David Alward's daycare election promise falls short

A key social policy commitment made by the Progressive Conservatives in the 2010 election campaign to increase daycare spaces in the province by 50 per cent has come up more than 5,300 spots short of that target, new figures show.

Figures show 4,751 daycare spaces have been created, short of the promised 10,087 spaces

A key social policy commitment made by the Progressive Conservatives in the 2010 election campaign to increase daycare spaces in the province by 50 per cent has come up more than 5,300 spots short of that target, new figures show.

Education Minister Marie-Claude Blais said the failure to establish even half of the daycare spaces promised during the election does not constitute a broken promise. (CBC)
The Department of Education released new figures to CBC News that show there has been an increase of 4,751 daycare spaces since the election of the Alward government in 2010, including 346 spaces specifically for infants under the age of two. 

The Progressive Conservatives had promised to create 10,087 spaces, including 677 spots for infants.

Education and Early Childhood Development Minister Marie-Claude Blais said the failure to establish even half of the daycare spaces promised during the election does not constitute a broken promise.

"Certainly it was a number that we wanted to target," said Blais. 

"We had set up for an achievement. We're still working towards the achievement."

Daycare has been an issue in the last two provincial elections. Former premier Shawn Graham's Liberal government presided over the creation of 6,500 new daycare spots following the 2006 election and promised to create another 7,000 as he campaigned in 2010.

But David Alward dismissed the Liberal record as inadequate and promised during the election campaign to spend $35 million to greatly expand available spaces in the province from 19,913 to 30,000 in his first term.

David Alward's Progressive Conservatives promised to increase the number of licensed childcare spots to 30,000. (CBC)
"The Graham government hasn't invested enough to make a real difference in additional spaces over the past 4 years," Alward told a crowd of preschoolers and their parents at a Dieppe daycare during the first week of the campaign.

"We will create 50 per cent more childcare spaces bringing the provincial total of childcare spaces to 30,000," he said in August 2010. 

"What a great plan."

If the government were able to step it up a little bit more in those [middle] income areas — I think it would help a lot. It would help the parents and I think more of them would look at putting their children in.- Penny Buck

New figures show that as of May 1, the provincial government was well short of that target promised in the 2010 election campaign with a total of 24,644 licensed child-care spots 

The education department says $15.8 million was spent during the government's first three years on child-care wage subsidies, parental assistance and other programs to enhance daycare.

But significant barriers exist for many parents, especially middle income families who don't qualify for financial help. 

A typical daycare spot in New Brunswick costs between $700 and $800 per month per child.  

Penny Buck, a Saint John daycare operator, says many working parents, especially those with more than one child, find the cost of child care difficult to afford. 

"It can be pretty expensive, you know sometimes you probably weigh the options of whether it’s worth it to you to work or not " said Buck. 

"If the government were able to step it up a little bit more in those [middle] income areas — I think it would help a lot. It would help the parents and I think more of them would look at putting their children in."

About the Author

Robert Jones

Reporter

Robert Jones has been a reporter and producer with CBC New Brunswick since 1990. His investigative reports on petroleum pricing in New Brunswick won several regional and national awards and led to the adoption of price regulation in 2006.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.