Related
In depth: Afghan detainees
Features
- Who's who: Officials named in Colvin's testimony
- Timeline: Afghan prisoner transfers
- Background: Afghan detainees
- Blog coverage: Inside Politics
- Background: The history of law surrounding torture
- Audio interview: Helen Colvin on her son's experience (8:33)
Analysis
Key developments
Susan Short says the military should have told her that they handed the suspects in her husband's death over to Afghan authorities and lost track of them. (CBC)A Fredericton military widow says she feels betrayed by the Canadian Forces and federal government.
Susan Short was reacting to being told by CBC News that the military has no idea what happened to the men suspected of killing her husband in 2003.
Sgt. Robert Alan Short, 42, was one of the first two Canadian soldiers killed in Afghanistan.
He and Cpl. Robbie Christopher Beerenfenger, 29, of Ottawa died and three others were injured when their vehicle hit a landmine in Kabul.
'I am so disappointed in my government.'— Susan Short, military widow
Two men were arrested in connection with the bombing. But sources have told CBC News that the Canadian Forces turned the men over to Afghan authorities and lost track of them.
Susan Short said she felt she should have been told by the military.
"I feel like I have a right to know," she said, fighting back tears. "I would have thought that if they had found out exactly who had killed my husband that they would have gotten them to stand accountable. It amazes me that they found out who it was and just let them be.
"I am so disappointed in my government."
Political decision
Military analyst Mercedes Stephenson said it would have been a political decision to hand the prisoners over to Afghan authorities, and Canada had few options.
"At the time, Canada had no appetite to have prisoners on their hands of their own, which would have meant that we would have had to run our own prison camps," said Stephenson, a national media commentator on defence matters.
The "optics" of handing prisoners over to the U.S. would also have been considered, since this happened in the aftermath of Abu Ghraib, the Baghdad prison where inmates were abused by U.S. soldiers, she said.
Canadians didn't like seeing prisoners turned over to Americans, Stephenson said.
"And it caused a huge political kerfuffle here at home. The decision was made that the best thing to do was hand prisoners over to Afghan authorities."
Asked why the prisoners were not returned to Canada to face trial, Stephenson said there were concerns that some of the techniques used by the intelligence agencies would be revealed under cross-examination.
"So rather than risk revealing those techniques, the decision was not to try them here and to instead turn them over to the Afghan government."
Three soldiers injured in the blast that killed Short's husband were Cpl. Cameron Lee Laidlaw, 25, of Oromocto; Master Cpl. Jason Cory Hamilton, 33, of Regina; and Cpl. Thomas Stirling, 23, of Assiniboia, Sask.
All five soldiers were with the 3rd Battalion, Royal Canadian Regiment, based in Petawawa, Ont.
Share Tools
Latest New Brunswick News Headlines
- PCs to refund Horizon Health donation
- The New Brunswick Progressive Conservative Party has vowed to be clearer about future fundraisers after Horizon Health Network officials claim they didn't realize money they spent on tickets for an event were going to the party. more »
- Wetlands announcement disappointing, say environmentalists
- Environmentalists are disappointed with what they say is a lack of detail in the provincial government's long-awaited wetlands announcement Monday afternoon in Saint John. more »
- Meth, cash seized in Bouctouche
- A 66-year-old Bouctouche woman is facing drug-related charges after police raided a home on Highway 515. more »
- Moncton seniors protest no-pet policy
- About 15 seniors gathered outside Social Development Minister Sue Stultz's constituency office in Moncton to protest a policy that could force seniors to give up their pets or move out of their subsidized housing units. more »
Top News Headlines
- HMCS Corner Brook collision damage extensive
- The damage done to HMCS Corner Brook when it hit the ocean floor off B.C.'s coast last summer was more extensive than first reported, CBC News has learned by obtaining exclusive pictures of the submarine. more »
- Mandatory gun sentence struck down by Ontario judge
- An Ontario Superior Court judge has struck down a mandatory minimum sentence for a first offence of possessing a loaded firearm. more »
- UN warns of civil war in Syria
- Syrian government forces renewed their assault on the rebellious city of Homs on Tuesday, activists said, as the UN human rights chief raised fears of civil war. more »
- U.S. gets 1st hard look at future China leader
- Washington gets its first hard look Tuesday at Xi Jinping, the man destined to lead China in the coming decade, during which the global powers probably will see their economic ties grow. more »
- Father, son recall close call on ice road
- Meth, cash seized in Bouctouche
- Moncton seniors protest no-pet policy
- Wetlands announcement disappointing, say environmentalists
- PCs to refund Horizon Health donation
- Kennebecasis River ice road re-opened
- Bathurst plane crash under review
- 3 killed in 2 N.B. car crashes
- Create-your-own-app product to launch in Moncton

