Introduce more private medicine, says doctor who challenged Quebec ban
Last Updated: Tuesday, March 21, 2006 | 3:55 PM ET
CBC News
HEALTH CARE BEFORE THE SUPREME COURT
The question: Is it unconstitutional to outlaw private health care for patients who can pay?
The argument: Canadians should have the right to buy private insurance and pay for private care rather than waiting in the public system.
The ruling: The Quebec government cannot prevent people from paying for private insurance for procedures covered under medicare. The ruling has no immediate impact outside Quebec.
The patient: George Zeliotis, 73, from Montreal. He waited almost a year for hip surgery in the mid-'90s.
The doctor: Dr. Jacques Chaoulli tried and failed to set up a private hospital in Quebec. The Supreme Court decided to hear his and Zeliotis's cases together.
Earlier rulings: In Quebec, lower courts have ruled that the collective right to a publicly funded system is more important than individual rights.
The warnings: Ottawa advised against meddling with "one of Canada's finest achievements." Quebec warned of a brain drain to private health care.
» The Supreme Court decision
The argument: Canadians should have the right to buy private insurance and pay for private care rather than waiting in the public system.
The ruling: The Quebec government cannot prevent people from paying for private insurance for procedures covered under medicare. The ruling has no immediate impact outside Quebec.
The patient: George Zeliotis, 73, from Montreal. He waited almost a year for hip surgery in the mid-'90s.
The doctor: Dr. Jacques Chaoulli tried and failed to set up a private hospital in Quebec. The Supreme Court decided to hear his and Zeliotis's cases together.
Earlier rulings: In Quebec, lower courts have ruled that the collective right to a publicly funded system is more important than individual rights.
The warnings: Ottawa advised against meddling with "one of Canada's finest achievements." Quebec warned of a brain drain to private health care.
» The Supreme Court decision
The doctor who took the Quebec government to the Supreme Court of Canada, causing it to change its policy on wait times and private health insurance, wants to see more privatization.
In his Supreme Court case, Dr. Jacques Chaoulli argued "patients will continue to suffer and die" because of waiting lists.
- INDEPTH: Public vs. private health care
Last year, the high court ruled in response that some wait times for medical procedures in the province were unconstitutional.
Dr. Jacques Chaoulli. (file photo)
- FROM FEB. 16, 2006: Private health care has role in Quebec, says Charest
On Tuesday, Chaoulli called the move a good first step, while urging the Quebec government to go further with privatization.
"I would like that Quebecers have the best value for the public money they spend," Chaoulli said.
He said the best way would be to allow more private medicine, including:
- Allowing doctors to work in both the public and private systems, such as at a public hospital and a private clinic, rather than one or the other.
- Privatizing medical schools and hospitals.
- Loosening legal restrictions that limit private insurance.
The ideas were outlined in a 40-page document Chaoulli submitted to a provincial government commission looking into health reforms.
Share Tools
Big Box Advertisement
Top News Headlines
- Markets gain after Greece approves austerity plan
- World stock markets rise after Greece's parliament approves a new set of austerity measures that were required by international lenders in exchange for an emergency bailout. more »
- Hit and run victim's family fears accused will walk
- The family of a young mother killed in a hit and run is outraged that the case against the alleged driver is among thousands in B.C. at risk of being thrown out because of a huge court backlog. more »
- CBC launches digital music service
- CBC is diving into the world of online music with the goal of providing listeners access to their favourite tunes and a way to discover new artists and connect with fellow music fans. more »
- Neil Macdonald: The death penalty debate America isn't having
- Texas's death row archive is a troubling document, not the least for what it doesn't say about those who may be wrongfully convicted, Neil Macdonald writes. more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Hit and run victim's family fears accused will walk
- The family of a young mother killed in a hit and run is outraged that the case against the alleged driver is among thousands in B.C. at risk of being thrown out because of a huge court backlog. more »
- Doors blocked in fatal Manitoba trailer blaze
- Four men who died in a residential trailer fire in Selkirk, Man., may not have been able to escape because both of the home's exits were blocked, says a local fire official. more »
- NDP leadership hopefuls face off in Quebec City
- Federal NDP leadership candidates argued over Canada's global standing, climate change and language during a French-only debate in Quebec City on Sunday. more »
- Manitoba man dies after falling off moving SUV
- A 23-year-old man from Elie, Man., has died from injuries he sustained after falling off the outside of a vehicle as it was driving down a highway, according to RCMP. more »
On Tonight's National
Top stories
Shafia Jury Deliberations
- Dan Halton
- The jury in the Shafia murder trial begun deliberations today. Mohammad Shafia, his wife and his son are accused of killing four of their family members. They are charged with four counts of first-degree murder and have all pleaded not guilty to the charge.
Watch the Best of the Show
- Get Connected
- Syria cracks down on protesters, one day before an Arab League delegation arrives.
Stay Connected
- Carolyn Dunn
- An English soccer captain is facing racial abuse charges after an on-field exchange with another player.
The Current
- Panda Diplomacy Feb. 10, 2012 2:43 PM Zoos in Canada are getting ready to welcome two giant pandas despite concerns about whether this will actually generate revenue and awareness about conservation.
- Adele wins best album, best record Grammys
- Houston autopsy results withheld by police
- Quebec town 'heartbroken' after killing of woman, sisters
- Pop queen Whitney Houston dies at 48
- Greece passes new austerity deal amid rioting
- Northern lights viewed from space
- Manitoba man dies after falling off moving SUV
- Doors blocked in fatal Manitoba trailer blaze
- Former Stanley Park petting zoo goats feared slaughtered
Big Box Advertisement
