Woman narrowly avoids crashing window on St-Laurent Blvd

The Plateau-Mont-Royal borough says a building at the corner of St-Laurent Boulevard and St-Viateur Street is completely safe. However, a woman who was nearly hit by a falling window isn't so sure.

Ashleigh Delaye pushed boyfriend out of way and ran after window fell out of semi-residential building

Ashleigh Delaye was nearly hit by a falling window pane last week at the corner of St-Viateur Street and St-Laurent Boulevard. (Shawn Apel/CBC)

The Plateau-Mont-Royal borough says a building at the corner of St-Laurent Boulevard and St-Viateur Street is completely safe.

A semi-residential building at the corner of St-Laurent Boulevard and St-Viateur Street had its wall removed more than a year ago. An inspector told CBC News that the lack of brick work around the windows could have contributed to the window falling. (Shawn Apel/CBC)

However, the woman who stood on the sidewalk below the building last week as a large window pane fell from the building toward her last week isn't so sure.

"I literally see the window falling down," AshleighDelaye told CBC Montreal's Daybreak. "And in this moment, I realize this was obviously a very dangerous situation. I kind of remember just telling my boyfriend to get back I pushed him in (to a doorway) and I just ran."

Delaye was unscathed, and said she didn't want to think about what almost happened to her.

Instead, she's wondering why the window fell out, and also when someone will force the building's owners to repair it. The building has been without its brick covering for more than a year.

"Montrealers need to get angry about this kind of thing," Delaye said. "It’s certainly ugly but it's more the issue that it’s becoming dangerous."

Building wall removed in 2013

The building has had an unusual 16 months, even before the window fell. The CBC has learned the fire department saw a bulge in the building's brick wall in February 2013, and borough officials subsequently ordered the entire wall removed.

Shards of glass remain on the sidewalk after a window fell out of a building in the Plateau-Mont-Royal borough. (Shawn Apel/CBC)

Since then the owners at a company called SSDL Properties haven't replaced the brick. The building has been covered in white polyethylene fabric for several months. The CBC called the company several times but did not get any calls back.

The borough did send the owners a notice telling them to re-brick the building two months ago, but that was for aesthetic reasons, according to borough officials. It's not clear if that notice included any sort of deadline.

"I don’t know if there is any sort of timetable for that," said borough spokesperson Michel Tanguay.

"Anyway the next step will be a ticket to the owner of the building," added Tanguay, who said he wasn't sure when that might happen. That step would, he said, include a fine of about $1,000.

Tanguay said the borough also inspected the building to make sure it was safe after the window fell out and concluded it was fine.

But Ian Towers, a home inspector with Inspectrum Residential Inspections, wasn't quite as sure. Towers visited the building and looked at its exterior for CBC, and said the window frame from which the pane of glass fell was clearly sagging. He said the lack of brick under the window frame could have contributed to that sagging.

"The framing around the window won’t be prone to sagging if there’s a concrete lintel around it,” he said. “With nothing there, then for sure that could cause some sagging,”

Towers said bricks probably would have helped in this case.

Meanwhile, tenants in the building are now worried about it, after 16 months of complaining to the owners about the lack of bricks.

“I mentioned it most of the time when I’m sending the cheques,” said DinanauthDamar, who owns a restaurant on the ground floor and lives upstairs.

“I keep asking them, 'When you going to fix?' I even threatened them; one time [I said] I’m not going to pay until you fix. They say, 'You’re not allowed to do that.' I say, 'OK.'” Damar said.

And AshleighDelaye, who got out of the way of the big pane of glass? She says the situation seems ridiculous and that someone the owner or the borough should have done something by now.

“A lot of people in the Mile End are saying, ‘I wonder what’s going on with this building.’ So maybe now they’ll do something about it,” she said.

About the Author

Shawn Apel

Shawn is the host of CBC's provincewide, interactive radio program, Radio Noon.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.