Moncton mother appeals for organ donation rule changes

A Moncton mother is lobbying the Nova Scotia Health Authority because she wants to be able to donate a kidney to her 18-month-old son.

Ashley Barnaby has sent a letter to the Nova Scotia Health Authority asking to be re-considered as a donor

Ashley Barnaby says it was frustrating to hear that after months of medical appointments and tests she won't be eligible to donate a kidney to her son Zaccari (CBC)

Moncton mother is appealing to the Nova Scotia Health Authority to be reconsidered as a kidney donor for her young son.

Ashley Barnaby's son Zaccari Buell has congenital nephrotic syndrome and minor heart issues and has spent much of his life at the IWK Health Centre in Halifax. 

Barnaby says she was told she was a match only to learn she was rejected as an organ donor because she previously developed gestational diabetes and high blood pressure when she was pregnant. 

"Now that I'm completely healthy and capable of making this donation to my son, I'm being denied because of the chance of something happening in the future with my health," she said. 

"If those red flags were such an issue I should've been given that information back in October instead of building my hopes up, making me go through months of testing." 

Potential donors have approached the family, Barnaby says, but now they have to start from scratch with the screening process. Just a few weeks ago, she says she'd talked to doctors about the possibility of a transplant as early as February. 

Petitioning for change

Barnaby has written a letter to the health authority and says she's been told her case will go before a panel of nephrologists, or kidney specialists, in the coming weeks. 

This weekend she started an online petition that she hopes to present to the panel. So far there are about 300 signatures on it. 

No one from the Nova Scotia Health Authority was available to comment Sunday.

Zaccari Buell has spent most of his life in the IWK Health Centre in Halifax. (Stephanie vanKampen/CBC)

In a statement, the medical director of the Living Kidney Donation program says specialists follow national guidelines when evaluating possible donors and consider applicant's health and safety in the short and long term.

"Unfortunately, there are times when health factors result in the donation being ruled out," Dr. Christine Dipchand said in a statement. "As health care providers we share in that disappointment." 

Barnaby is still hopeful her son will receive a transplant, which she says is necessary for her son's quality of life.

Around the clock care

The toddler is hooked up to a dialysis machine for 12 hours a night, needs medication throughout the day and receives nutrients through a feeding tube. Although he's 18 months old, his condition has affected his development. 

"The only thing that is keeping him going is being hooked up to his [peritoneal] dialysis machine every night. That's no way a child should have to live. That's not life living on a machine," Barnaby says. 

She hopes her plight will help raise awareness about the importance of organ donation.

In the fall, Barnaby created another online petition to lobby the federal government to consider switching to a system where it is presumed people will donate unless they opt out

Now she says the organ donation process must also adapt to allow people like herself to make calculated risks. 

"If at the end these are the issues, I should have a voice. I should be able to give consent, waive those health issues, take full responsibility for my own health and be able to give my son this life-changing kidney treatment."

About the Author

Elizabeth McMillan

Elizabeth McMillan is a journalist with CBC Nova Scotia. Over the past eight years, she has reported from the edge of the Arctic Ocean to the Atlantic Coast and loves sharing people's stories. She can be found on twitter @elizmcmillan.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.