Bus drivers should have annual health checks, MPP urges

The transportation critic for Ontario's PC party says drivers of city buses across the province should have annual health checks to renew their licence and semi-annual checks if they are older than 40.

PC transportation critic Frank Klees wants drivers to have same rules as commerical airline pilots

All Ontario city bus drivers would have, at minimum, annual health checks if PC transportation critic Frank Klees had his way.

Drivers of Ontario’s city buses should have stricter rules for monitoring their health like those used for commercial airline pilots across Canada, according to the PC transportation critic.

Currently, the Ministry of Transportation of Ontario requires bus drivers younger than 46 years old to submit a medical report every five years to maintain their Class “C” licence. If drivers are older than 46, they have to submit the report every three years.

MPP Frank Klees spent a short time as Ontario's transportation minister before the 2003 provincial election. (Photo courtesy of Frank Klees)

Doctors must also notify the ministry immediately if there is a significant change to a driver's health, such as a heart condition.

Transport Canada stipulates commercial airline pilots have medical checks each year if they are 40 or younger, and every six months if they are older than 40.

“To me there is not a great deal of difference between what a commercial airline pilot does and what a bus driver does every day,” said MPP Frank Klees, who was also the province’s transportation minister for a short time in 2003.

“I think the Ministry of Transportation here in the province of Ontario would do well to implement a parallel set of requirements."

Bus crash ignites debate on drivers' health

The issue of bus drivers’ health has been the focus of some debate after it was learned the driver of OC Transpo Route 76, which crashed into a Via Rail passenger train on Sept. 18, had been prescribed medication to treat a less severe form of diabetes.

The crash killed six people including the driver, 45-year-old Dave Woodard, and five of his passengers: Kyle Nash and Connor Boyd, both 21; Michael Bleakney, 57; Rob More, 35; and Karen Krzyzewski, 53.

But investigators have not linked Woodard’s health to the crash and it could be months before the public hears about possible factors in the crash.

(CBC)

In Ottawa, OC Transpo verifies bus drivers' licences regularly, but it does not conduct separate medical checks. Klees said no matter what investigators find after the bus crash, city bus drivers across Ontario should be monitored more carefully.

Craig Watson, president of the Amalgamated Transit Union 279, agrees with Klees. But the man whose union represents Ottawa city bus drivers said the idea would only work if the province footed the bill for all medical checks.

"There is the cost of the time, the effort and the monetary cost of the doctors, which is not covered by OHIP,” Watson said.

“But if it's another safety consideration that the Ontario government would consider … we're all about safety."

Poll question

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.