Kathy TomlinsonGo Public
Man regains transplant coverage lost because wife gets EI
Family of 5 can't claim maternity benefits and disability assistance at same time
By Kathy Tomlinson, CBC News
Posted: Oct 8, 2012 5:11 AM ET
Last Updated: Oct 8, 2012 5:01 AM ET
A young Ontario father who suffers from kidney disease and needs a transplant has found out the drug benefits he lost because his wife is collecting employment insurance while on maternity leave will be restored.
Ryan Davis, who lives in Wallaceburg, about 140 km southwest of London, said his family was "blindsided" when they initially discovered he would lose the drug and disability benefits he had been collecting. “If I don’t have those drug benefits, the hospital will not move forward with the transplant.”
“I cried all day long the first day we found out we were going to get cut off,” said his wife, Rebecca.
An Ontario government regulation requires household income from EI to be deducted — dollar for dollar — from provincial disability coverage. Similar rules apply across Canada, essentially to prevent people from receiving assistance from two levels of government.
Davis said he found out just two days before his $850 monthly benefit was due that he wouldn’t be getting it for October.
No coverage, no transplant
“I don’t feel the government owes me a living,” he said. “It’s just that I need disability so that I can get my transplant and get back to school and get working.”
His wife had just started collecting maternity benefits, after giving birth to a premature baby girl at the end of August. She normally earns $1,500 per month — and has no drug coverage.
“My husband is not well and might need drugs at any time,” she said, adding there is no way they could afford the post-transplant medications, which cost thousands.Baby Olive's mother is afraid she will have to leave her and go back to work so her father can get the medical treatment he needs. (CBC)
She has a full-time job as an early childhood educator. Her husband was studying engineering, until last fall, when he became too ill to keep up with his studies. With a baby and two other young children, they are now borrowing from family to buy groceries.
“It was tough when I found out I was pregnant because I knew things were going to be hard, but I didn’t realize they were going to be this hard,” said Rebecca, whose pregnancy was unplanned.
“It almost feels like we’re being punished for my husband being ill and for having a new baby, which should be such a joyous time.”
Her husband had hoped to have a transplant by the end of the year, because his mother has been approved as a donor. He is currently undergoing dialysis treatment, which takes up to five hours each day.
“My husband, I’m sure, doesn’t like the feeling that his illness is causing so much turmoil,” Rebecca said. “We’ve had our feet kicked out from under us.”
Her husband adds: “I feel like I should be trying to find a job, but I can’t.”
Incentive to work, says government
While Rebecca Davis was working, her husband qualified for half of his maximum benefits. That’s because the province lets families keep employment income, without dollar for dollar deductions, as an incentive to work.
“It’s an income replacement of last resort,” said John Milloy, the Ontario minister responsible for disability benefits. “At the same time, we want to encourage people to work.”
“I don’t need incentive to find a job — I already have a job,” said Rebecca. “I am legally entitled to take a maternity leave. I’ve paid into my unemployment. I have a job to go back to.”
Unless an exception was made, Rebecca said she will have no choice but to stop breastfeeding and go back to work — against her doctor’s advice — so her husband can get his benefits reinstated.John Milloy, the Ontario minister responsible for disability benefits, said he will look at the Davis case, but there are no exceptions to existing rules. (CBC)
“I feel devastated that I have to leave my infant when she is so little and my family has to struggle like this.”
The full deductions also apply in B.C and other provinces. However, if the Davis family lived in Alberta, they would still be allowed to keep a large portion of Ryan’s benefits. In that province, the first $775 of household income from EI cannot be deducted.
Advocates for the disabled say there should be more flexibility nationwide, based on circumstances, because many Canadians are hit hard by the rules.
“Yes, they have incentives for work. That’s good. We all agree that’s a good idea. But it seems to me they are incredibly harsh when it comes to other kinds of income,” said Robin Loxton of the B.C. Coalition for People with Disabilities.
“When people are getting dinged for what I think are stupid rules, then they should think what are the needs of that family? What is reasonable?”
Milloy says Ontario has 800 rules that govern people on assistance and he believes that should change.
“We are right now in the process of a pretty comprehensive review of social assistance,” he said.
“That’s a good opportunity for us to look at the system as a whole and make sure that it’s supporting people, and if there are anomalies in the system to take a look at those.”Robin Loxton, of the B.C. Coalition of Persons with Disabilities, said the dilemma faced by the Davis family is not unusual. (CBC)
He told Go Public he would look at the Davis case. But he also said current rules don’t allow exceptions.
“I realize how serious this is,” said Milloy. “There is no way that we can go in and change the rules for an individual situation. But we can make sure that they are able to access everything that they are eligible for.”
After CBC interviewed Milloy, the Davis family found out late last week that their case was being reviewed. They were subsequently told that "transitional" drug benefits had been been restored. However, Davis is still without the disability benefits he lost.
Ryan Davis says he hopes his story will inspire the government to rethink the rules, particularly those for EI claimants, who bank on maternity benefits being there when they need them.
“They are kicking people when they are down and [EI is] not government money,” said Ryan. “You pay into it, so it is your money.”
Latest Ottawa News Headlines
- Impact of LRT roadwork to be felt today
- The first visible sign of Ottawa's ambitious five-year light rail transit line construction begins this week as crews work at Nicholas Street in preparation for the excavation of an underground train tunnel. more »
- Harper to address Tory caucus amid Senate scandal
- Conservatives gathered Monday night to mourn the passing of a key architect in their rise to power — and to brace for the toughest test Prime Minister Stephen Harper's government has faced since taking office on a promise to clean up politics in the national capital. more »
- La Peche, Que., man drowns Monday
- A 73-year-old La Pêche, Que., man drowned Monday after falling into a creek near his home. more »
- Ottawa police seek man last seen at Royal hospital
- Ottawa police are asking the public's help finding Michael Pitblado, 41, who disappeared from The Royal hospital Monday morning. more »
Top News Headlines
- Oklahoma tornado recovery work begins after dozens killed
- Rescue teams searched through the night looking for survivors after dozens of people were killed in a tornado in an Oklahoma City suburb. WATCH LIVE: Local authorities have scheduled a news conference for 9 a.m. ET with updates on the storm that flattened homes and two elementary schools. more »
- Will alleged Rob Ford video overshadow Toronto casino debate?
- A debate about a proposed downtown casino is supposed to take centre stage at Toronto City Hall on Tuesday, but it seems a safe bet that a still-unseen video of Mayor Rob Ford will continue to be a topic of conversation. more »
- Harper to address Tory caucus amid Senate scandal
- Keith Boag: Have you heard about the murderous abortion doctor?
- The gruesome trial and murder conviction of Philadelphia abortion provider Dr. Kermit Gosnell is unlikely to change American abortion law, Keith Boag writes. But it has U.S. journalists questioning their priorities and how they cover such a sensitive issue. more »
- Fearful Oklahoma families search for children
- The parents and guardians stood in the muddy grass outside a suburban Oklahoma City church, listening intently as someone with a bullhorn called out the names of children who were being dropped off — survivors of Monday's deadly tornado. more »
- Driver dead after Regional Road 174 rollover
- Fire destroys 100-year-old barn near Kemptville, Ont.
- Bagpiper finds extremely rare instrument at auction
- Man charged with attempted murder after Orleans stabbing
- 2 earthquakes felt in Ontario and Quebec
- NDP wants RCMP inquiry into $90K payment to Duffy
- Teen rugby player dies after suffering head injury in game
- Petition looks to rename Victoria Day
- Gatineau officer shot her own leg, police say