Brian Gallant promises auditor general more money for Atcon probe

Less than a day after Speaker Chris Collins insisted Auditor General Kim MacPherson should abandon plans to overspend her budget, Premier Brian Gallant has dismissed that position.

Auditor General Kim MacPherson's request for extra funds to audit Atcon will not be refused, premier says

Premier Brian Gallant says Auditor General Kim MacPherson's request for more money to investigate where the $70 million given to Atcon went will be taken seriously. (CBC)

Less than a day after Speaker Chris Collins insisted Auditor General Kim MacPherson should abandon plans to overspend her budget, Premier Brian Gallant has dismissed that position.

The premier told reporters his government will now likely offer MacPherson's office more money. The auditor general has requested more funds in order to conduct a second audit into the Atcon loan fiasco.

"We're very open to listen and I think we're very open to giving the auditor general the resources she believes she needs," Gallant told reporters on Tuesday.

Gallant's statement reverses a December announcement that no new money would be made available and appeared to undermine Collins who had been taking a hard line with MacPherson.

Collins insisted on Monday the Legislature, not the premier, had the authority to deal with the issue.

"I am not government. I am manager for the budgets of the Legislative Assembly and this falls under my category," said Collins.

Refused extra funding

MacPherson has continued her investigation into the Atcon matter despite being told by the provincial government she would receive no extra funding. (CBC)
MacPherson has been on a collision course with the province over her budget since last winter when she was refused extra funding to undertake an in-depth audit of the 2010 bankruptcy of the former Atcon construction company in Miramichi.

The province lost $70 million in Atcon's collapse and although it happened long before Gallant entered the Legislature, several of his current cabinet members were involved in decisions to fund the company. 

MacPherson made it clear she wants to get to the bottom of what happened.

"It is my intention to table an independent report responding to a number of the unanswered questions, including the most common question my office receives from concerned citizens on the Atcon file, 'Where did $70 million of taxpayers' money go?'," MacPherson said in a statement last December.

But Liberal cabinet minister Roger Melanson told the Legislature the following day MacPherson would receive none of the extra money she said she needed to pursue the Atcon issue.

"She has a budget and she will have to work within that budget," said Melanson.

Continued work

Legislature Speaker Chris Collins said there would be no extra money for MacPherson's continued investigation into where the $70 million given to Atcon went. (CBC)
Despite that refusal MacPherson began the work anyway and this summer informed Legislature officials her office would likely overspend its budget this year by $400,000 because of the Atcon probe.

On Monday, Collins said MacPherson was out of line and would have to answer to the body that is supposed to independently control her budget, the 10 MLA committee of the Legislature which he chairs.

"We're appealing to the auditor general's accounting nature and trying to work this out so she doesn't come in over budget. Otherwise it will have to be all determined by the Legislative Administration Committee," said Collins.

But Gallant's intervention appears to usurp Collins' responsibility to deal with the issue. 

The premier said government expects MacPherson to detail exactly how much money she wants and formally request it, but there will be no more efforts to stop her getting it once that happens.

"We foresee probably no problem," said Gallant. 

"We will certainly take her request, once we hopefully formally get it, very seriously."

About the Author

Robert Jones


Robert Jones has been a reporter and producer with CBC New Brunswick since 1990. His investigative reports on petroleum pricing in New Brunswick won several regional and national awards and led to the adoption of price regulation in 2006.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.