Feds take Ashley Smith 'death video' ruling to court
Coroner says prison video of teen's death should be public at inquest
The Canadian Press
Posted: Oct 23, 2012 4:48 PM AT
Last Updated: Oct 23, 2012 5:48 PM AT
The inquest under Dr. John Carlisle, slated to begin early in the new year, is the second one into Ashley Smith's death. (Courtesy of Ashley Smith's family)Federal prison authorities are going to court to try to stop release of jailhouse video of a teen who died in her cell.
Their announcement came minutes after the coroner refused to put a publication ban on the videos of Ashley Smith.
The decision by Correctional Service Canada threatens to delay the long-delayed inquest still further.
Prison authorities wanted the videos of a dying Smith held from public view.
But presiding coroner, Dr. John Carlisle, said the public's right to know was too important to ignore.
A lawyer for Correctional Service Canada had argued the tapes had not been entered as evidence.
Allowing the public to see the materials ahead of time, he said, could undermine the process.
Lawyers for Smith's family and media outlets called that position absurd.
They argued the inquest had begun even though no jury has been seated, and the public has a right to know what materials are in play.
Smith, 19, choked herself to death in her cell in Kitchener, Ont., five years ago after repeated bouts of self-harm.
Speculation about possible harm was not enough to order the secrecy, Carlisle ruled.
"There will be no sealing order," he said.
Joel Robichaud, lawyer for Correctional Service Canada, immediately asked for a brief adjournment.
"My instructions are to seek a judicial review of your decision," Robichaud told Carlisle afterward.
Julian Falconer, who speaks for Smith's family, urged the coroner to reject the adjournment motion as "colossally" without merit.
"A losing party will always have an interest in stopping things," said Falconer, who accused the government of holding the proceedings "hostage" at taxpayers' expense.
Most other lawyers lined up to urge that the hearing proceed,with one saying the process had already been "agonizingly slow."
Carlisle reserved his decision.
Share Tools
Latest New Brunswick News Headlines
- Fredericton mom told to stop breastfeeding at public pool
- A Fredericton mother is speaking out after a lifeguard asked her to stop breastfeeding her daughter at the indoor public pool. more »
- MS liberation therapy fund should end, Parrott says
- Independent MLA and retired surgeon Jim Parrott is calling on the provincial government to stop spending taxpayers' money on a controversial treatment for multiple sclerosis. more »
- Dog taken amid allegations of abuse reunited with family
- A dog that went missing in Saint John earlier this week amidst online allegations of abuse and neglect has been reunited with its owners. more »
- Heavy rainfall forecast prompts flood warnings
- Environment Canada has issued a heavy rainfall warning for New Brunswick with as much as 120 millimetres of rain expected to fall in central, southeastern and southwestern regions by late Saturday. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Royal Bank pledges not to outsource jobs for cash savings
- Royal Bank has promised it will never outsource a Canadian job to a foreign worker solely to save money. more »
- Washington police blame bridge collapse on Alberta trucker

- Washington State police say an Alberta trucker was responsible for hitting a steel beam precipitating a bridge collapse on one of the busiest routes in the American northwest. more »
- Man accused of killing child in patio crash granted bail
- Emotions ran high in a packed Edmonton courthouse Friday as Richard Suter, accused of causing a crash into a restaurant patio that killed a young boy, was granted bail. more »
- Senators' unlikely playoff run ends in Game 5 disappointment
- The Ottawa Senators can't hang their heads after a 6-2 loss in Game 5 ended their improbable run to the second round of the NHL playoffs, but questions abound whether their 40-year-old captain will hang up his skates. more »
- Fredericton mom told to stop breastfeeding at public pool
- Dog taken amid allegations of abuse reunited with family
- Rothesay man charged with 2nd-degree murder
- Heavy rainfall forecast prompts flood warnings
- Joe Oliver challenges Trudeau's west-east pipeline 'tone'
- Saint John carpenters lowest paid in country
- MS liberation therapy fund should end, Parrott says
- Teen dies after falling from moving vehicle
- Rescue attempt over for New Brunswick fishermen

