Criminal profiling and the body parts case
Q&A with Jim Van Allen, profiling expert
By Daniel Schwartz, CBC News
Posted: May 31, 2012 5:50 PM ET
Last Updated: Jun 1, 2012 11:42 AM ET
The search for the person who killed and dismembered a man in Montreal — sending body parts in the mail — has drawn international attention because of the macabre details of the crime and the difficulty of understanding who could commit such a deed.
Jim Van Allen has many years of experience as a criminal profiler, including as former manager with the Ontario Provincial Police Criminal Profile Unit.
He assisted in the investigation of the Paul Bernardo cases, and the Holly Jones and Cecilia Zhang homicides, two young girls who were abducted and killed in 2003 and 2004
A much sought after expert, Van Allen now heads the Behavioural Science Solutions Group, a private firm in Langley, B.C., that specializes in threat assessments and violence reduction strategies. He spoke to CBC News by phone from Langley.
Have you seen other crimes that resemble the body parts case in Montreal?
We've seen different crimes in different places that have some similarities to this. But I've never seen somebody publish it on the internet, like has been done here.
We've seen various crimes recorded either by digital photos or video. Normally that's kept privately by the offender for himself. This individual appears to be publishing it, he's looking for maximum media attention, he's looking for the shock value to the public, and it's likely to just increase his own notoriety. He wants to receive attention, even if it’s strong negative attention.
Certainly one way to get attention is by mailing body parts. As a profiler, do you see any significance in where the body parts were sent?
Those targets guaranteed him maximum media attention and he got it.
Dismembering a body first of all sounds like a pretty difficult thing and not too many murderers do that. What does it say to a profiler when dismemberment follows a murder?
Criminal profiling expert Jim Van Allen says the evidence in the body parts case suggests an individual looking for media attention and notoriety. (Courtesy Jim Van Allen)Individuals dismember bodies for different reasons. Sometimes it's just to facilitate the disposal of the body, of evidence, prevent discovery of the crime and avoid apprehension. But other times bodies are mutilated or dismembered because of the level of anger and rage.
In some cases it's a sexual crime. Certainly there's a strong sexual component to this crime.
There are multiple reasons for the dismemberment in this case. Dismemberment made the torso easy to dispose of and he also had this design to commit a sensational crime and he used the body parts to do that.
The mutilation and dismemberment are recorded. The video is one of the most gruesome things the average person could see.
I had to avert my eyes from the screen a couple of times and I've looked at a lot of graphically violent stuff. I'd recommend that most people do not watch it.
Once the police have a suspect, how do they connect the profile to the individual?
Profiling does not always help direct investigation at a suspect.
This is an easy one to misinterpret or just not get, because it seems so unusual at first glance. The better you understand it, the better you can investigate it, you will know how to deal with and communicate with the suspect once you locate him. One of the goals is to get the individual into an interview room talking to police officers.
If we understand the dynamics of the crime, and the personality, then we’re better prepared to speak to him and set up an environment where he can share information, should he choose.
Is there anything here that tells you the perpetrator wants to be caught?
No, that's a myth. People who show remorse after committing a crime call 911 or show up at a police station and he has not done that to date.
Is it also a myth that people who commit violent acts or cruelty against animals go onto crimes against people?
Not all of them, no. Many little boys go through that, not to the extent he's published on the internet, of course, but not everybody that does that goes on to commit crimes against human beings, at least of this severity.
An unusual amount is known about the suspect, 29-year-old Luka Rocco Magnotta. All this stuff that he's been doing online, including the kittens, was that just his attempt to get attention or is there something else at play there?
What we're seeing is the same theme going through all his activities. It's part and parcel of his personality, who he is, what he wants out of life. And he wants to be known as this racy, glamorous persona, the Russian, Italian model thing that he's not. It all seems to be orchestrated to garner him attention and notoriety and it has continued to the point where it's at now.
But that makes it difficult to get away with the crime, if he's guilty.
If he was trying to get away with that crime, he sure went about that the wrong way. But if he's attention seeking and looking for the notoriety, he’s done it. He's fled, he's got a bit of a head start and now the police are trying to trace him.
An international manhunt is now underway. I’ve heard Magnotta probably has limited resources, he's probably going to be easily recognized, so what do you think he's going to do?
I think he's going to hop on a bus and go somewhere he can blend in, where they don't know him. The United States is close to Montreal, he apparently has a background in Toronto, and those might suggest areas he might go to, but all possibilities are very much alive. Hopefully a member of the public will recognize him, report him and that will focus the manhunt.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Deadly Oklahoma tornado confirmed as most powerful type
- Emergency workers neared the end of their search Tuesday afternoon for survivors in Moore, Okla., following a deadly tornado that weather officials said was now classified among the most powerful type of twister. more »
- Children driven around too much, Canadian report suggests
- Fewer Canadian kids are commuting by walking or biking as a new report reveals a marked decline among young people using active modes of transportation. more »
- Senate set to debate expense audits amid greater scrutiny
- The Senate will debate its own committee's reports into living expenses claimed by three senators Tuesday night in a session that could see Senator Mike Duffy's claims sent back for a second audit. more »
- 'Speculation' in Bosma death unfair to accused, says lawyer
- "Speculation" surrounding the accused, Dellen Millard, in the case of Timothy Bosma's death is unfairly poisoning the suspect's image, his lawyer said Tuesday. more »
Must Watch
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Mountie sues 13 ex-colleagues for sex assault, harassment
- An RCMP staff sergeant has filed a multimillion-dollar lawsuit against 13 former colleagues in the force's travelling equestrian show the Musical Ride, claiming she was sexually assaulted and harassed in the 1980s. more »
- Canadian on EI shut out amid foreign worker influx
- A jobless Canadian IT professional who is collecting employment insurance is upset because he now suspects several recent jobs he applied for went to temporary foreign workers. more »
- B.C. mine's temporary foreign workers case dismissed
- The Federal Court of Canada has dismissed a challenge launched by two unions against a company that hired more than 200 temporary workers from China for its coal mine in northeastern B.C. more »
- Dellen Millard farm still under police watch
- Police remain at the Waterloo region farm of murder suspect Dellen Millard today after unknown remains were found on the property, and there's still no word on the test results to determine if they're human or animal. more »
The National
The Current
- The morning after the Oklahoma tornado May. 21, 2013 4:17 PM The rescue efforts and aftermath of yesterday's devastating tornado in Moore, Oklahoma.
- Deadly Oklahoma tornado confirmed as most powerful type
- 'Very upset' Harper wants fast Senate spending reform
- Microsoft unveils Xbox One
- Schoolchildren describe Oklahoma tornado terror
- Microsoft's Xbox revamp: Is the sun setting on game consoles?
- Mountie sues 13 ex-colleagues for sex assault, harassment
- Dellen Millard farm still under police watch
- Edmonton driver, 62, charged in boy's patio death
- Jodi Arias asks jury to spare her life

