Wal-Mart baby abandonment case heard at Supreme Court
Mother gave birth in May 2007 in Prince Albert, Sask., Wal-Mart washroom and left the store
CBC News
Posted: Oct 11, 2012 8:31 AM CST
Last Updated: Oct 11, 2012 8:30 AM CST
The Supreme Court of Canada heard arguments today in the case of the northern Saskatchewan woman found not guilty of child abandonment after leaving her newborn baby in a Wal-Mart toilet.
After hearing from the Crown and the woman's lawyer for several hours Thursday morning, the court adjourned its decision.
The Crown appealed to the country's top court after the Saskatchewan Court of Queen's Bench acquitted the woman — whose name is covered by a publication ban and has been identified as A.D.H. — and the province's Court of Appeal upheld that decision.
On May 21, 2007, the then-20-year-old A.D.H. gave birth in a washroom stall at a Prince Albert Wal-Mart and left the store.
Minutes later, shoppers found the baby boy in a toilet. The baby was purple and did not appear to be breathing at first, but thanks to quick action by the store manager and an ambulance crew, he was revived.
Later, A.D.H., was charged with child abandonment. The 2009 trial unveiled disturbing details of the day in question, but also dealt with whether the mother had a guilty mind, was in shock, or knew what she had done when she walked out of the store.
The defence argued she didn't know she was pregnant before she gave birth and afterward thought the baby was dead.
The trial judge ruled that A.D.H., didn't "wilfully" abandon her child and therefore wasn't guilty.
When the Crown appealed to Saskatchewan's highest court, the appeal court disagreed with some of with the trial judge's reasoning but upheld the acquittal, saying A.D.H., was not guilty because even if she had her facts wrong, she had an honest belief the baby wasn't alive.
The Supreme Court can agree with the lower courts, or overturn the acquittal and find her guilty. Another option, which the Crown is requesting, is to order a new trial.
Eugene Meehan, an Ottawa lawyer who tracks Supreme Court cases, says the outcome will impact how judges weigh what an accused was thinking at the time of an offence.
"Is she expected to act the way a reasonable person would act in these circumstances?" he asked. "Or, is the real question, 'What was in her mind as an individual at that point in time?'"
Court heard the baby, whose identity is covered by a publication ban, was hospitalized for a while but later regained his health. He was placed with a family member and A.D.H. was allowed access.
The case was closely followed by people in Saskatchewan. It sparked a debate about whether a "safe harbour" policy was needed to allow abandoned babies to be turned over to the authorities without fear of criminal charges.
Share Tools
Latest Saskatchewan News Headlines
- Saskatchewan being allowed 450 more immigrants annually
- Saskatchewan will be allowed to welcome 450 more immigrants every year under the provincial nominee program, according to a new deal with Ottawa. more »
- Train carrying crude oil derails east of Saskatoon
- Emergency crews have now contained crude oil leaking from a damaged rail car, according to a CP Rail spokesperson. The derailment happened this morning about 150 kilometres east of Saskatoon. more »
- 'Very upset' Harper wants fast Senate spending reform
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper told the Conservative caucus this morning that he's "upset" about the recent conduct of some senators and his own office, and he wants Senate spending rules tightened quickly. more »
- Tornado safety tips
- Tornadoes are one of nature's most powerful and destructive forces. These are some tips on how to prepare for a tornado and what to do if you're caught in a twister's path. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- 'Very upset' Harper wants fast Senate spending reform
- Prime Minister Stephen Harper told the Conservative caucus this morning that he's "upset" about the recent conduct of some senators and his own office, and he wants Senate spending rules tightened quickly. more »
- Children driven around too much, Canadian report suggests
- Fewer Canadian kids are commuting by walking or biking as a new report reveals a marked decline among young people using active modes of transportation. more »
- Keith Boag: Have you heard about the murderous abortion doctor?
- The gruesome trial and murder conviction of Philadelphia abortion provider Dr. Kermit Gosnell is unlikely to change American abortion law, Keith Boag writes. But it has U.S. journalists questioning their priorities and how they cover such a sensitive issue. more »
- Oklahoma tornado death count not firm, governor says
- The number of deaths caused by the Oklahoma tornado may yet rise, Gov. Mary Fallin indicates, saying there have been 237 injuries reported in the aftermath of the storm 16 kilometres south of Oklahoma City. more »
- Crowd helps out Saskatoon singer who forgets U.S. anthem
- Police ask for help finding Biggar, Sask. man
- Controversy swirls around chief who sexually assaulted teen
- Saskatoon couple hailed as heroes for saving woman's life
- Train carrying crude oil derails east of Saskatoon
- 'Very upset' Harper wants fast Senate spending reform
- Athlete hopes to race her way to Paralympic Games
- 10 years since mad cow linked to Saskatchewan farm
- Articling law students caught plagiarizing

