Parents of twins take benefits appeal to top court
Couple challenging decision denying them combined 70-week leave with twins
Posted: Jan 24, 2013 11:56 AM ET
Last Updated: Jan 24, 2013 1:41 PM ET
An Ottawa father says a decision to dismiss his Federal Court appeal, which sought 35 weeks of parental leave for each parent so they could care for their twin girls at the same time, was unfair and he is taking the case to the Supreme Court.Christian Martin and Paula Critchley have been fighting for a double claim of parental leave benefits after having twin girls in 2009. (CBC)
Christian Martin and his wife, Paula Critchley, had each asked to take the full 35 weeks after the births of their daughters, Lucie and Athena, in April 2009.
Martin had argued the Employment Insurance Act was inconsistent and violated the couple's right to equality under Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
Three Federal Court judges, however, ruled against the couple Thursday with the reasons detailed in a 54-page document, which can be seen at the bottom of this story.
'It is unfair and I plan to keep fighting.'—Christian Martin, father of twin girls
The judges ruled the arbitrator’s interpretation of the act was correct, and the family did not have a legitimate argument under the charter.
After the decision was released Thursday, Martin said the court made a "big mistake."
"We lost all our arguments. It isn’t a good day for parents of multiples," he wrote in a statement to CBC News. "It is unfair and I plan to keep fighting."
The lawyer for the couple, Stephen Moreau, said another appeal was officially filed Thursday.
Arbitrator had reversed commission's decision
Normally, under Canadian law, parents may take a total of 35 weeks of parental leave following a birth or adoption while receiving benefits under Canada's employment insurance program, no matter how many children are born to or adopted by the parents at the same time.
But Martin and Critchley had argued since parents of children born a year apart are entitled to two 35-week benefit periods, parents of twins should receive the same amount of time.
In September 2009, a board of referees of the Canada Employment Insurance Commission awarded the couple 35 weeks each — one for each child.
But in May 2011, an arbitrator overturned that decision, saying the Employment Insurance Act is clear benefits were limited to 35 weeks for "the care of one or more new-born or adopted children as a result of a single pregnancy or placement."
A New Democrat MP has tabled a private member’s bill pushing for more leave for parents of multiple birth babies.
The bill, which has not yet been debated in the House of Commons, proposes amendments to the Canada Labour Code and Employment Insurance Act.
NDP MP Sana Hassainia wants parents to have a total of 70 weeks of EI benefits and to receive the time simultaneously to allow both parents to stay home for up to 35 weeks.
Latest Ottawa News Headlines
- Woman's basement sprayed with raw sewage
- An Ottawa homeowner says she got little help after city workers flooded her basement with raw sewage last week. more »
- Gatineau promotes itself with free shuttle service
- A new bus service has launched in Gatineau as part of a larger push to market the Outaouais region and boost the economy. more »
- Canadian Tire Centre replaces Scotiabank Place
- The Ottawa Senators announced Tuesday morning that Scotiabank Place will be renamed the Canadian Tire Centre. more »
- 'Fireball' erupted during blaze on Pathway Private
- Police say the extensive damage caused by a large fire in Ottawa's Redwood neighbourhood early Tuesday morning may make it difficult to find out how it started. more »
Top News Headlines
- Neil Macdonald: Washington's obsession with leakers
- Julian Assange and Edward Snowden are just the most prominent targets in an all-out legal and propaganda campaign that America's security apparatus is mounting against leakers everywhere, Neil Macdonald writes. more »
- Half of First Nations children live in poverty
- Half of status First Nations children in Canada live in poverty, a troubling figure that jumps to nearly two-thirds in Saskatchewan and Manitoba, says a newly released report. more »
- Who's who in the Senate expense controversy
- Keeping track of the names popping up in the ongoing Senate expenses controversy — from the investigators to the four senators themselves — could be a difficult task for even the most seasoned political observers. more »
- How open is Ottawa's new 'open data' website?
- Treasury Board President Tony Clement is touting the federal government's revamped data portal as a "new natural resource." But that online window for previously published data arrives at the same time the government faces controversy over just how open it really is. more »
- Mike Fisher, Carrie Underwood selling Ottawa dream home
- Ottawa craft beer breweries fuel Ontario boom
- The Spartan Race in 90 seconds
- Ottawa RedBlacks officially revealed as newest CFL team
- G8 leaders agree to 7-point plan on Syria as summit wraps
- Woman charged after drink tossed at Toronto Mayor Rob Ford
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford needs security, brother says
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges
- Sharlene Bosma speaks out about husband's murder