Hillier wanted Canadians in safer Kabul: memoir
Last Updated: Monday, October 19, 2009 | 10:38 PM ET
The Canadian Press
Related
Internal Links
Video
- Leslie MacKinnon reports: Hillier wanted Canadians in safer Kabul: memoir (Runs: 2:28)
- Play: QuickTime »
- Play: Real Media »
- Former CBC senior correspondent Brian Stewart discusses Hillier's book (Runs: 2:21)
- Play: Real Media »
- Play: QuickTime »
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Rick Hillier says he argued for Canada to take over responsibility for the reconstruction of the airport in Kabul. (Les Perreaux/Canadian Press) Canada's former top soldier says in his new memoir that he argued for Canadian troops deployed to Afghanistan to be kept in the relative safety of Kabul, and he rebuffs claims he was responsible for getting the country mired in the bloody battlefields of Kandahar.
The decision to send Canadian soldiers to southern Afghanistan was largely made before Rick Hillier became the country's military commander, the former chief of defence staff says in a provocative new memoir, A Soldier First: Bullets, Bureaucrats and the Politics of War, which is now available.
Blunt, hard-hitting and often cheeky, Hillier lays out his side of the story through the tumultuous early years of the war, including his strained relationship with former defence minister Gordon O'Connor and an attempt by Prime Minister Stephen Harper's office to limit his public profile.
But it was the Liberals — both publicly and privately — who've tried to shift the blame onto Hillier for getting the country into the bloody, bitter guerrilla war in the south that has claimed the lives of 131 soldiers. One diplomat and two aid workers have also been killed.
"It had already been largely decided that the Canadian presence in Afghanistan was shifting to the southern half of the country," Hillier writes about his return to Ottawa in the fall of 2004 after a stint as NATO commander in Kabul.
"Even before I returned from commanding [the International Security Assistance Force], NATO had announced its intentions to expand the ISAF mission beyond Kabul in 2006, and planning was already well on its way for a move into Kandahar province by the time I landed back in Canada that fall."
In a book written two years ago, former Liberal staffer Eugene Lang and academic Janice Gross Stein argued Hillier persuaded former prime minister Paul Martin to take Canadians into the heartland of the Taliban.
But Hillier says the decision to set up a provincial base in Kandahar was made before his time, and that he had argued within National Defence for Canada to take over responsibility for the reconstruction of the airport in Kabul, a much more benign assignment.
"Nobody in Ottawa seemed interested, so the idea died," he writes in the 498-page memoir.
"The government had already signalled its intent to go into Kandahar province, and the Department of Foreign Affairs, CIDA and National Defence were well into their planning of that mission by the time I came back to work at [Defence headquarters] after my time as ISAF commander."
And with the decision made, Hillier said, he did argue forcefully — as a responsible soldier — for a battle group to back up the provincial reconstruction base that the Liberals had agreed to establish.
"If the security situation in Kandahar became dire, as indeed it did soon after our arrival, those [provincial reconstruction] soldiers would be stuck out in vulnerable positions with no easy way to ensure their security or rescue them from the extreme risk they would face every day," he writes.
Clashes with Liberals
In vintage Hillier style, the book brims with praise for members of the Forces and is sprinkled with anecdotes about his family and early life. But it is his political and bureaucratic battles that make the most engaging reading.
Hillier clashed publicly with the Liberals over his description of the budget-cutting Chrétien years in the 1990s as a "decade of darkness" for the Canadian military.
The party's defence critic at the time, Denis Coderre, painted the general as a Conservative stooge, a response Hillier characterized in the book as "dumber than dirt."
Despite the seeming bad blood, the Liberals tried to persuade him to run for them soon after his retirement in mid-2008. And Hillier himself gushes in the book about his respect and personal rapport with Martin and former defence minister Bill Graham.
His relationship with Harper was cooler and more business-like. Hillier describes the prime minister as someone who was sharp, asked good questions and above all was committed to the military.
At times, Hillier sneers at the whirlwind of Ottawa media speculation that accompanied some of his public statements and his relationship with those in power, including O'Connor, who was his first Conservative boss and a former brigadier-general.
Clashes with defence minister
While he was happy to have a minister who already knew the "ABCs of defence," Hillier was frustrated by O'Connor's tendency to go around him for advice. O'Connor would "sometimes meddle in the day-to-day details" of the department.
"Gord constantly reached out to information from generals or colonels in the army, navy or the air force, or would go directly to a colonel running a base with a question," Hillier's memoir says.
"It seemed to me he was asking the advice of the lower ranks of the Canadian Forces in order to get the answer he wanted, not the answer I would necessarily have given him.… He preferred to hear advice that he liked, that was in line with his own views."
They disagreed, too, over the level of funding for the military and what big-ticket purchases could be made and when.
Hillier also describes a closed-door meeting, soon after the Conservatives were elected in 2006, at which O'Connor passed along a request — likely from the PMO — that they "see less" of him in public.
It was a request he says he ignored.
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- U.S. bank reforms could hurt Canadians, Flaherty fears
- Canada's finance minister and the governor of the Bank of Canada have formally complained to their American counterparts that proposed banking reforms could harm Canadian banks, business, investors and the government itself. more »
- CBC digital music service launches today

- CBC is diving into the world of online music with the goal of providing listeners access to their favourite tunes, and a way to discover new artists and connect with fellow music fans. more »
- Whitney Houston was found unconscious underwater, police say
- Whitney Houston was underwater and apparently unconscious in a bathtub at the Beverly Hilton Hotel when found, Beverly Hills police said Monday. more »
- Organ donation rates go flat
- Organ donation rates have stagnated in Canada since 2006, according to a new report. more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- 'Disgusting' court backlog may free hit and run accused
- The family of a young mother killed in a hit and run is outraged that the case against the alleged driver is among thousands in B.C. at risk of being thrown out because of a huge court backlog. more »
- Manitoba wants ER death lawsuit thrown out
- The Manitoba government is making a court bid Monday to quash a lawsuit by the family of Brian Sinclair, a homeless man who died after waiting 34 hours in a hospital emergency room in 2008. more »
- Organ donation rates go flat
- Organ donation rates have stagnated in Canada since 2006, according to a new report. more »
- Accused in Quebec triple murder appears in court
- A Quebec judge has ordered a 35-year-old man accused of killing his mother and two nieces in Saint-Romain, Que., to undergo a psychiatric evaluation. more »
On Tonight's National
Top stories
Shafia Jury Deliberations
- Dan Halton
- The jury in the Shafia murder trial begun deliberations today. Mohammad Shafia, his wife and his son are accused of killing four of their family members. They are charged with four counts of first-degree murder and have all pleaded not guilty to the charge.
Watch the Best of the Show
- Get Connected
- Syria cracks down on protesters, one day before an Arab League delegation arrives.
Stay Connected
- Carolyn Dunn
- An English soccer captain is facing racial abuse charges after an on-field exchange with another player.
The Current
- Panda Diplomacy Feb. 13, 2012 1:59 PM Zoos in Canada are getting ready to welcome two giant pandas despite concerns about whether this will actually generate revenue and awareness about conservation.
- 'Disgusting' court backlog may free hit and run accused
- Adele wins best album, best record Grammys
- Whitney Houston autopsy results withheld
- Whitney Houston death shows no signs of trauma
- Ice road closed after 2 incidents
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- CBC digital music service launches today
- Manitoba wants ER death lawsuit thrown out
- Greece cleans up after anti-austerity riots

