School closure review continues with public hearings

Nova Scotia's Department of Education and Early Childhood Development released a discussion paper Tuesday that floats ideas on how to improve the school closure process.

Current process in Nova Scotia criticized as inadequate, stressful

Nova Scotia's Department of Education and Early Childhood Development released a discussion paper Tuesday that floats ideas on how to improve the school closure process as the provincial government grapples with the problem of aging schools and a declining student population.

The paper said standard indicators would help school boards identify whether schools should close. As it stands, school boards are not required to base their school closure decisions on specific information, but they can look at population numbers, enrolment patterns and facility utilization.

The document said a standardized method would help the public understand the rationale behind school closures, which have prompted protests from parents in recent years.

Bob Fowler, a former provincial deputy minister and chairman of the province's school review committee, said the ideas in the discussion paper will be discussed at nine public meetings across Nova Scotia in January.

"Do people find resonance in what's there, or would they like to broaden it? Would they like to change it? Do they like the current process?" Fowler said at a news conference in Halifax.

"We have to listen to people in those broader consultations."

School board2002-032007-082012-132017-18
Enrolment Trends (2002-2013) and Projection (2017-2018)
Cape Breton-Victoria19861164181383912413
Annapolis Valley16887154661357912606
South Shore9160790368526444
Acadien provincial4059425749345319

The public input from those meetings will help Fowler and a new committee develop recommendations for Education Minister Karen Casey, to be submitted by the end of February.

Fowler said he's already received some written submissions.

"There were people who said the process is fine, leave it alone. There were other people who said we need to reinvent it completely," he said Tuesday.

In April, then education minister Ramona Jennex asked the province's school boards to suspend all school closures until next year, saying the review process had become adversarial and upsetting for parents and school boards.

'We need a dramatic change'

Casey said the review process will always be an emotionally-charged issue, regardless of how or if the process is changed in the spring.

"Will it ever be a process that is without anxiety? No," Casey said. "I think governments are to be commended for responding to the concerns that people bring forward."

Paul Bennett, director of Schoolhouse Consulting in Halifax, said communities across the province feel the criteria used by school boards is inadequate and they should also consider the impact the closure would have on the community.

He urged the province and school boards to put more consideration into transportation costs before they close small schools and bus students to larger ones.

"It costs more in gas for parents who drive. It increases our bus transportation. It's unhealthy. It's actually contributing to bullying because more of the bullying occurs on the buses than on the school ground," Bennett told reporters.

"All of these things suggest we need a dramatic change and if this report leads in that direction, then I'm all in favour of it."

Any new legislation designed to improve the school closure policy will have to be in place by April 1, 2014, as that's the time of year when school boards decide which schools to put on the chopping block.

Between the 2008-2009 school year and the 2012-2013 school year, boards across the province decided to close 40 schools, the discussion paper said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.