Manitoba to review child-welfare agencies
Last Updated: Tuesday, March 21, 2006 | 4:42 AM ET
CBC News
Family Service Minister Christine Melnick said the external review will examine the protocol surrounding the opening and closing of cases, the transfer of cases between various child-welfare authorities and the caseloads managed by front-line social workers.
Melnick said she hopes the review process will improve services for children in care and provide support for social workers who are on the front lines.
"Manitobans want to know the answers," she said. "I want to know the answers. We will find out the answers, and we will make the changes to improve the child and family services system for all of our children."
The external review will be carried out by Manitoba ombudsman Irene Hamilton, children's advocate Billie Schibler and an Ontario child and family services director.
The internal review under the Child and Family Services Act will examine financial files and accountability, review file-management practices and interview agency staff, management, clients and community members.
The external review is scheduled to have a draft completed by the end of June, with a final report due by September.
The opposition Conservatives also want a full public inquiry into child care, so clients and workers can speak freely about problems they see in the system. They have also called for Melnick's resignation.
Second Fisher River girl died in care
Meanwhile, the father of another child on the Fisher River First Nation has come forward with a troubling story of his daughter's death in the care of child-welfare authorities.
Fisher River resident Lawrence Traverse said he believes his two-year-old daughter, Heaven, was abused while in the care of the child-welfare system.
Traverse told CBC News he saw unexplained bruises on Heaven on several occasions while she was in the care of a foster family. He said he raised concerns about his daughter's care with child-welfare authorities.
Heaven died in a Winnipeg hospital in January 2005. Traverse said she appeared to have several bruises on her body, including a large welt on her head. He said doctors told him Heaven died as a result of head trauma.
RCMP investigators say Heaven's death is still being investigated. No charges have been laid.
Traverse's case is the second tragic story in recent weeks about children in care on the Fisher River First Nation. Last week, RCMP charged Samantha Dawn Kematch, 24 and her common-law husband, Karl Wesley McKay, with first-degree murder in the death of the Kematch's five-year-old daughter, Phoenix Victoria Sinclair.
- FROM MARCH 16, 2006: Charges upgraded in case of missing girl
Phoenix had been missing for nine months, although her case only came to light recently. Court documents indicate police believe the little girl was abused, confined and eventually killed in June 2005. Her body has not been found.
Phoenix was in and out of the child welfare system for most of her life. Her case had been closed by social workers before her death.
Lack of resources: former social worker
A former social worker said a lack of resources and foster families may have contributed to the deaths of the two little girls on the Fisher River First Nation.
Janet Brady, a former social worker who currently teaches at the University of Manitoba's faculty of social work in Thompson, said most groups who work with endangered children are facing a lack of resources.
"I think the problem is now with agencies having enough placement resources for children," Brady told CBC News on Monday. "Do they have enough foster homes? What is the quality of those foster homes that they do have, and is there training going on for those foster parents?"
Brady believes there should be a public inquiry into the deaths of Phoenix Sinclair and Heaven Traverse, but she's not confident it would result in changes, noting inquiries have been held on similar cases in the past.
"It's very sad when I hear this over and over and over again," she said. " I thought we've done this before. Have we not learned from our mistakes? We've had internal reviews of the system and recommendations have been made, so it kind of begs the question, how come things are not getting any better?"
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Botox injected by unlicensed practitioners
- Some Vancouver-area medical spas are ignoring Health Canada regulations that Botox be prescribed and injected by a physician, a CBC News investigation has revealed. more »
- NDP MPs urged to scrap gun registry in final vote
- Public Safety Minister Vic Toews urges opposition MPs to break party ranks and side with the government during tonight's vote on scrapping the long-gun registry. more »
- 6 ways Greece can bounce back
- Although Greece's economic future seems dire, a number of the country's sectors show promise, according to observers. more »
- Are you a good Canadian citizen? Compare yourself
- Waving the Canadian flag is an easy act of patriotism. But beyond that what are hallmarks of being Canadian? more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Online privacy erosion dismays critics
- Government and law enforcement access to people's electronic communications is the norm in dictatorships around the world, but the same intrusion appears to be creeping into North America, say opponents of a new online surveillance bill tabled in the House Tuesday. more »
- Immigrants the proudest Canadians, poll suggests
- Most Canadians feel immigrants are just as likely to be good Canadian citizens as people who were born here and don't object to them keeping their original citizenship, according to a recent Environics survey. more »
- Barefoot Newfoundland girl survives icy ordeal
- A young girl wearing no footwear and only a light dress travelled over snow and ice on Tuesday, after leaving her babysitter's home without being noticed. more »
- Toronto NBA fans experience 'Lin-sanity'
- Members of Toronto's Asian community who went to the Air Canada Centre on Tuesday to cheer on New York Knicks' point guard Jeremy Lin — rather than the hometown Raptors — saw first-hand that so-called Lin-sanity is more than just hype. more »
- Drummond report on Ontario spending due today
- Former TD Bank chief economist Don Drummond will release his long-awaited report on Wednesday that outlines his suggestions for ways the Ontario government can pare back spending. more »
On Tonight's National
Top stories
Shafia Jury Deliberations
- Dan Halton
- The jury in the Shafia murder trial begun deliberations today. Mohammad Shafia, his wife and his son are accused of killing four of their family members. They are charged with four counts of first-degree murder and have all pleaded not guilty to the charge.
Watch the Best of the Show
- Get Connected
- Syria cracks down on protesters, one day before an Arab League delegation arrives.
Stay Connected
- Carolyn Dunn
- An English soccer captain is facing racial abuse charges after an on-field exchange with another player.
The Current
- An Exploration of Dating Online Feb. 14, 2012 4:13 PM Internet dating is a popular way to meet people, but some researchers question whether compatibility is something that can be determined online.
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- Immigrants the proudest Canadians, poll suggests
- Barefoot Newfoundland girl survives icy ordeal
- Botox injected by unlicensed practitioners
- Trudeau says sovereignty less of a bogeyman now
- Online privacy erosion dismays critics
- Toronto NBA fans experience 'Lin-sanity'
- Russians in abusive plane tirade to be sentenced
- Honduras prison fire kills hundreds

