Horizon Health's John McGarry says dramatic change needed now

Horizon Health Network CEO John McGarry says it is time to move away from the concept that all care must occur in hospitals.

Health authority wants province to close hospitals and emergency rooms and deliver care differently

Horizon Health Network president John McGarry says changes need to be made in the way health care is carried out in New Brunswick. (CBC)

Horizon Health Network CEO John McGarry says it is time to move away from the concept that all care must occur in hospitals.

"We have seen a shift in demography coming for some time — an aging population, southern migration within the province, and the shift from rural to urban living," McGarry writes in a commentary.

The health of our population is not getting better for the dollars that we're spending. It's like banging your head against the wall.- John McGarry, Horizon Health CEO

"There are negative health impacts associated with our climbing poverty rate; the incidence of chronic diseases in our province is at an all-time high. Clearly, we need better preventive, primary, long-term and palliative care."

McGarry says it is time to embrace a new way of thinking about health care in our province, which he believes should include fewer emergency rooms and improved care in communities.

"I think we need to start looking at our infrastructure and say, 'If we came from Mars to New Brunswick and we looked at this province and the way it's laid out, is this the way we would design a system? Would we put hospitals where they are now? Would they be the same size? Would they have the same programs?'"

The constant challenge of seniors who are in hospital beds because there are no long-term care beds available is a real and immediate problem, but McGarry says changes must go beyond that.

"We will always be here to look after the seniors, but the fact is that we have a bigger mission and it is not just to provide hospital services or residential care for seniors, it is much beyond that."

More than half of ER visits unnecessary 

McGarry understands the angst that communities feel when he suggests cuts to local hospitals, but says primary care has changed and it should be offered outside of hospitals.
John McGarry, CEO of Horizon Health Network, says it is time to provide better primary care outside of hospitals. He says 60 per cent of patients who visit emergency rooms are there not because they are experiencing an emergency, but because they have no where else to go. (CBC)
He says about 60 per cent of visits to New Brunswick's more than 20 emergency rooms aren't from people experiencing a health emergency but rather from people who have no where else to go.

"One ... night shift in [all 22 New Brunswick emergency rooms] just for doctors is $550,000 — that's not talking about the nurses and all the other services that go with that," McGarry said.

"Sixty per cent of the visits really don't have to be there if you would serve them someplace else in a better environment."

He says the amount the province spends will likely never decrease, but the way the money is spent should change.

"The health of our population is not getting better for the dollars that we're spending. It's like banging your head against the wall. You're always going to feel the same at the end. If you just keep doing the same thing you're always going to get the same results so we do need to spend our money differently."

McGarry cautions premier

The Gallant government will release its budget on Feb. 2, and Premier Brian Gallant has said New Brunswickers are asking him to protect health care and education from cuts as the province struggles to reduce its deficit.

 I think we have some big changes that need to be made.- John McGarry, Horizon Health CEO

"I hear the premier talking about health care is going to be protected — I hope he's talking about funding issues and not there will be no changes in health care because I think we have some big changes that need to be made," McGarry said.

By closing some hospitals and freeing up money, he argues more could be invested in community health care.

"And prove to people that this is a better way of providing health to a population so I think we will be seeing hopefully some changes in our hospital infrastructure ... let's face it — health care just can't be designed the way it was in the 60s and 70s and 80s and still be effective." 

McGarry says the province must take a long-term view and begin measuring the health of the population over ten years and then making investments that will improve it.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.