N.B. premier threatens to sue Ottawa over Point Lepreau reactor
Graham wants feds to cover cost overruns of stalled refurbishment
Last Updated: Tuesday, January 12, 2010 | 12:37 PM AT
CBC News
IN DEPTH: Point Lepreau
Internal links
- IN DEPTH: Energy
- N.B. reactor upgrade delayed again
- Lepreau refurbishment misses another target
- N.B. premier threatens to sue Ottawa over Point Lepreau reactor
- AECL says N.B. reactor delay now 16 months
- Graham pressures Harper for Point Lepreau deadline
- AECL showing 'lack of focus' on Point Lepreau: Graham
- Point Lepreau refurbishment 9 months late
- Costly Lepreau nuclear plant refit may extend into 2010: VP
- Removing radioactive tubes causes delay in Point Lepreau overhaul
- AECL paying out $100M for Point Lepreau, Bruce refurbishment delays
- Point Lepreau delays will cost $70M to $90M: NB Power
- More delays in Point Lepreau refurbishment: NB Power
- Point Lepreau refurbishment slipping behind schedule
- 'Pain all around' from turbine fall into harbour: NB Power CEO
- N.B. to refurbish aging nuclear plant
- Ottawa rejects New Brunswick nuke funding
- Rebuilding NB nuclear plant '$1.4 billion question'
- Debate over Lepreau future continues
External links
- NB Power's website
- Point Lepreau refurbishment project website
- DOCUMENT: June 30 Point Lepreau Refurbishment Report
- Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd.'s website
- N.B. government decides to proceed with the Point Lepreau refurbishment project
- DOCUMENT: Robin Jeffrey's 2004 review of the Point Lepreau refurbishment project
N.B. Premier Shawn Graham is threatening to sue the federal government over delays in the refurbishment of the Point Lepreau nuclear reactor. (CBC)N.B. Premier Shawn Graham is again threatening to take legal action against the federal government if it doesn't cover the cost overruns of the $1.4-billion refurbishment of the Point Lepreau nuclear power plant.
Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. has already announced the project is 16 months behind schedule and that the nuclear reactor, Atlantic Canada's only one, is not expected to come back on line until February 2011.
CBC News reported last week that the Point Lepreau reactor is again running into problems, this time with the installation of the calandria tubes. The tubes contain smaller pressure tubes that hold the uranium bundles that fuel the reactor.
An AECL spokesman said the problem won't further delay the project because enough of a buffer was built into the new timeline to account for any additional problems.
However, Graham told reporters on Monday that AECL is not living up to its contract and that could result in a court fight.
"We want to continue dialoguing with the government of Canada, which is an extension of AECL. This is a government of Canada responsibility," Graham said.
"But I've been very clear if we can not come to an end result that benefits the ratepayers of New Brunswick, then we will commence legal action, and we feel strongly that we have a solid case to stand on."
Only "eight or nine" of the 380 new calandria tubes have been installed, according to AECL.
The work started nearly three weeks ago, and only about five weeks have been set aside for this phase of the project.
The problem is that one of the calandria tubes did not fit properly. The engineers have since decided to skip over that problem tube and come back to it later to keep the job moving, AECL said.
Feds will only pay contract costs
It has been estimated that NB Power will have to pay $1 million a day to purchase replacement power while the reactor is not in service.
Graham has twice written to Prime Minister Stephen Harper insisting that New Brunswick should not be left paying for any new costs associated with the refurbishment. Harper has said the federal government will only pay what it is obligated under the existing agreements.
Energy Minister Jack Keir said in October that the New Brunswick government would consider legal action to recoup cost overruns associated with the world's first Candu-6 refurbishment project.
When the former Progressive Conservative government pushed ahead with the project in 2005, the province renegotiated a series of retubing and refurbishment contracts with AECL.
The renegotiated contracts included stiffer penalties on AECL if the project was not completed on time. NB Power also took out insurance in case of any setbacks at the reactor.
Share Tools
Latest New Brunswick News Headlines
- SWN may get frosty reception, says mayor
- Southwestern Resources Canada may not be well received when it begins seismic testing for shale gas in Kent County this spring, says one area mayor. more »
- Bodyguard hired for bully victim in Fredericton
- A Fredericton girl was bullied so badly at school that her mother hired a bodyguard to protect her. more »
- Fredericton Police warn of bank scam
- Fredericton residents are being warned of a new scam where a man is posing as a local bank investigator. more »
- Special needs cats hold Valentine's Day Skype date
- Fredericton's famous Tiny the cat and Edmonton's Valentina held a special Valentine's Day Skype date as the two special needs felines recover from their health issues. more »
Top News Headlines
- Immigrants the proudest Canadians, poll suggests

- Most Canadians feel immigrants are just as likely to be good Canadian citizens as people who were born here and don't object to them keeping their original citizenship, according to a recent Environics survey. more »
- NDP MPs urged to scrap gun registry in final vote
- Public Safety Minister Vic Toews is urging opposition MPs to break party ranks and side with the government during tonight's vote on scrapping the long-gun registry. more »
- Honduras prison fire kills hundreds
- Trapped inmates screamed from their cells as a fire swept through a Honduran prison, killing at least 300 inmates in one of the world's deadliest fires in decades, authorities said Wednesday. more »
- Iran trying to 'distract attention' from sanctions
- The United States says Iran is lashing out at the world to distract attention from the damage that international sanctions are having at home. more »
- Police ID body found on Kingston Peninsula
- Saint John mulls cutting pension guarantees
- Parking shortage at Moncton Hospital
- Special needs cats hold Valentine's Day Skype date
- Eastern communities question census results
- Fredericton Police warn of bank scam
- SWN to resume seismic testing
- Moncton teen gets prison for cabbie attack
- Saint John pension deficit blame will be exposed, court hears

