Government axes Halifax railbed plan as cost soars
Last Updated: Wednesday, March 4, 2009 | 3:24 PM AT
CBC News
The government of Nova Scotia has rejected a plan to develop a consolidated truck and rail corridor in Halifax.
Transportation Minister Brook Taylor says expanding what's called the rail cut to make room for trucks is just too expensive.
"There certainly would have been efficiencies if the project had have went ahead, but frankly, when you looked at the capital, it just wasn't or it isn't worthwhile," Taylor said Wednesday.
A feasibility report examining the proposed project put the cost between $205 and $270 million, even though the governing Conservatives had originally estimated the cost at $80 million.
New Democrat Leonard Preyra said the cost discrepancy shows the Conservatives are "out of touch" while Liberal Leader Stephen McNeil says the idea was "ill-conceived" from the get-go.
The proposal, which was part of the Atlantic gateway initiative, called for using existing rail lines as a route for truck and container traffic to and from the port of Halifax.
The project would have seen the railway bed paved to allow 18-wheelers to travel to and from the Halterm container terminal in the city's south end.
Sue Uteck, the city councillor who represents the south-end neighbourhood, said she was not surprised that the project has been turned down by the province, and she agrees with the decision. She wants the money that was put toward the plan to go into improving the Port of Halifax.
"There's not a person in HRM [Halifax Regional Municipality] that's not concerned for the Port of Halifax, and let's work together and find the brightest and best solution for it," she said.
The study found that the truck corridor might save 15 minutes travel time for transport trucks heading into or out of the city's downtown, but there would be almost no impact on overall traffic congestion and therefore no positive effect on decreasing greenhouse gases.
Although the study suggested the enormous cost of the project outweighed the benefits from a provincial government investment point of view, it went on went to say that it might be worthwhile for the city's transit goals.
However, Halifax Regional Municipality Mayor Peter Kelly said Wednesday he's not interested.
"If it's too expensive for the province, it's too expensive for us. If they can't do it with their budgets, and their resources, there's no way in this world we can afford it, so that would be an no go," Kelly said. "...But to spend $270 million when there's so many other demands, it would be asinine for us to go in that direction."
With files from the Canadian PressShare Tools
Latest Nova Scotia News Headlines
- Metro Transit workers vote in favour of arbitration
- Striking Metro Transit union members voted in favour of binding arbitration on their dispute with the Halifax Regional Municipality Tuesday afternoon. more »
- White Point Beach Resort redesign unveiled
- The redesign of White Point Beach Lodge was unveiled Tuesday, just three months after part of it was destroyed by fire. more »
- Coyotes kill deer in Lower Sackville backyard
- A man who discovered a partially-eaten deer in his Lower Sackville backyard says he believes there are several coyotes in his residential neighbourhood. more »
- What falling in love does to you
- On Valentine's Day, the CBC's Colleen Jones talked to people about what it feels like to fall in love. more »
Top News Headlines
- Legalize pot, say former B.C. attorneys general
- Four former B.C. attorneys general are joining a coalition of health and justice experts calling for the legalization of marijuana. more »
- Whitney Houston's funeral to be held Saturday
- Pop star Whitney Houston's funeral service will be held Saturday in the New Jersey church where she first showcased her singing talents as a child. more »
- Online surveillance bill targets child porn: Toews
- A bill that would give police and intelligence agencies new powers to access Canadians' electronic communications is needed to protect against child pornography, says Public Safety Minister Vic Toews. more »
- Air Canada pilots give strike mandate to union
- The union representing Air Canada pilots has been given an overwhelming mandate to call a strike, though the pilots have said they won't use that option while mediated talks are ongoing. more »
- HMCS Corner Brook collision damage extensive
- Metro Transit workers votes in favour of arbitration
- Seniors pray for end to Metro Transit strike
- 120 patients affected in Capital Health breach
- Math scores low across Tri-County board
- Antigonish murder trial hears 911 tape, witnesses
- N.S. workplace deaths prompt warning
- Veterans' privacy breaches prompt call for inquiry
- White Point Beach Resort redesign unveiled

