N.B. Court of Appeal paves way for Morgentaler's lawsuit
Crusading doctor wants medicare to pay for abortions at his Fredericton clinic
Last Updated: Thursday, May 21, 2009 | 7:31 PM AT
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
- TIMELINE: Abortion in Canada
- IN DEPTH: Morgentaler
- N.B. health minister 'not entirely' comfortable enforcing abortion laws
- Court hears appeal in Morgentaler's fight against N.B. government
- N.B. court gives nod to Morgentaler's challenge
- N.B. challenges Morgentaler's right to sue over abortion policy
- Morgentaler to sue N.B. over abortion costs
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Dr. Henry Morgentaler was named to the Order of Canada in 2008. (Canadian Press)The New Brunswick Court of Appeal paved the way Thursday for Dr. Henry Morgentaler to sue the province for refusing to pay for abortions at his private clinic in Fredericton.
"I accuse the government of New Brunswick of being sexist, male chauvinist, of victimizing and oppressing women," Morgentaler said in 2002 when he announced his lawsuit.
Morgentaler wants medicare to pay for abortions at his clinic, while the province says it only has to pay for abortions approved by two physicians and performed in hospitals. Currently, women pay the $750 fee at Morgentaler's clinic themselves.
The province argued Morgentaler couldn't sue on the issue because it affects women, not him. In January, after a judge ruled in Morgentaler's favour, the province appealed the decision. On Thursday, three appeal judges also ruled in Morgentaler's favour.
The province had argued it would be better if the lawsuit was launched by a woman who had been forced to pay for a clinic abortion.
Chief Justice Ernest Drapeau said that argument doesn't pass muster. None of the many women who have had abortions at Morgentaler's Fredericton clinic in the past 15 years has come forward to file a lawsuit, he noted.
"That state of affairs is likely the product of two factors operating in tandem: the prohibitive cost of litigation and the intimate and private nature [of choosing to have an abortion]," wrote Drapeau.
"Dr. Morgentaler brings to the judicial arena financial resources and legal expertise which will undoubtedly help level the playing field and greatly improves the chances that any judicial decision on the merits is fully informed both factually and legally."
Morgentaler's long history of legal battles over abortion means his lawsuit is the only reasonable way to resolve the issue in court, he added.
The province could still appeal to the Supreme Court. If not, Thursday's decision would pave the way for Morgentaler's lawsuit to finally go ahead.
Share Tools
Latest New Brunswick News Headlines
- East Coast braces for severe weather
- Environment Canada issued weather warnings early Saturday afternoon across much of Atlantic Canada and Quebec. more »
- Moncton seniors denied their pets
- The province has ordered a group of Moncton seniors living in a subsidized housing unit to give up their pets or move out. more »
- Attawapiskat sites not ready for modular homes
- The first two of 22 modular homes promised by the federal government to Attawapiskat are on their way to the remote northern Ontario community, but the minister handling the Aboriginal Affairs portfolio is expressing concern over the "readiness" of the lots. more »
- Society slams transfer of female inmates to youth jail

- The Elizabeth Fry Society is concerned that a decision to move incarcerated women to the Miramichi Youth Centre is not fair because it will cut off the women from their family and friends. more »
Top News Headlines
- Quebec man charged with killing mother, 2 nieces
- A 35-year-old man has been charged with three counts of first-degree murder in connection with the deaths of his mother and two young nieces in Quebec's Eastern Townships. more »
- Manitoba trailer fire kills 4
- Four people are dead after an early-morning fire quickly engulfed a residential trailer in Selkirk, Man. more »
- Harper's China visit ends with panda pact

- Prime Minister Stephen Harper wrapped up a visit to China aimed seeking new investments by officially announcing that Beijing will loan two of the country's prized giant pandas to Canadian zoos. more »
- Attawapiskat sites not ready for modular homes
- The first two of 22 modular homes promised by the federal government to Attawapiskat are on their way to the remote northern Ontario community, but the minister handling the Aboriginal Affairs portfolio is expressing concern over the "readiness" of the lots. more »
- East Coast braces for severe weather
- Moncton seniors denied their pets
- Attawapiskat sites not ready for modular homes
- Occupy Fredericton eviction legality questioned
- Prohibited driver gets jail for 6th offence
- Snowblower that caused stir on Kijiji sold
- Society slams transfer of female inmates to youth jail
- Thrift store forced out after renovations
- Murder-suicide confirmed in northern N.B. deaths

