Omnibus crime bill could free more accused criminals
Askov ruling means delayed cases could be dismissed
Posted: Feb 13, 2012 8:09 AM ET
Last Updated: Feb 13, 2012 3:11 PM ET
The federal government's proposed omnibus crime bill could free more accused criminals than it incarcerates, according to the Canadian Bar Association and some lawyers.
In Canada, the Askov ruling happens when a judge determines whether an accused's right "to be tried within a reasonable time" has been infringed under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. It means any case that drags out for an unreasonably long time can be dismissed.
That rule, which comes from a Supreme Court decision in October 1990, now has many lawyers worried the proposed crime bill, which is currently the subject of Senate hearings, will clog the court system.
Bill C-10 makes changes to several existing laws. It creates some new offences, introduces mandatory minimum sentences for some crimes, eliminates pardons and house arrest for some criminals and proposes a number of other changes, including reforms of youth justice laws.
There is concern surrounding mandatory minimums, especially, as the bar association said they make people fight their charges harder.
"If you're already going to be faced with the worst-case scenario anyway — and for a lot of clients, going to jail is the worst-case scenario — then there's a serious disincentive to resolve the case early," said Eric Gottardi, a Vancouver-based lawyer who is also vice-chairman of the bar association's criminal justice section.
1 in 10 criminal charges go to trial
The bill combines nine previous bills that were never passed in previous sessions of Parliament. Federal Justice Minister Rob Nicholson also said the bill targets people in the business of trafficking drugs and exploiting children, and sends a clear message to them there are serious consequences for their actions.Public Safety Minister Vic Toews (left) and Justice Minister Rob Nicholson testified before the Senate Legal and Constitutional Affairs committee on Feb.1. The Senate is considering proposed amendments to the Harper government's omnibus crime legislation. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)
The bill's downside, added Gottardi, is he thinks more criminals could be walking among the public sooner than they should.
Statistics back up that claim, too, as only one in 10 criminal charges ever go to trial. A large majority reach agreements to plead.
Lawyers believe if most of that majority instead decides to test out a trial, the system could see more and more Askov rulings.
Courts are always backlogged with cases, but the worst, according to Ottawa lawyer Mark Ertel, came in 1993 when there was a shortage of judges.
He said as soon as delays reached eight to 10 months, lawyers would start filing Askov appeals and judges granted the appeals. Ertel estimated hundreds of accused just walked away.
"It's a battle they've been fighting since 1993 and they've been fairly successful fighting it," Ertel said, "But this is a bomb that's going to hit the system and all their good efforts will have been for naught."
Reforms to the Canadian court system have helped reduce wait times.
Currently, delays are about six to seven months, according to Ertel, but he said just a few more trials a month would overload the system in Ottawa.
Latest Ottawa News Headlines
- Hutt changed story, said he burned wife accidentally
- A man accused of scalding his wife and leaving her to die changed his story about how his wife was burned during a police interrogation, an Ottawa court heard today. more »
- Torch relay kicks off Ottawa Race Weekend
- Torchbearers carried the flame to Ottawa all the way from Marathon, Ont., on Thursday to help officially kick off Ottawa Race Weekend. more »
- Mike Duffy says he wants to give Canadians 'the whole story'
- Senator Mike Duffy says he wants a "full and open" inquiry so Canadians can get all the facts about the scandal that has rocked the Senate and the Prime Minister's Office and that he has no plans to resign. more »
- Wharnsby: Never count out Paul MacLean
- CBC Sports senior hockey writer Tim Wharnsby explains why it would be unwise to write off head coach Paul MacLean and his pesky Ottawa Senators just yet. more »
Top News Headlines
- Rob Ford councillors set to take over if mayor steps down
- Members of Rob Ford's executive committee say they are prepared to take over the day-to-day running of the city if the Toronto mayor is no longer able to perform his duties amid a scandal involving allegations he was caught on video smoking crack cocaine. more »
- Greg Weston: Senate scandal may be Harper's worst hour
- The widening Senate scandal that the prime minister flippantly tried to dismiss as a 'distraction' just days ago has instead become arguably Stephen Harper's worst hour. more »
- Washington state bridge collapse injures 3
- A Washington state bridge over a river collapsed last night, dumping two vehicles into the water and sparking a rescue effort by boats and divers who searched the chilly waterway north of Seattle. more »
- 3D printers give rise to 'desktop manufacturing'
- Customizable objects from plastic dollhouse furniture to medical prosthetics can now be designed and printed out by almost anyone at the press of a button, and is going to lead to an 'explosion of new stuff,' predicts author Chris Anderson. more »
- Rob Ford fired chief of staff for telling mayor to 'get help'
- CBC News has learned the details of what precipitated the firing of Mark Towhey as Toronto Mayor Rob Ford's chief of staff — and it was advice from Towhey that Ford needs to 'get help.' more »
- Hutt changed story, said he flung hot water at wife accidentally
- The Ottawa Senators love their dogs
- Fire destroys 100-year-old barn near Kemptville, Ont.
- Orleans man dies from stabbing injuries
- Finding inspiration for the Sens
- Alleged Ford crack video seller not responding to calls
- Woman pleads for help after daughter kidnapped in Haiti
- Senators' Alfredsson on defeating Penguins: 'Probably not'
- Stabbing victim not expected to live, family says