Sask. gets a D+ from health groups for 'listless' effort to reduce smoking

Health advocates from the Lung Association, Canadian Cancer Society and Heart and Stroke foundation released a report card on the provincial government's tobacco policies.

Saskatchewan has the highest youth smoking rate in the country, according to the Canadian Cancer Society

It's not quite a failing grade — but you wouldn't want your teenager to come home with this mark either. 

Canadian health advocates including the Lung Association, Canadian Cancer Society and Heart and Stroke Foundation have given the Saskatchewan government a D+ on its efforts to curb tobacco use. 

"Saskatchewan has the highest youth smoking rate in Canada, which is nearly double the national average," said Donna Pasiechnik of the Canadian Cancer Society, in a release Tuesday. She went on to call the rates unacceptable. 

According to the health groups, the report card and analysis was conducted by an independent tobacco control consultant. It found Saskatchewan was far behind the rest of the country. 

"Other provinces have moved to ban smoking on outdoor playgrounds and parks, sports fields where kids gather. We simply don't believe tobacco should be used in these places where kids play," Pasiechnik said.

The Heart and Stroke foundation says the government has not kept up with new evidence. While the Lung Association is calling for a more aggressive strategy that will reduce the high use of tobacco in the province. The report card calls the government's efforts "listless". 

"We have the smoking rates that are too high. We have public support. We have provinces moving forward on all of these measures. Why are we not?" Pasiechnik said.

The groups say Saskatchewan made around $275 million off of tobacco taxes, but only spent $450,000 on tobacco control.

Here's a look at how the province scored:

  • Control of the sale of tax exempt and discount tobacco: A
  • Public awareness campaigns to counter tobacco promotion and advertising: C
  • Prohibiting smoking in cars when a person under 19 is present: B
  • Supporting communities in their prevention efforts: D
  • Increasing funding in the province's tobacco reduction strategy: D
  • Adopting regulations around e-cigarette: F
  • Banning smoking and water pipes in specific outdoor public places: D
  • Banning the sale of flavoured tobacco: F
  • Reducing where tobacco is sold: D
  • Helping people quit: C


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.