Gender-Ed
Robert Smol
Why our schools are failing boys
Last Updated: Friday, January 8, 2010 | 3:55 PM ET
By Robert Smol, special to CBC News
Robert Smol
Biography
Born and raised in Montreal, Robert Smol holds degrees from McGill and Queen's universities as well as from the Royal Military College in Kingston, Ont., where he obtained a master of arts in war studies.
At 17, he enrolled in the army reserves as a private in the infantry and served both full- and part-time for over 20 years until his retirement as a captain in the Intelligence Branch.
Since 1992, he has been mostly teaching elementary and high school students in the Toronto area.
As a freelance journalist, Smol has written extensively on military policy, as well as on veteran and education matters, for the Hill Times and Embassy Magazine in Ottawa. He also contributes to the Toronto Star and Sun, among others.
Looking at the demographics of university-bound students today, it is hard to believe that not so long ago we were developing programs to get more girls into university.
By all indications now, that same spirit of reform and innovation is needed to push more boys into higher education — for all that may be worth.
These days I need only peek into a class and I can tell by the gender makeup whether or not it is academic or applied.
Those classes where the majority are female students are invariably academic. Those where the majority is male are not.
No surprise then that the face of university education in this country is increasingly becoming female as women have been overtaking men in both the participation rate as well as in the percentage who graduate.
In September 2009, Monica Garcia, president of the Los Angeles public school system, tours L.A.'s first middle school to teach boys and girls in single-gender core classes. (Damian Dovarganes/Associated Press) According to the federal department of human resources and skills development, 18 per cent of young men 18-24 were in university in 2005-06. The equivalent figure for young women was 28 per cent.
At the same time, the high school dropout rate for male students has remained consistently higher in recent decades than that for girls, another indicator that our education system is failing our boys.
There is clearly a problem here.
Increasingly female
I am blaming "the system" for this because we shouldn't be blaming young male students for the difficulties they face in what is arguably an increasingly female-programmed educational culture.
Some, such as Michael Reist, an Ontario teacher and author of The Dysfunctional School: Uncomfortable Truths and Awkward Insights on School, Learning, and Education, blame the problem on research that suggests the brains of boys and girls are "wired" differently.
They argue that boys' brains are more able to deal with spatial problems and girls tend to be more developed in language and communication, which, if true, is certainly a concern when one looks at the way many class lessons are now organized.
"Classrooms keep getting set up more and more around the verbal and less around the kinesthetic and active," says Michael Gurian author of Boys and Girls Learn Differently. "They are increasingly becoming environments that favour the girls' brain."
And as enticing as the notion may be to some radical feminists, we simply cannot re-engineer the male brain. From a teacher's perspective, at least, boys and girls are simply different.
Boys can learn
As Gurian says, "You can't treat boys as defective, they are not defective, they are really good learners.
"But they are not going to learn well in the environments that we are putting in front of them." Apart from being hands-on learners, boys tend to have a preference for informational text as opposed to narrative, according to some research.
In fiction, they like text that is funny and they like material with action and description. They also seem to like to solve problems.
So why do we not treat this male brain as a springboard from which we can set the groundwork for a new generation of male scientists, engineers, teachers, journalists and businessmen? As a change from our current one-size-fits-all approach.
Today, in a desperate attempt to address the gender-learning gap, "alternate" boy strategies and "supplementary" reading material are being offered to teachers, to try to re-engage the males in our classrooms.
But as much as I try I cannot help but see the word CHARITY written in big letters in the overriding attitude of everything that has come my way.
We will not get very far if we merely give underachieving boys some alternative, not-intellectually-stimulating material and treat them as academic charity cases.
Instead, there must be genuine recognition and appreciation of boys' different learning styles, regardless of how these styles are viewed by those currently in charge.
A different path
Institutionally, this may yet play out in the new emphasis on skilled-trade education that is sweeping across the country.
In some places, it is being aggressively packaged as one possible solution to help boys succeed better in the educational system.
But we won't get the clientele that can really thrive in this program unless we treat this as a viable and respectable non-university career path, indeed one that could even exceed the material success of many in the university-bound cohort.
In today's economic climate, skilled-trade education, with its focus on hands-on informational and problem-solving skills, should no longer be seen as low-value "compromise" education.
I certainly do not see this when I encounter former students, now working as plumbers or electricians, who are making more money than their university-educated teachers.
So many of them are doing very well in the real world. We just now have to find a way of getting them to thrive in our schools.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
- Wildfires, high winds put northeastern Ontario on alert
- It's going to be a tense weekend in northeastern Ontario where strong, shifting winds have been fuelling a forest fire that has blanketed the Timmins area with smoke and ash. more »
- Labrador fire out of control
- A forest fire continues to burn out of control in Happy Valley-Goose Bay today, according to provincial firefighting officials. more »
- The risks and responsibilities of taking on Mt. Everest

- The deaths of five climbers last weekend on Mt. Everest, with more summits underway this weekend, fuels the debate about the risks and responsibilities of high altitude climbing. more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Canada ending 'Buffalo shuffle' for visas, closing consulate
- The federal government is shutting the Canadian consulate in Buffalo less than two years after costly renovations, while dropping a requirement for visas to be renewed outside the country, CBC News has learned. more »
- Wildfires, high winds put northeastern Ontario on alert
- It's going to be a tense weekend in northeastern Ontario where strong, shifting winds have been fuelling a forest fire that has blanketed the Timmins area with smoke and ash. more »
- Labrador fire out of control
- A forest fire continues to burn out of control in Happy Valley-Goose Bay today, according to provincial firefighting officials. more »
- B.C. premier unhappy with disgraced Mountie's transfer
- B.C. Premier Christy Clark says she is not happy with the RCMP decision to transfer a disgraced Alberta Mountie to the West Coast. more »
The National
The Current
- What does it take to get fired at the RCMP? May. 25, 2012 5:02 PM After a senior Mountie was demoted for disgraceful conduct including sex with subordinates, exposing himself and drinking on the job, some former employees wonder what you have to do to get fired.
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges
- Everest victim's husband says family not seeking government help
- B.C. premier unhappy with disgraced Mountie's transfer
- Canada ending 'Buffalo shuffle' for visas, closing consulate
- What a Greek euro exit could mean for Canada
- The risks and responsibilities of taking on Mt. Everest
- Police probe Halifax homicide after shooting
- Ottawa man in hospital after lightning strike
- RCMP officer charged in fatal crash

