N.B. teen's prison files to be released
Ashley Smith killed herself while guards followed orders not to intervene
Last Updated: Monday, August 23, 2010 | 9:22 PM AT
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Corrections Canada has dropped its bid to keep the personal files of a teenage inmate who killed herself under wraps.
Ashley Smith is shown being restrained in a New Brunswick correctional facility in footage obtained by CBC's the fifth estate. (CBC)Ashley Smith of Moncton, N.B., choked herself with a piece of cloth in October 2007 while guards, under orders not to intervene, looked on. She was 19.
The Canadian Association of Elizabeth Fry Societies, a non-profit advocacy group for federally sentenced women, had applied for the documents on Smith's behalf before she died in prison in Kitchener, Ont.
In April, Federal Court Justice Michael Kelen ordered the Correctional Service to hand over the nearly 300 pages of records about Smith, including numerous assessments, her transfer and violent-incident records, criminal charge sheet and documents about her "maximum" security risk classification.
He said Corrections Canada had breached the Privacy Act in not giving Smith her records. Smith's death and the subsequent RCMP investigation into the conduct of prison staff were not valid reasons to withhold the documents from the Elizabeth Fry Societies, the judge said.
Smith had complained of poor treatment by the Correctional Service, alleging an assault, lack of psychiatric care and frequent transfers among prisons and treatment facilities across Canada.
Death was 'entirely preventable'
Smith was only 13 when she was charged with minor offences and entered the youth correctional system. Over the next six years, she went from problem to problem and institution to institution.
Prison ombudsman Howard Sapers found she was moved 17 times in just 11 months. In a 2009 report, the correctional investigator criticized the prison service for failing to give Smith proper care and protection and pressed it to make changes to prevent similar tragedies.
Sapers said Smith's death was the "entirely preventable" result of a series of systemic failures.
Smith died of asphyxiation in her cell in a federal prison near Kitchener, Ont., in 2007. (Courtesy of Ashley Smith's family) Despite her years in the youth correctional system and her history of violence and self-harm, Smith never received a comprehensive psychological assessment in federal custody, Sapers found.
Elizabeth Fry executive director Kim Pate said she wants to see Smith's 291-page file to glean any lessons.
The prison service originally announced it would appeal Kelen's decision on the documents but quietly abandoned the challenge later.
A spokesman for Public Safety Minister Vic Toews, the cabinet member responsible for corrections, declined to comment Monday on the reasons for dropping the bid, citing a lawsuit by Smith's family that is still before the courts.
Smith's records are to be disclosed to the Elizabeth Fry Societies by Sept. 17.
A federal court order issued Monday makes it clear the files will include material from the last few months of Smith's life as well as earlier records.
"In many respects, getting this last piece of information is important because without it you couldn't paint the full picture," said lawyer Kris Klein, who represented the advocacy group in court. "You only had an incomplete picture of what had happened to her."
The Privacy Act allows individuals to request information about them held by federal agencies, including the Correctional Service.
Privacy requests are supposed to be answered within 30 days, but the service took a 30-day extension. It missed that deadline, and the request had gone unanswered when Smith died — 123 days after her initial application.
The Correctional Service told the court such delays "happen all the time."
With files from The Canadian PressShare Tools
Latest New Brunswick News Headlines
- 'Unauthorized' pension change to be reversed
- Saint John's outgoing deputy mayor says an "unauthorized change" to the city's pension plan that would have benefitted the city's top earners if they retired early will be reversed. more »
- Fredericton invites citizens to weigh-in on new bylaw
- The City of Fredericton is inviting citizens to have their say on the municipality's new zoning bylaw. more »
- Workers' EI history to affect claim under new rules
- Human Resources Minister Diane Finley has announced details about the government's planned changes to employment insurance that would tighten the rules for Canadians collecting the benefit. more »
- 8 views on EI changes: 'political football' or 'eHarmony'?
- Human Resources Minister Diane Finley released more details of the government's plans for reforming employment insurance Thursday. Here's a sample of the reaction. more »
Top News Headlines
- Quebec faces mounting pressure amid student crisis
- The morning after nearly 700 people were arrested in protests in Montreal and Quebec City, Jean Charest announced he has replaced his top aide with his former right-hand man. more »
- Reclaiming the dead on Mt. Everest

- The difficulty, danger and expense of removing the bodies of climbers who died in Mount Everest's "death zone" mean most of the dead remain on the mountain as a stark reminder to other climbers of the risks. more »
- Conservatives move again to have robocalls suits tossed
- The Conservative Party has filed a second motion to dismiss the robocalls lawsuits filed by the left-leaning Council of Canadians, calling council chairperson Maude Barlow a 'virulent critic' of Prime Minister Stephen Harper who has 'orchestrated' the litigation. more »
- Suspect arrested in decades old N.Y. missing boy case
- A man has been arrested in the 1979 disappearance of a six-year-old New York City boy, in the first arrest ever made in a case that helped give rise to the nation's missing-children movement. more »
- Man dies after assault at house party
- 'Unauthorized' pension change to be reversed
- Workers' EI history to affect claim under new rules
- 300 litres of heavy water spilled at Point Lepreau
- Saint John managers ‘duped’ council, says deputy mayor
- Scrap metal plant sparks noise complaints
- Moose on the loose shot in Fredericton
- Food safety course necessary, trainer says
- Plastic bag fees should be legislated, council says

