N.B. early French immersion cuts 'unfair and unreasonable': judge
Education minister says he'll announce program's fate in August
Last Updated: Wednesday, June 11, 2008 | 5:32 PM AT
The New Brunswick government's decision to scrap early French immersion programs was quashed for at least a few months by a provincial court judge Wednesday.
Justice Hugh McLellan, of the Court of the Queen's Bench in Saint John, ruled there should be a judicial review into the cancellation of the early French immersion program, which was offered to students entering Grade 1.
In his seven-page decision, McLellan wrote that the decision to cut the French education program was "unfair and unreasonable."
"The application for judicial review is allowed. The minister's decision to phase out early French immersion is removed into the court and quashed."
Education Minister Kelly Lamrock announced in March that the province was cutting the program in favour of a five-month intensive French program for all Grade 5 students, effective this coming September. In Grade 6, the students would then have the choice of moving into a late immersion program or continuing to take French as a single-class mandatory subject until they graduate from high school.
"The government just got handed a speeding ticket," Michael Wilcott of Citizens for Educational Choice said after the judge's decision.
Breach of contract alleged
The group had called on the court to delay the program's cancellation. The court challenge dealt with two specific children who are currently enrolled in kindergarten and registered to start early French immersion in the fall, but the case will affect the entire province.
Lawyers for parents Paula Small and Patrick Ryan, whose children were registered for the program in February, also argued that allowing parents to enroll their children in the program and then later cancelling it amounted to a breach of contract.
McLellan said that parents who had enrolled their children in the program for the fall "had a reasonable and legitimate expectation that program would not be cut without them having a real opportunity to be heard by the minister."
The parents' lawyer also argued the cuts violated the right to minority language education that is enshrined in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. McLellan rejected this argument.
The province's lawyers argued there was no breach of the charter and there was plenty of time for parents to have their say.
McLellan said any future decisions on the program "should be made in accordance with the principles of fairness after an appropriate opportunity for interested citizens and organized groups to be heard."
Jane Keith, of Canadian Parents for French in New Brunswick, said that she hoped Lamrock would not try to work around the court decision in order to axe early immersion in September.
"It wouldn't be smart for him to do so, given that the court has said it wasn't a proper review, it wasn't based on sound decisions and parents weren't given a chance to have input," she said.
Lamrock says he'll announce future of program in August
Later Wednesday, Lamrock said he would announce the fate of the program in early August.
He said he "accepts" the judge's "good advice" and that he was pleased the judge had affirmed that the government has the right to change the education system and that the changes were permitted under the Charter.
Lamrock said he would set up a website and consult with those affected by the decision. The consultations are set to continue until July 25, with the announcement on whether the program will go ahead in September to be announced on August 5.
He said the six-week consultation period will allow the government "to hear if there are other ideas from New Brunswickers as to how we can meet our goals. For example, making sure we have a higher rate of participation in immersion programs, making sure we have more bilingual graduates, not fewer, making sure we have more equality and equality of access to bilingual access. These are important questions."
Lamrock said the website and discussion document would be ready by the end of the week. When asked why this process was not conducted initially, he said it was an effort to make a real change after looking at numerous reports.
"I was very comfortable that at the time that I had heard everything," he said, adding he was prepared to hear alternate proposals and ideas.
He said he hoped there would be "good conversation" over the next few weeks and that he would keep an open mind.
He said a decision in early August would still leave time to implement his proposals from March for the start of the school year. He said whether another plan could be implemented on this timeline would depend on the details of the alternate plan.
Conservative education critic Madeleine Dube said the Liberal government is just waiting six weeks to please the court and that she doubts the final decision will change.With files from the Canadian Press
Latest New Brunswick News Headlines
- 'Sense of panic' surrounded Ashley Smith
- The prison where Ashley Smith died had a sense of panic around the teenager, an inquest heard Tuesday. more »
- Conservatives closer to selling government airplane
- New Brunswick's Progressive Conservative government is a step closer to fulfilling a promise to sell the government-owned airplane used by the premier and members of cabinet. more »
- Catastrophic drug plan coming by fall, health minister says
- New Brunswick's health minister says he expects to begin rolling out parts of a catastrophic drug program as early as this fall. more »
- Tory minister denies nixing class trip to Trudeau rally
- New Brunswick's education minister is defending the decision earlier this year to cancel a high school class trip to see a federal Liberal leadership campaign event hosted by Justin Trudeau. more »
Top News Headlines
- Most groups don't want return of Trudeau speaking fees
- Most of the 17 charitable and other organizations that have paid speaking fees to Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau during his time as an MP say they aren't interested in having their fees returned, despite Trudeau's offer on the weekend to reimburse any organization unhappy with his services. more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- Canada to send peacekeeping troops to Haiti
- A handful of Canadian troops are about to take part in peacekeeping operation in Haiti, under the command of Brazilian forces, in a long-delayed mission that has been kept inexplicably low on the political radar. more »
- Google asks secret court to lift gag on surveillance
- Google is asking the secretive Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court to lift its long-standing gag order on how often the company is asked to turn over data about its customers to the U.S. government. more »
- Tory minister denies nixing class trip to Trudeau rally
- Miramichi student mourned after fatal crash
- Thieves steal 9-metre rowing dock in Fredericton
- Province urged to deal with shale-gas protests
- Saint John pushes regional police force
- Fredericton's only French radio station may close
- FHS students arrive in style to their prom
- CenterBeam sale 'exciting news,' says CEO
- Moncton downtown centre moves ahead