Senate nixes Obama's Guantanamo plan
Lawmakers refuse to OK funds requested to shutter facility by January
Last Updated: Wednesday, May 20, 2009 | 6:33 PM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
Video
- Alison Smith reports: Senate nixes Obama's Guantanamo plan (Runs: 2:25)
- Play: QuickTime »
- Play: Real Media »
A guard leans on a fence while talking to a detainee at the U.S. naval base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in this photo taken Jan. 21 and reviewed by the U.S. military. (Brennan Linsley/Associated Press)In a rare, bipartisan defeat for U.S. President Barack Obama, the Senate voted overwhelmingly Wednesday to keep the prison at Guantanamo Bay open for the foreseeable future and forbid the transfer of any detainees to facilities in the United States.
Democrats lined up with Republicans in the 90-6 vote that came on the heels of a similar move a week ago in the House of Representatives, underscoring widespread apprehension among Obama's congressional allies over voters' strong feelings about bringing detainees to the U.S.
Obama has vowed to close the prison by January 2010, and the Senate's vote was not the final word on the matter. It will be next month at the earliest before Congress completes work on the legislation, giving the White House time pursue a compromise that would allow the president to fulfill his pledge.
Additionally, U.S. District Judge John Bates ruled this week that some prisoners — but not all — can be held indefinitely at Guantanamo without being charged, thus increasing the pressure on the administration to develop a plan for the men held there.
"The president understands that his most important job is to keep the American people safe and that he is not going to make any decision or any judgment that imperils the safety of the American people," White House press secretary Robert Gibbs said after the Senate vote.
Obama has not yet decided where some of the detainees will be sent, Gibbs added. A presidential commission is studying the issue.
'Guantanamo Bay was never meant to be an Ellis Island.'— Representative Lamar Smith of Texas
There was no suspense in the moments leading to the Senate vote, although Democrats manoeuvered to take political credit for denying Obama funds he sought to close the prison.
Senator Daniel Inouye, a Democrat from Hawaii and chairman of the appropriations committee, said he initially had favoured keeping Guantanamo open until Obama produced a "coherent plan for closing the prison."
The administration asked for $80 million to close the facility. Obama promised repeatedly as a presidential candidate to shut down the prison, calling it a blot on the international image of the United States.
Rare victory for Republicans
The lopsided vote was a victory for Senate Republicans, who have recently turned their attention to Obama's foreign and terrorism-related policies after failing to make headway in criticizing his economic program.
Senator Richard Durbin of Illinois, the second-in-command among Democrats, pointed out that no one has ever escaped from a federal "supermax" prison and that 347 convicted terrorists are among those held in them.
That drew some support from Senator Lindsey Graham, a Republican who represents South Carolina.
"The idea that we cannot find a place to securely house 250-plus detainees within the United States is not rational," he said.
Not all Republicans were thinking along the same lines.
"No good purpose is served by allowing known terrorists, who trained at terrorist training camps, to come to the U.S. and live among us," said Representative Lamar Smith of Texas. "Guantanamo Bay was never meant to be an Ellis Island."
With files from The Associated PressShare Tools
Latest Ottawa News Headlines
- New mom among dead in Aylmer triple stabbing

- A young mother, her mother and another man, who all lived together in the Gatineau, Que., suburb of Aylmer, were found stabbed to death in their home, police say. more »
- Canadian woman continues tweeting her way to the top of Everest
- Sandra Leduc is taking a second run at Mount Everest's summit after a deadly storm forced her back down the mountain and killed four others on Sunday. The Canadian lawyer and government worker is tweeting her progress along the way. more »
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Raw stories about bullying emerged when a video booth was set up inside a Quebec high school. more »
- Memorial held at Eric Leighton's high school
- A memorial is being held today at Mother Teresa Catholic Secondary School where Grade 12 student Eric Leighton was killed in a shop class explosion one year ago. more »
Top News Headlines
- Quebec students to challenge Bill 78 in court
- A collective of student associations, unions and environmental groups is holding a news conference Friday morning to announce their plans to mount a legal challenge against Bill 78. more »
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Raw stories about bullying emerged when a video booth was set up inside a Quebec high school. more »
- Reclaiming the dead on Mt. Everest

- The difficulty, danger and expense of removing the bodies of climbers who died in Mount Everest's "death zone" mean most of the dead remain on the mountain as a stark reminder to other climbers of the risks. more »
- Foreign investment review threshold rising to $1 billion
- The federal government is raising to $1 billion the amount of foreign money that can go into a Canadian company before the investment is reviewed. more »
Most Viewed/Commented
- New mom among dead in Aylmer triple stabbing
- Gatineau police to question suspect in multiple homicides
- Birds attack Ottawa joggers
- Woman pinned between forklifts in Ottawa warehouse
- Teens share bullying tales in confession booth
- Ottawa race weekend road closures
- Double-lung recipient Hélène Campbell dances for joy
- Victim named in Queensway rollover crash
- G20 police illegally arrested journalists, used gay slur

