Logging fight not over, native leaders say
Last Updated: Wednesday, July 20, 2005 | 9:48 PM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
Audio
-
Louise Elliott reports for CBC Radio
(Runs: 2:43)
play: RealMedia »
Video
- Heather Robinson reports for CBC-TV (Runs: 2:28)
play: RealMedia »
play: RealVideo »
play: QuickTime »
"It wasn't the outcome we were expecting, but it's not the end of the battle," said Reg Maloney, former chief of the Indian Brook First Nation in Nova Scotia.
In a pair of unanimous decisions, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled that aboriginals in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia do not have a treaty claim to log commercially on Crown lands without a permit, as two Mi'kmaq men charged with illegal logging had claimed.
"I find that I'm very disappointed in the way the Supreme Court has put the burden of proof on us to assert our rights," Maloney said. "I think the burden is an impossible burden.
Chief Dwight Dorey, national chief of the Congress of Aboriginal Peoples.
"We don't have the history or the evidence that is needed in order put a case forward. Unless that changes, it's going to be very difficult for First Nations people to make progress with their rights in this country."
The Supreme Court found that treaties signed in 1760-61 only granted the Mi'kmaq the right to continue trade in items traditionally traded at that time.
The justices said there was no evidence to prove the Mi'kmaq were logging 250 years ago when they signed the treaties with the Crown.
"In order to be protected under those treaties, trade in forest products must be the modern equivalent or a logical evolution of Mi'kmaq use of forest products at the time the treaties were signed," the court wrote.
"Logging is not a logical evolution of the activities traditionally engaged in by Mi'kmaq at the time the treaties were entered into."
The justices also ruled that aboriginals in New Brunswick did not have title to the lands they were trying to log.
'Evidence wasn't there'; natives will keep pressing
If Canada's top court had ruled in favour of native logging rights, the decision could have had a major impact on Atlantic Canada's multibillion-dollar forestry industry.
Private forestry companies that lease Crown lands and employ thousands of people in the region were worried that granting these rights would create chaos in the industry.
But aboriginal leaders had hoped a ruling in their favour would lessen their economic dependence on government and change their lives overnight.
"The court has stated there may be other times and other cases where aboriginal treaty rights will still be upheld, just not in this particular case. The evidence wasn't there," said Chief Dwight Dorey, national chief of the Congress of Aboriginal Peoples.
"So it's important for us to continue to press the government" to resolve outstanding issues outside the court, he said.
"We do believe we have aboriginal title. This case simply did not have the proper facts to prove it," said George Ginnish, chief of the Eel Ground First Nation in the Miramichi area of New Brunswick.
"As we move ahead, we will take this decision [and] it will guide us on how we choose to proceed."
Cases involved members of 2 First Nations
The first of the two cases before the high court dated back to 1998, when Joshua Bernard of the New Brunswick Eel Ground First Nation was arrested for taking native-harvested logs to a sawmill. He was charged with illegal possession.
In the second case, involving Stephen Marshall of the Millbrook First Nation, 34 Mi'kmaq loggers were charged with illegally logging in Nova Scotia.
The two men argued they had the right to earn a living by logging on Crown lands because of the treaties signed in 1760-1761.
Ottawa and the provinces argued that aboriginals were not conducting commercial logging as it exists today when the treaties were signed.
"Obviously, I'm very disappointed in the outcome," said Bernard.
"I guess the best way to describe how I feel is [that] despite of what was said or what ruling came down, I still feel I have the right to harvest Crown timber.
"I don't know what the next steps I'm going to take are or where to head from here."
The forestry industry creates 19,000 jobs in New Brunswick and 11,000 in Nova Scotia.
New Brunswick's government owns 50 per cent of the province's land base, while Nova Scotia owns about 25 per cent.
Mitch Taylor, representing the federal justice department, said the Wednesday's ruling won't affect how the government handles other negotiations.
"The federal government will continue to look at the big picture and to bring to the negotiations a fair and balanced approach," he said. "It won't be hard-nosed. There are important questions, there are legitimate claims."
Share Tools
Top News Headlines
- Everest victim's husband says family not seeking government help
- The husband of a Toronto woman who died trying to climb Mt. Everest on Saturday says his family is not seeking government help to cover the cost of bringing his wife's body home. more »
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped
- The federal government is scrapping two review boards used by people appealing decisions made about their employment insurance. more »
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Raw stories about bullying emerged when a video booth was set up inside a Quebec high school. more »
- Serial carjacker gets life term for fatal crash
- An Ontario judge was moved to tears while delivering a life prison sentence to a serial carjacker who killed a woman and injured five others after driving a stolen van into her car during a 2010 police chase. more »
Latest Canada News Headlines
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
- Forest fires still burning near Timmins, Ont.
- A new forest fire is burning north of Highway 101 near Timmins, Ont., creating a new challenge for firefighters who have been working to contain another fire in the area. more »
- RCMP to close labs in Halifax, Winnipeg, Regina
- The RCMP is closing forensic laboratories in Halifax, Winnipeg and Regina and consolidating them with three others in a move the force says will lead to faster, more efficient service. more »
- Small plane crashes on lake near Cochrane, Ont.
- The Transportation Safety Board has dispatched a team to investigate after an Air Cochrane plane crashed on Lillabelle Lake just north of Cochrane, Ont. Friday afternoon. more »
The National
The Current
- What does it take to get fired at the RCMP? May. 25, 2012 5:02 PM After a senior Mountie was demoted for disgraceful conduct including sex with subordinates, exposing himself and drinking on the job, some former employees wonder what you have to do to get fired.
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges
- Everest victim's husband says family not seeking government help
- Reclaiming the dead on Mt. Everest
- Employment Insurance review boards to be scrapped
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Canada ending 'Buffalo shuffle' for visas, closing consulate
- Brave cat makes epic leap of faith
- What a Greek euro exit could mean for Canada
- Double-lung recipient dances on Ellen show



