National Post loses secret source case
Civil liberties group says court decision a blow to press freedom
Last Updated: Friday, May 7, 2010 | 1:26 PM ET
The Grand-Mère Inn in Shawinigan was the focus of the National Post's investigation. (CBC)The Supreme Court of Canada says journalists have no constitutional right to protect confidential sources at all costs, in a ruling against the National Post that could have major implications for press freedom.
The top court ruled 8-1 against the newspaper and journalist Andrew McIntosh, in a case linked to the 10-year-old so-called Shawinigate scandal that involved former prime minister Jean Chrétien, a hotel in his home riding and questionable bank documents.
McIntosh and the Post were attempting to quash a search warrant issued nearly 10 years ago in the case that would have forced them to provide RCMP with the documents, which McIntosh obtained from a confidential source known as "X."
"The law should and does accept that in some situations, the public interest in protecting the secret source from disclosure outweighs other competing public interests – including criminal investigations," Justice Ian Binnie wrote on the Ottawa-based court's behalf, in a ruling released on Friday.
"In those circumstances, the courts will recognize an immunity against disclosure of sources to whom confidentiality has been promised."
McIntosh, who no longer works for the National Post, promised "X" confidentiality and stored the documents in a safe place.
RCMP sought the documents via a search warrant after the Business Development Bank of Canada called them forgeries.
The Supreme Court's justices said claims of immunity can be argued on a case-by-case basis, but there is no broad legal protection to shield sources. In certain cases, such as this one, the court said police investigation needs override confidentiality.
Brown envelope passed to paper
In 2000, the investigative reporter was looking at potential links between Chrétien and the Grand-Mère Inn, a hotel in his home riding of Shawinigan, Que.
McIntosh obtained the bank documents from "X" around this time, and the paperwork appeared to be internal loan forms connecting the inn to a Chrétien family corporation.
McIntosh has already testified his source told him the documents arrived by mail anonymously, and "X" passed them along, believing them to be real.
When the BDBC said the documents were forgeries, RCMP were called in and requested them for testing. The Mounties obtained a search warrant and assistance order asking the newspaper to assist in locating the documents.
Ontario's Superior Court struck both orders down, but the province's Court of Appeal later reinstated them.
Decision hurts press freedom: liberties association
The court decision has major implications for the journalist-source relationship, said the B.C. Civil Liberties Association (BCCLA), an intervener in the case.
"We all rely on that relationship to get the news and issues of great national importance, such as this one," said Tim Dickson, who acted as counsel for the BCCLA.
"It's because of the willingness of confidential sources to come forward. But they only come forward because they're promised confidentiality."
It's disappointing to see the country's highest court miss a chance to "set a high bar" for journalist-source relationships, Dickson added.
"That relationship is so important to freedom of the press, and having the news be brought out to the public."With files from The Canadian Press
Latest Montreal News Headlines
- Montreal council must pick new mayor after Applebaum resignation
- Montreal city council must select an interim mayor to replace Michael Applebaum, who resigned a day after being arrested by Quebec's anti-corruption unit. more »
- Hungary indicts ex-Montrealer on Nazi-era war crimes
- Hungarian prosecutors indict a 98-year-old former police officer for abusing Jews and assisting in their deportation to Nazi death camps during World War II. more »
- Canada to send peacekeeping troops to Haiti
- A handful of Canadian troops are about to take part in peacekeeping operation in Haiti, under the command of Brazilian forces, in a long-delayed mission that has been kept inexplicably low on the political radar. more »
- Quebec wants Haiti earthquake victims to stay in Canada
- The Quebec government is hoping Ottawa will allow thousands of Haitians who fled to Canada after the 2010 earthquake to stay in the country, many of them saying they have been living in limbo since arriving in Montreal. more »
Top News Headlines
- Senators call for 'zero tolerance' on harassment in RCMP
- The RCMP should amend its code of conduct to explicitly define and prohibit harassment, a Senate committee is recommending in a newly tabled report. more »
- Are e-cigarettes safe to puff?
- As electronic or e-cigarettes grow in popularity, some health advocates want them to be regulated. more »
- Most groups don't want return of Trudeau speaking fees
- Most of the 17 charitable and other organizations that have paid speaking fees to Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau during his time as an MP say they aren't interested in having their fees returned, despite Trudeau's offer on the weekend to reimburse any organization unhappy with his services. more »
- Google asks secret court to lift gag on surveillance
- Google is asking the secretive Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court to lift its long-standing gag order on how often the company is asked to turn over data about its customers to the U.S. government. more »
- Montreal mayor resigns amid corruption charges
- Quebec premier says Montreal mayor should resign
- Lawyer Mélanie Joly announces mayoral bid
- Construction strike halts major projects in Quebec
- Hungary indicts ex-Montrealer on Nazi-era war crimes
- Quebec white-collar workers angry with cuts
- Ex-Tory adviser Saulie Zajdel arrested in corruption probe
- Petite-Patrie fire forces a dozen people from their homes
- Quebec, Vermont make it easier to charge electric cars with new terminals