Lorneville causeway flagged for repairs 7 years ago

New Brunswick’s transportation minister said the partial collapse of the Lorneville causeway this week caught his department by surprise, despite it being flagged for repairs seven years ago but never fixed.

Lorneville bridge closes after structural failure

New Brunswick's Auditor General Kim MacPherson published a report on 293 bridge structures in New Brunswick and the Lorneville Creek bridge tied for the lowest score. It scored only one point on the province's 100 point rating system. (CBC)

New Brunswick’s transportation minister said the partial collapse of the Lorneville Creek causeway caught his department by surprise, despite it being flagged for repairs seven years ago but never fixed.

On Friday, the causeway remained impassable with a two-metre deep hole in the southbound lane. Pieces of the metal culvert that caused the road failure sat crumpled nearby on the Lorenville mudflats.

Its failure was unforeseeable, according to Transportation Minister Claude Williams

"We're dealing with Mother Nature and we do regular inspections, but again we cannot control or evaluate or predict the magnitude or the force or the damage that happens when we deal with those situations,” he said.

The culvert gave way last week and Williams blames a storm and tidal surge for triggering the damage.

But locals like Lorneville Lobster Shop owner Karen McCavour said the province can't credibly claim to be surprised by what happened.

"They knew the road was getting bad. The dip in the culvert has been known since June. Everybody's been talking about it. Pieces of the culvert are out in the mud flats and they were warned last week with the high tides coming it was going to undermine and sure enough it undermined,” she said.

The province has almost 300 bridges listed in poor condition, and the auditor general flagged the Lorneville Creek causeway as one of the worst. It scored only one point on the 100 point bridge rating system. A 60 is considered poor.

That put Lorneville’s bridge on the province's priority list for repairs seven years ago, but nothing happened.

Saint John council not warned 

"This is stuff that needs to get taken care of,” said Saint John Coun. Greg Norton, who represents the Lorneville area.

He said the city was never told how bad the province's inspection reports had become.

"I would suggest the more eyes on that information and the more people who have access to that information  the better we are equipped to take care of things like this,” he said.

“As a result, we don't have an inconvenience like this where we have jersey barriers preventing people from crossing a bridge.”

The province said it's unsure if the causeway can be fixed this winter so it might have to wait until spring

Residents will have to use the back roads until it can be repaired

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.