Bill to give Canadian torture victims right to sue
Last Updated: Thursday, November 26, 2009 | 5:23 PM ET
CBC News
Liberal MP Irwin Cotler's private members bill was seconded by a member of each party in the Commons on Thursday (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)New legislation introduced in the House of Commons Thursday would give Canadians tortured abroad a chance to sue the perpetrators — including foreign states and officials — in Canadian civil court.
In the past, attempts by torture victims such as Maher Arar and Houshang Bouzari have failed because Canadian courts have ruled they did not have the right to sue foreign states under the State Immunity Act.
"Our present legislation criminalizes torture, war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide — the most heinous acts known to humankind," said Montreal Liberal MP Irwin Cotler, who tabled the private member's bill. "But Canadian law does not allow a civil remedy for the victims of such horrific acts."
As it stands, a Canadian can sue a foreign government on commercial issues, like a breach of contract. But Canadian victims of torture, crimes against humanity and genocidal governments have no redress.
"It is time to rectify this inversion of rights and remedy, this inversion of law and morality," said Cotler, who served as justice minister in the Liberal government of Paul Martin.
It's a move being welcomed by human-rights activists, who say it is long overdue.
"We need to make sure that as many survivors [as possible] of torture and other atrocities can have some sort of access to some sort of justice, some sort of legal remedies for what happened to them," said Matt Eisenbrandt of the Canadian Centre for International Justice.
Canada introduced its Crimes Against Humanity and War Crimes Act in 2000. Two people have been charged since the law was enacted. One, Rwandan Désiré Munyaneza, was convicted this year of genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes. The second, Rwandan Jacques Mungwarere, was arrested earlier this month in Windsor, Ont., and charged with war crimes related to the 1994 genocide in his country.
Giving victims the ability to sue in civil court would give them another option to pursue their abusers.
"Although we strongly support criminal prosecutions of human-rights abusers who might be in Canada, we know that there are limitations on how much the government can do in terms of its funding and its own resources," Eisenbrandt said.
While private member's bills rarely pass, Cotler said he is hopeful because his bill will be seconded by a member of each party in the House of Commons.
"Torture is always wrong — as are crimes against humanity," NDP foreign affairs critic Paul Dewar, who seconded the bill.
Conservative MP Scott Reid and Bloc Québécois MP and foreign affairs critic Francine Lalonde also supported Cotler's legislation.
Canadians failed in attempts to sue foreign countries
Two well-known attempts by Canadians to sue foreign states have failed because courts in this country ruled they had immunity.
Arar, a Syrian-Canadian engineer, was tortured in a Syrian prison for a year over false allegations of terrorist involvement. A Canadian inquiry ruled he had been tortured and the government awarded Arar a $10.5-million settlement.
But he was not successful in suing the Syrian and Jordanian governments in Canada. Neither was Bouzari, an Iranian-Canadian man who attempted to sue the Iranian government for torture in that country.
Bouzari, who went on to found the Toronto-based International Committee Against Torture, said he hoped the amendment would give torture victims a chance to fight the "ugliest and ancient form of human rights abuse."
"Everybody [that's a victim of torture] is looking for closure, and this will help," Bouzari said.
"If you make it financially difficult for countries to torture people — say a slap to the face costs $10,000 — they won't do it, I can assure you."
With files from the Canadian PressShare Tools
Top News Headlines
- Tories move to curb 'bogus' refugees
- The Conservative government is poised to change the refugee system yet again in an attempt to deter what it considers "bogus" claimants, CBC News has learned. more »
- Children of immigrants challenged at school, home
- By 2016, foreign-born youth and Canadian-born youth from immigrant families will make up a quarter of the country's population, according to predictions by the Canadian Council on Social Development. As their numbers grow, more attention is being paid to their successes and failures. more »
- 2 NDP MPs back final Commons vote to kill gun registry
- Two NDP MPs broke party ranks to vote with the government in the final House of Commons vote on scrapping the long-gun registry. more »
- B.C. house party trial hears from tearful teens
- Two teenagers cried as they testified at the trial of a B.C. woman who was charged after a teen died while her son was hosting a party at her house in 2008. more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Drummond report on Ontario calls for cutbacks
- The Ontario government must curtail its spending with the kind of cuts not seen since the Mike Harris years, according to a report by former TD Bank chief economist Don Drummond. more »
- B.C. house party trial hears from tearful teens
- Two teenagers cried as they testified at the trial of a B.C. woman who was charged after a teen died while her son was hosting a party at her house in 2008. more »
- 2 NDP MPs back final Commons vote to kill gun registry
- Two NDP MPs broke party ranks to vote with the government in the final House of Commons vote on scrapping the long-gun registry. more »
- Children of immigrants challenged at school, home
- By 2016, foreign-born youth and Canadian-born youth from immigrant families will make up a quarter of the country's population, according to predictions by the Canadian Council on Social Development. As their numbers grow, more attention is being paid to their successes and failures. more »
The National
The Current
- Abortion and Conservative Caucus Feb. 15, 2012 3:21 PM The return of a debate that may have lost some of its explosive power, but may still be ready to detonate in Prime Minister Harper's back benches.
- Drummond report on Ontario calls for cutbacks
- Barefoot girl's icy trek not blamed on babysitter
- 2 NDP MPs back final Commons vote to kill gun registry
- Immigrants the proudest Canadians, poll suggests
- Honduras prison fire kills hundreds
- Bodyguard hired for bully victim in Fredericton
- Canadian housing market cools in January
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- Russians' abusive plane tirade to cost them $19K

