Cost of Ottawa light rail tunnel could jump: critic
Last Updated: Sunday, January 3, 2010 | 1:54 PM ET
CBC News
The price tag for Ottawa's proposed downtown light rail tunnel could balloon because of engineering complications, says a local transit advocate.
City councillors voted last month to approve a $2.1 billion, 12.5-kilometre stretch of light rail track, to run from the Tunney's Pasture transit station in the west to the Blair station in the east.
It will include a 3.2-kilometre long tunnel between LeBreton Flats and the University of Ottawa, with four underground stations. Portions of the tunnel will go under the Rideau Canal, and at points will reach depths of over 100 feet.
David Jeanes, head of the transportation advocacy group Transport 2000, told CBC News digging that far underground could present unforeseen complications.
"Ottawa is proposing a tunnel [that] is very deep. It's passing underneath buildings and it's passing through rock that we really don't know much about," Jeanes said.
"Very few other building owners or land owners have ever gone as deep as we need to go for this system."
Ottawa officials have said they have budgeted extra money for problems like hitting fault lines, tricky geological conditions and even old sewers.
"We have limited information at the depth that we've done the design. As a result, our design is relatively conservative," said David Hopper, a project consultant hired by the city from Delcan Corporation.
Niagara tunnel comparison
But the project could run into problems similar to those encountered by a much-maligned hydro tunnel project in Niagara Falls, Jeanes said. The Niagara Tunnel project is intended to deliver a new water source to the Sir Adam Beck generating station near Queenston, Ont., in an effort to boost energy production.
The cost of that project has ballooned to $1.6 billion from $985 million, and its expected completion date has been pushed to December 2013, from the original target of June 2010.
The cost overruns and construction delays have been blamed in part on the geological complexities of the area.
Dennis Gratton, a senior project manager with the city, played down fears the Ottawa tunnel could face similar problems. Deep transit tunnels under bodies of water are becoming more commonplace around the world, he said.
"With that in mind, and going into preliminary engineering later on next year, I don't think we're going to have those types of serious cost overruns or mistakes that were made in Niagara or [with] anybody else," Gratton said.
Tunnel experts from England are advising Ottawa on the dig. The city says its project is modeled on ones in Pittsburgh and New Jersey.
The city has so far secured $600 million from the province to put toward the $2.1 billion project. However, even if the federal and municipal governments make equal commitments, the project will still have a $300 million shortfall.
Share Tools
Latest Ottawa News Headlines
- Ottawa smoking ban passed at committee
- Members of the community and protective services committee voted in favour of the new, updated Ottawa smoking ban that prohibits lighting up at parks, beaches and on patios. more »
- 2 NDP MPs back final Commons vote to kill gun registry
- Two NDP MPs broke party ranks to vote with the government in the final House of Commons vote on scrapping the long-gun registry. more »
- Civics and careers course needs work, say students
- High school students say compulsory courses in civics and careers need to be revised to make them more relevant to their lives. more »
- Nortel collapse linked to hacking attack
- A former systems security adviser to Nortel Networks says he has no doubt that extensive cyber attacks on the technology company contributed to its downfall. more »
Top News Headlines
- Drummond report on Ontario calls for cutbacks
- The Ontario government must curtail its spending with the kind of cuts not seen since the Mike Harris years, according to a report by former TD Bank chief economist Don Drummond. more »
- Children of immigrants challenged at school, home
- By 2016, foreign-born youth and Canadian-born youth from immigrant families will make up a quarter of the country's population, according to predictions by the Canadian Council on Social Development. As their numbers grow, more attention is being paid to their successes and failures. more »
- B.C. house party trial hears from tearful teens
- Two teenagers cried as they testified at the trial of a B.C. woman who was charged after a teen died while her son was hosting a party at her house in 2008. more »
- Whitney Houston funeral to be livestreamed
- Whitney Houston's funeral will be livestreamed, to satisfy the desire of fans to grieve alongside family members at the Saturday memorial. more »
Most Viewed/Commented
- Unlicensed Ottawa children's taxi investigated
- Ontario police help Ottawa predator probe
- Ottawa men charged after pellet gun incident
- Hundreds mourn Carleton suicide victim
- McGuinty backs Wi-Fi in schools
- Community groups seek legal advice on prostitution sweeps
- Report on slashing Ontario deficit due Feb. 15
- Ottawa high school student found
- Drummond report on Ontario spending due today

