Parents of twins denied double benefits to appeal
Posted: Jun 16, 2011 9:20 AM ET
Last Updated: Jun 16, 2011 9:32 PM ET
An Ottawa couple who were denied double parental benefits to care for their twin girls are taking their case to the Federal Court of Appeal.
Christian Martin and his wife Paula Critchley both applied for the full 35 weeks of parental leave after the births of their daughters, Lucie and Athena, in April 2009.
Normally, under Canadian law, the parents may take a total of 35 weeks of parental leave following a birth or adoption while receiving benefits under Canada's Employment Insurance program, no matter how many children are born to or adopted by the parents at the same time.
But Martin and Critchley had argued that since parents of children born a year apart are entitled to two 35-week benefit periods, parents of twins should receive the same amount of time.
In September 2009, a board of referees of the Canada Employment Insurance Commission awarded the couple 35 weeks each — one for each child.
But in May this year, an arbitrator overturned that decision, saying the Employment Insurance Act is clear that benefits were limited to 35 weeks for "the care of one or more new-born or adopted children as a result of a single pregnancy or placement."
Martin said they are appealing, arguing the law is inconsistent and violates their right to equality under Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"They say on one hand that it's based on pregnancy, but in fact it isn't, it's based on caring for a child," said Martin, arguing that mothers who give their babies up for adoption are not entitled to the benefit while those who adopt are.
"But they use that pregnancy provision to prevent people like me to be able to obtain benefits. It's only used in that instance, so it's a double standard," Martin said.
"It's unfortunate because they are not applying their own law properly," he said.
Martin said he is reaching out to other families to help fund his fight to the next stage at the Federal Court of Appeal.
Monique MacKenzie, mother of twin girls, said she sympathizes with the case after caring for her infant daughters alone for many months.
"I had my mom for a few months, but I did do a couple months all on my own and almost went insane," MacKenzie said. "If we had them one at a time, they would have been paying EI times two years."
Martin said he hopes the case will lead Parliament to reconsider whether multiple births deserve multiple benefits.With files from the CBC's Alistair Steele
Latest Ottawa News Headlines
- Toronto mayor's brother says he never dealt drugs
- The brother of Toronto Mayor Rob Ford has vehemently denied allegations in Saturday's Globe and Mail that he was involved in the illicit drug trade in the 1980s. more »
- Feds look to snag corporate sponsors for Ottawa events
- McDonald's golden arches on Parliament Hill? Tim Hortons billboards at the Governor General's residence? Nothing quite so crass is in the works, but a cash-strapped federal agency is actively looking for corporate sponsors to fill gaping holes in its budget. more »
- PM's credibility at stake in growing Senate expenses crisis
- With the prime minister's credibility at stake in a growing political crisis, has Stephen Harper done enough to explain his former chief of staff's $90,000 cheque to Senator Mike Duffy? Listen to CBC Radio's The House with Evan Solomon here. more »
- Audit of city's Orgaworld contract not expected until fall
- A long-awaited audit of the controversial deal between the City of Ottawa and Orgaworld won't be released until an ongoing commercial arbitration process ends, likely in the fall. more »
Top News Headlines
- 3 more suspects arrested in slaying of U.K. soldier
- Hockey Canada votes to ban bodychecking in peewee hockey
- Neil Macdonald: How serious is Obama about curbing the drone surge?
- Ontario man lost in Australian mountains has survival skills
- Senators' unlikely playoff run ends in Game 5 disappointment
- Ottawa Race Weekend road closures
- Ottawa Senators thank fans after pesky season
- Canada Post tells residents that junk mail is useful
- Ottawa residents use green bins more, landfills less
- Fire destroys 100-year-old barn near Kemptville, Ont.
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford denies using crack cocaine
- Train travel back to normal after fatal crash in eastern Ontario
- The Ottawa Senators love their dogs