Quebec premier slams Harper's environment stance
Last Updated: Wednesday, December 23, 2009 | 3:47 PM ET
The Canadian Press
Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Quebec Premier Jean Charest are at odds on climate change policy. (Jacques Boissinot/Canadian Press) A war of words has erupted between Prime Minister Stephen Harper and the premier of Quebec, with Jean Charest tearing a strip off Ottawa's environmental performance.
In 25 years in politics, Charest says, he's never seen a federal government rely so heavily on the White House before taking a position on an issue, with Ottawa now saying it will model its climate policy on Washington's.
Charest says the Harper government has displayed hostility toward environmentalists.
And if there are any hard feelings after the Copenhagen climate summit, Charest says, it's the federal government's doing.
"They are totally responsible for what happened at Copenhagen," Charest said in an Tuesday interview with TVA, a French-language news network in Quebec.
He made the remarks after Harper, in his own interview with TVA, suggested provincial governments were wrong to drag their internal squabbling onto the world stage at Copenhagen.
Provinces argue about accountability
Quebec and Ontario argued at the international summit that they should not be made responsible for emissions from the oilsands.
'We can only have one voice at the negotiating table and it's only sovereign countries that can arrive at a consensus.'—Prime Minister Stephen Harper
Alberta Premier Ed Stelmach countered that the oilsands have enriched the rest of the country.
And the federal government declared that Canada's bargaining position was hardly being helped by the interprovincial slugfest being staged in the international arena.
Harper echoed that theme in his French-language year-end interview with TVA. "These perspectives don't have any place on the international stage," Harper said.
"We can only have one voice at the negotiating table and it's only sovereign countries that can arrive at a consensus."
But Charest swung back. He said it was his duty as premier to represent his province's interests.
Ottawa called hostile to environmentalists
Charest also told TVA that the Harper government had demonstrated hostility toward environmentalists.
'Why would I be silent at Copenhagen — I'd say one thing in Quebec and the opposite thing there? Defending Quebec's position is not working against Canada.'—Quebec Premier Jean Charest
Charest cited an on-camera argument between Harper press secretary Dimitri Soudas and Canadian environmentalist Steven Guilbeault.
That spat featured Soudas accusing Guilbeault, with cameras rolling next to them, of being behind a spoof designed to embarrass the Canadian government. That accusation enraged Guilbeault, and American pranksters later claimed responsibility for the stunt.
"You saw it like I did," Charest told TVA. "His press secretary attacking an environmentalist — on the basis of false information."
As for the suggestion that the provinces should have kept Canada's dirty laundry in Canada, Charest was dismissive.
"Mr. Harper wanted me to say nothing at Copenhagen? Why? Why would I be silent at Copenhagen — I'd say one thing in Quebec and the opposite thing there? Defending Quebec's position is not working against Canada."
Provinces concerned about true cost of oilsands
Several energy-consuming provinces fear they will be forced to make additional greenhouse-gas cuts to compensate for emissions growth in the oilsands.
They also fear that if Canada is seen as a laggard on climate change, the whole country could be slapped with punitive tariffs.
The position from Alberta is that the oilsands have pumped billions into other provinces' coffers and that should be taken into account while divvying up emissions targets.
As for Harper and Charest, theirs has been a rocky political marriage.
Harper's 2006 promise to fix an alleged fiscal imbalance and transfer money to the provinces was greeted warmly by Charest, and it helped the Tories get elected.
Charest's own fortunes subsequently rose — with his once-dismal popularity surging as he extracted concessions from Ottawa, including recognition of a Québécois nation.
But their relationship went south over time, as Harper took positions that were unpopular in Quebec on issues like arts funding, justice policy, and climate change.
Charest spoke out against those policies, perhaps winning him plaudits at home but losing him friends in Ottawa.
There had been signs in recent months, however, that their relationship was improving.
Share Tools
Latest Montreal News Headlines
- Former Expos catcher Gary Carter succumbs to brain cancer
- Hall of Fame catcher Gary Carter, who left an indelible mark on baseball in Canada during his 12 years with the Montreal Expos, died on Thursday. The man nicknamed "Kid" or "Kid Carter" for his ever-smiling face and cheerfulness is free from the inoperable brain cancer that sapped his energy and took his life at age 57. more »
- Arrests made in Montreal anti-government protest
- At least four people were arrested during a protest in front of Montreal's stock exchange. more »
- Montreal telemarketers in fraud case still making calls
- CBC News has learned that no government agency has taken legal action to try to stop a Montreal-based telemarketing company accused of defrauding thousands of small businesses. more »
- Man shot by Montreal police dies
- A man in his thirties is dead after being shot by Montreal police Thursday morning. more »
- Gordon Ramsay splits from Montreal BBQ
- Stick a fork in it — the barbecue chicken venture of celebrity chef Gordon Ramsay has come to an end in Montreal. more »
Top News Headlines
- Vancouver Stanley Cup rioter gets 17 months in jail
- Ryan Dickinson has been sentenced to 17 months in jail for his part in the June 15, 2011, Vancouver Stanley Cup riot. more »
- Former Expos catcher Gary Carter succumbs to brain cancer
- Hall of Fame catcher Gary Carter, who left an indelible mark on baseball in Canada during his 12 years with the Montreal Expos, died on Thursday. The man nicknamed "Kid" or "Kid Carter" for his ever-smiling face and cheerfulness is free from the inoperable brain cancer that sapped his energy and took his life at age 57. more »
- Dog kills newborn in Alberta community
- Officials in Airdrie are revealing few details about the fatal mauling of an infant by a family dog in the southern Alberta city. more »
- Underwear bomber sentenced to life in prison
- A Nigerian man who tried to blow up an international flight near Detroit on behalf of al-Qaida has been sentenced to life in prison without parole. more »
Most Viewed/Commented
- Montreal telemarketers in fraud case still making calls
- Man shot by Montreal police dies
- Actor who played mobster sentenced to 3 1/2 years
- Dog mauled at Montreal dog daycare
- Travellers at Trudeau airport witness flash mob
- 4km police chase ends in car breaking down
- Quebec daycare strike suspended
- Quebec denounces gun registry vote
- Sweet Isabelle's sexy cookies a St. Valentine's hit

