the league were forced to admit that the NHL does not, in fact, own the Stanley Cup after all. So it could theoretically return to its roots as a challenge trophy in any season where an NHL champion isn't crowned — as may end up being the case this season.
"The agreement they signed said they can, they may," Gilbert noted.
2 Cup trustees may not be onboard
There's no indication that's a likely development, however. The Cup trustees, Ian (Scotty) Morrison and Brian O'Neill — NHL loyalists with decades of professional hockey experience between them — haven't expressed any sort of desire to award the Cup to a non-NHL team.
As Gilbert's case established, they have the right to do so. But there doesn't seem to be the will.
That's the case with other influential people, too.
In 2004, Gov. Gen. Adrienne Clarkson caused a ruckus by suggesting that, in the absence of NHL games during the lockout that year, the Stanley Cup should be awarded to the best women's team in the country.
Policymakers quickly backed away from that idea, and Gilbert suggests the two highest-ranking hockey fans in Canada — Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Gov. Gen. David Johnston — are unlikely to want to wade into the debate this time, barring a major show of support for the idea
"If any Canadians have a good idea, I would suggest they would write to the trustees, and … decide what's best for the good of the game," Gilbert says.
Watch the complete interview with Gilbert above or click here to watch it in a new window.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges
- Montreal Mayor Michael Applebaum has resigned in the wake of corruption charges being laid against him, although he maintains he is innocent. more »
- 2 men jailed in Dominican wedding fight return to Canada
- Two Canadian men who were detained in the Dominican Republic for nearly three weeks after a post-wedding fight broke out at a resort have returned to Toronto, the latest step in a drama that the wife of one of the men said was "like a scene from the movies." more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- Senators call for 'zero tolerance' on harassment in RCMP
- The RCMP should amend its code of conduct to explicitly define and prohibit harassment, a Senate committee is recommending in a newly tabled report. more »
Must Watch
Latest Canada News Headlines
- 2 men jailed in Dominican wedding fight return to Canada
- Two Canadian men who were detained in the Dominican Republic for nearly three weeks after a post-wedding fight broke out at a resort have returned to Toronto, the latest step in a drama that the wife of one of the men said was "like a scene from the movies." more »
- MPs and senators' side income provokes ethics debate
- The debate over Justin Trudeau's speaking fees has raised questions about what MPs and senators should be allowed to earn on top of their salaries, with some political watchers urging a wider discussion about financial conduct among parliamentarians. more »
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges
- Montreal Mayor Michael Applebaum has resigned in the wake of corruption charges being laid against him, although he maintains he is innocent. more »
- Disabled woman's care before dying on bus still a mystery
- CBC Radio's The Current has broadcast a documentary about a 48-year-old Alberta woman with developmental problems, Betty Anne Gagnon, who died in November 2009 in a filthy converted bus that had no heat, electricity or running water. more »
- MPs pass NDP motion on expenses, adjourn for summer
- One week after defeating Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau's attempt to open MPs' expenses to public scrutiny, the NDP has won approval for a proposal of its own just before MPs voted unanimously to rise for the summer break. more »
The National
The Current
- What happened to Betty Anne Gagnon? Jun. 18, 2013 3:09 PM Betty Anne Gagnon's mental disabilities didn't stop her from finding work, or finding friends. But when she needed it the most, she was unable to find help.
- 2 men jailed in Dominican wedding fight return to Canada
- Police probe death of woman, 27, in Kelowna home
- Hundreds attend 'Change Brazil' protest in Vancouver
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- Parents of son 'brutally beaten' playing hockey want charges
- Huge ancient city at Angkor Wat revealed by lasers
- Most groups don't want return of Trudeau speaking fees
- MPs pass NDP motion on expenses, adjourn for summer
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges

