In-custody death renews call for RCMP oversight
Last Updated: Tuesday, June 1, 2010 | 8:45 PM CST
CBC News
Western Arctic NDP MP Dennis Bevington, left, and B.C. NDP MP Nathan Cullen, right, speak to reporters in Ottawa on Tuesday. (CBC) The federal New Democrats are again calling for the creation of a civilian watchdog agency to oversee the RCMP in light of the death of a Yukon man in custody nearly two years ago.
British Columbia NDP MP Nathan Cullen, who introduced a private member's bill last year proposing an independent RCMP watchdog, said the in-custody death of Raymond Silverfox in 2008 shows that police should not be policing police.
Cullen's bill proposes the creation of an independent civilian agency that would investigate deaths or serious injuries that occur to people in RCMP custody.
"Families have come forward in the most perfectly clear way: they're just looking for justice," Cullen told reporters Tuesday in Ottawa.
"It's not an issue of revenge. This is just purely an issue of justice."
Was mocked, neglected in cells
Silverfox, a 43-year-old First Nations man from Carmacks, Yukon, died after he was kept in the Whitehorse RCMP detachment's drunk tank for about 13 hours on Dec. 2, 2008.
A Yukon coroner's inquest in April heard that RCMP officers and detachment guards on duty that day did not seek medical attention for Silverfox during that time, even though he was vomiting profusely.
Some officers and guards even mocked and jeered at Silverfox as he lay in a pool of his own vomit and feces, the inquest heard. He was eventually taken to hospital, where he died that evening.
"My dad did not deserve the treatment he received in his last 13 hours of his life," Deanna Lee Charlie, Silverfox's daughter, told reporters.
"He was a human being, a proud First Nations man. He was my father."
MP supports call for inquiry
Raymond Silverfox, 43, died after spending 13 hours in Whitehorse RCMP cells on Dec. 2, 2008. His family has appealed the findings of a coroner's inquest, which concluded Silverfox died of natural causes. (Family photo)Silverfox's family has asked the Yukon Supreme Court to review the findings of the coroner's inquest, which concluded that Silverfox died of natural causes.
Cullen added his voice to a growing number of people and groups, including the Assembly of First Nations, supporting the family's demand for a full public inquiry into Silverfox's death.
"It was only through a public inquiry that we're able to properly understand what was happening and what happened to Mr. Dziekanski," Cullen said, referring to Robert Dziekanski, a Polish immigrant who died after RCMP officers used a Taser on him at the Vancouver airport in 2007.
"It seems to me that the only thing that we're going to have to bring satisfaction is to have a similar inquiry."
The Yukon government has not ruled out the possibility of a public inquiry. Last month, Premier Dennis Fentie said his government is waiting for Crown prosecutors to finish reviewing material from the coroner's inquest.
Also last month, Yukon RCMP commanding Supt. Peter Clark apologized for what he described as the "insensitive and callous treatment" Silverfox had endured in custody.
Clark indicated that five RCMP members are facing internal code of conduct investigations related to Silverfox's death.
'Nobody left resisting' bill: Cullen
Cullen said not much has happened with his private member's bill since it was introduced in the House of Commons in November 2009, although he noted that the Liberals and the Bloc Québécois support it.
"We think the public are onside, we know the RCMP are onside, the auditor general, the police complaints [commission] — there's nobody left resisting this," Cullen said.
"At some point the government's got to pick up the mantle and run with it."
Cullen said an independent RCMP watchdog agency would be similar to Ontario's Special Investigations Unit, which oversees the provincial police force there.
The Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP, an existing independent agency created by Parliament, is not given the "teeth" to conduct investigations and bring in experts, Cullen said.
'Extra emphasis' in North: Hanson
In February, RCMP Commissioner William Elliott announced that the RCMP will have independent agencies investigate cases where the force is involved in the serious injury or death of an individual, or if an RCMP employee is suspected of contravening the Criminal Code.
More recently, after details of Silverfox's death surfaced at the coroner's inquest, the RCMP and the Yukon government created a task force to review policing in the territory.
Yukon NDP leader Elizabeth Hanson said while the policing review will help the RCMP rebuild relations with Yukoners, it will not address the specific circumstances surrounding Silverfox's death or determine what consequences, if any, the RCMP officers and detachment guards involved should face.
Given the central role the RCMP has in northern communities, Hanson said there is an "extra emphasis on the need for members of the RCMP to be not only seen to uphold the values of the RCMP but to be able to demonstrate that in every way."
Share Tools
Latest North News Headlines
- Arctic scholar, politician Bob Williamson dies
- Arctic scholar, activist and politician Bob Williamson has died. more »
- Increased shipping in the North could threaten whales
- New research suggests that increased shipping in the North could pose a serious threat to whales, as underwater noise from ships can cause stress in the animals. more »
- Arctic bishop John Sperry dies
- Longtime northerner Bishop John R. Sperry died on Feb. 11 in Hay River, N.W.T. He was 87 years old. more »
- Imperial Oil says Mackenzie pipeline deadline will be tight
- An Imperial Oil spokesperson says the company intends to meet the NEB's 2013 deadline, but that it will be tight because it has to secure 'literally thousands' of permits. more »
Top News Headlines
- U.S. bank reforms could hurt Canadians, Flaherty fears
- Canada's finance minister and the governor of the Bank of Canada have formally complained to their American counterparts that proposed banking reforms could harm Canadian banks, business, investors and the government itself. more »
- CBC digital music service launches today

- CBC is diving into the world of online music with the goal of providing listeners access to their favourite tunes, and a way to discover new artists and connect with fellow music fans. more »
- Ontario teachers' union calls for classroom Wi-Fi ban
- Ontario's Catholic schoolteachers are calling for hardwire instead of Wi-Fi in classrooms. more »
- Whitney Houston was found unconscious underwater, police say
- Whitney Houston was underwater and apparently unconscious in a bathtub at the Beverly Hilton Hotel when found, Beverly Hills police said Monday. more »
- Imperial Oil says Mackenzie pipeline deadline will be tight
- Arctic bishop John Sperry dies
- Army drivers to train on Yellowknife roads
- Contractor says oil furnace industry needs policing
- Arctic scholar, politician Bob Williamson dies
- Shelter's resources strained by sled dog rescue
- N.W.T. Health Minister’s daughter charged in major drug bust
- Snowy owls flock south
- Nunavut unveils new high school curriculum

