Twenty years on
Don Murray
Assessing the fallout from Tiananmen
Last Updated: Thursday, June 4, 2009 | 7:42 PM ET
By Don Murray, special to CBC News
Related
Don Murray
Biography

During his 30 years at CBC, Don Murray filed hundreds of reports in French and English from China, Europe, the Middle East and the Soviet Union. He is currently based in London. He wrote A Democracy of Despots, documenting the collapse and rebirth of Russia. From Berlin, he reported the Bosnia peace agreement talks and, based in London, the death of Diana and Northern Ireland peace talks. He authored Family Wars for the International Journal, paralleling Northern Ireland and Bosnia. He has covered wars in Kosovo, Afghanistan and Iraq.
The bloody scars of the past have been airbrushed out of the photo and those who try to draw attention to that cleansing of the historical record have been hustled away.
Consider the case of Liu Xiaobo, one of the leaders of the Tiananmen protests in 1989. I met him a year ago, just after the 19th anniversary of the crackdown.
Liu hadn't been available in the run-up to the day. Chinese security police had locked him in his apartment and cut him off from the rest of the world. When they did eventually let him out, they drove him to his meetings.
Some obvious symbolism as cannons fire a salute in Tiananmen Square on June 3, 2009, the day before the 20th anniversary of the bloody crackdown in 1989. Security was heavy in the square and authorities blocked certain social networking websites. (Elizabeth Dalziel/Associated Press) Liu was sardonic about his treatment.
As a result of his role at Tiananmen, he had been tried for counter-revolutionary activity and jailed three times.
Still, he said, last summer as the Beijing Olympics beckoned, things were improving.
"When I was arrested in 1996, they ransacked my apartment and left a mess. When I was arrested a decade later they came with white gloves, and when they left, they put things back."
That was then
There will be no interviews with Liu this year, however. In December 2008, he led a group of intellectuals in drawing up and publishing Charter 08, a petition calling for respect for human rights, representative government, an independent judiciary and a federal system for China.
The petition was an updated, condensed call for democracy that was last heard loudly in public in Tiananmen Square in 1989.
Right after the publication of Charter 08, Liu was promptly arrested and taken away. His wife has seen him just once since then. The authorities won't say where he's being held.
Charter 08 was consciously modelled on Charter 77, the Czech call for freedom and human rights drawn up by playwright and dissident Vaclav Havel in 1977 when the Communists ruled Eastern Europe.
It also echoed the call for a "fifth modernization" during the Democracy Wall period in Beijing in 1979. Its author, Wei Jingsheng, was arrested and held in prison for almost 18 years.
The previous year, 1978, Deng Xiaoping came to power, calling for the "four modernizations" to transform a socialist peasant society into an economic power. The "fifth modernization" demanded by Wei was human rights.
Count to four
After 1979, and even more so after 1989, the unwritten rule in China was "count to four and forget five." Transformation would take time.
The Beijing I saw in 1989 during the Tiananmen demonstrations was visibly similar to the capital I worked in the early 1980s — a city of bicycles, dowdy clothes, few gadgets and fewer foreigners.
Beijing National Stadium, known as the Bird's Nest, and the Beijing Olympic Games' closing ceremonies both charmed the world in the summer of 2008. (Associated Press) The military crackdown that June was followed by a greater loosening of economic control. An unspoken quid pro quo. As a result, the Beijing of today is a world away, a capital with all the trappings of a modern consumer city.
An average economic growth rate of eight per cent per year over 30 years can do that.
That astonishing development has lifted hundreds of millions of Chinese out of the grinding poverty of peasant farming, though at the cost of punishing hours of factory work for low wages.
The export-driven boom, coupled with a careful husbanding of the mountains of cash that flowed in, means that China today has foreign currency reserves of more than $2 trillion.
In recent years, the Chinese have been turning that cash into economic and political clout.
For example, they have become the chief bankers of a new East Asian version of the International Monetary Fund, putting more than $40 billion into it.
They have pressured trading partners like Indonesia and Argentina into doing business directly in renminbi, the Chinese currency, rather than in U.S. dollars.
In Africa their influence is expanding as fast as their investments. In 2007, the Chinese invested almost $5 billion in infrastructure in Africa. That's more than the total of the G8 countries combined.
Chinese companies paved or re-paved 80 per cent of the roads in Rwanda and they are building railways in Nigeria and military bases in Ethiopia. Chinese companies own one of Zambia's largest copper mines and run a huge timber operation in Equatorial Guinea.
All this at a time when countries like Canada are turning away from that continent.
Day of reckoning
The Tiananmen protests in 1989 broke out just before then Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev was to make a state visit to China.
To the acute embarrassment of Chinese leaders, he actually saw the students in the square and, having just lived through enormous street demonstrations in Moscow, he counselled moderation and more openness to his Communist colleagues.
Nearly 3,000 delegates to the National People's Congress sing the national anthem on March 2009. Outside the Great Hall, Tiananmen Square was closed to tourists and ordinary Chinese. (Elizabeth Dalziel/Associated Press) At least one senior Chinese leader, Zhao Ziyang, agreed with this advice, but was overruled. The bloody crackdown took place and Zhao was removed and put under house arrest until he died 16 years later.
Two years after Tiananmen, the Soviet Union collapsed and I listened to a KGB colonel rail against Gorbachev for not following the path of Deng Xiaoping — count to four and forget five.
The irony is that now, with a former KGB officer, Vladimir Putin, in charge for the past nine years, Russia has been trying to do just that.
In China, more than 8,000 people have signed Charter 08, a respectable number at first glance, but pitifully small in a country of 1.3 billion people.
Most people have never heard of Charter 08 or Liu Xiaobo. Airbrushing the photo has worked. Young people in China today have a hazy understanding at best of the Tiananmen protests.
Getting rich is glorious, decreed Deng, and that is still the password embraced by the large majority.
For their pains, Liu Xiaobo and Charter 08 signers are offered foreign consolation prizes: the PEN American Centre award for Liu and a human rights award in Prague for Charter 08.
For the Prague ceremony, Vaclav Havel wrote a letter. The message from the Charter 77 dissident who went on to become his country's president was sobering:
"One may never reckon with success, one may never reckon with the situation changing tomorrow, the day after tomorrow, or in 10 years. Perhaps it will not. If that is what you are reckoning with, you will not get very far.
"However, in our experience," Havel went on, "not reckoning with that did pay in the end; we found that it was possible to change the situation after all, and those who were mocked as being Don Quixotes, whose efforts were never going to come to anything, may in the end and to general astonishment get their way."
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Adele wins best album, best record Grammys
- Adele capped off a "life-changing" year by winning six Grammys Sunday night, including record of the year and album of the year for 21 more »
- Hit and run victim's family fears accused will walk
- The family of a young mother killed in a hit and run is outraged that the case against the alleged driver is among thousands in B.C. at risk of being thrown out because of a huge court backlog. more »
- CBC launches digital music service
- CBC is diving into the world of online music with the goal of providing listeners access to their favourite tunes and a way to discover new artists and connect with fellow music fans. more »
- Whitney Houston death shows no signs of trauma
- Whitney Houston's life of glorious song and unnerving self-destruction apparently ended on Grammy weekend, but it could be weeks before investigators know exactly why she died. more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Manitoba wants ER death lawsuit thrown out
- The Manitoba government is making a court bid Monday to quash a lawsuit by the family of Brian Sinclair, a homeless man who died after waiting 34 hours in a hospital emergency room in 2008. more »
- Still no power for 1,500 in Maritimes
- Parts of eastern P.E.I. and the Tracadie-Sheila area of New Brunswick still have no electricity Monday morning following a storm Saturday. more »
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- A small Quebec town is in mourning Sunday after a Quebec man was charged with killing his nieces and his mother, who were found dead in their family home. more »
- Doors blocked in fatal Manitoba trailer blaze
- Four men who died in a residential trailer fire in Selkirk, Man., may not have been able to escape because both of the home's exits were blocked, says a local fire official. more »
On Tonight's National
Top stories
Shafia Jury Deliberations
- Dan Halton
- The jury in the Shafia murder trial begun deliberations today. Mohammad Shafia, his wife and his son are accused of killing four of their family members. They are charged with four counts of first-degree murder and have all pleaded not guilty to the charge.
Watch the Best of the Show
- Get Connected
- Syria cracks down on protesters, one day before an Arab League delegation arrives.
Stay Connected
- Carolyn Dunn
- An English soccer captain is facing racial abuse charges after an on-field exchange with another player.
The Current
- Panda Diplomacy Feb. 10, 2012 2:43 PM Zoos in Canada are getting ready to welcome two giant pandas despite concerns about whether this will actually generate revenue and awareness about conservation.
- Adele wins best album, best record Grammys
- Whitney Houston autopsy results withheld
- Hit and run victim's family fears accused will walk
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- Pop queen Whitney Houston dies at 48
- Manitoba man dies after falling off moving SUV
- 2 vehicles sink on river highway
- Doors blocked in fatal Manitoba trailer blaze
- Greece passes new austerity deal amid rioting


