Tory pamphlets courting Jewish voters anger Grits
Text painting Liberals as anti-Semitic sent out in Montreal, Toronto, Winnipeg
Last Updated: Friday, November 20, 2009 | 11:45 AM ET
CBC News
Related
Internal Links
Audio
- AUDIO: Montrealer Elaine Bander and Liberal MP Irwin Cotler talk about the pamphlet (Runs: 9:15)
- Play: Real Media »
External Links
(Note: CBC does not endorse and is not responsible for the content of external sites - links will open in new window)
Liberals are demanding an apology from the Conservative government for distributing taxpayer-funded pamphlets that suggest the Grits are anti-Semitic.
Liberal MP Irwin Cotler, who represents the Montreal riding of Mount Royal, said the flyer campaign "crosses the line." The pamphlets are "abusive, almost hate speech that should not be found in civil discourse," he told CBC News.
New Democrat and Bloc Québécois MPs have agreed the latest propaganda represents a new low in the Tories' increasingly partisan use of so-called 10-percenters. These are mailings that MPs are entitled to send to voters outside their own ridings as long as they are not sent to more than 10 per cent of households in the riding.
But the Tories are refusing to apologize, maintaining the pamphlets are a strictly factual account of Liberal waffling on Israel, terrorism and the fight against anti-Semitism.
The pamphlets were mailed recently to households in at least five Liberal-held ridings with large Jewish populations – three in Quebec, one in Toronto and one in Winnipeg – under the names of several different Tory MPs, including junior cabinet minister Steven Fletcher.
"You should not be using a 10 per cent mailing for partisan purposes, and pernicious, and in this case, almost defamatory purposes," said Cotler. "It's bad enough that they go ahead and falsely … [accuse] the Liberals of supporting Hamas. Political propaganda is an understatement here."
Pamphlets misleading, say Liberals
The black, grey and white pamphlets ask voters to choose which federal political leader "is on the right track to represent and defend the values of Canada's Jewish community."
Liberal MP Irwin Cotler referred to the pamphlets as 'scandalous.' (Canadian Press)The pamphlets compare Prime Minister Stephen Harper's strong support for Israel to alleged waffling on the part of the Liberals.
They point out, for instance, that Harper's Conservatives "led the world" in boycotting the second UN-sponsored conference on racism in Geneva, Switzerland, which the pamphlets dubbed a "hate fest against Israel."
By contrast, the previous Liberal government "willingly participated in [the] overtly anti-Semitic" first such conference, held in Durban, South Africa, in 2001.
Cotler calls that statement a "serious misrepresentation" that implies anti-Semitism. "I did participate in Durban 1, but I spoke up against what turned out to be an anti-Semitic conference."
He said the previous Liberal government participated in the first Durban conference because Israel asked Canada to stay and "bear witness" to the anti-Semitic tirades by some delegations.
"This doesn't mean people there overtly participated in anti-Semitism," Cotler insisted. "That's utterly false. In fact, it's the other way around."
The pamphlet also delves into the thorny issue of Hezbollah. It states that Harper "strongly backed Israel's right to self-defence against Hezbollah" during the bombardment of Lebanon in 2006 while Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff "accused Israel of committing war crimes."
And whereas the Harper government "led the world" in halting funding to the Hamas-led Palestinian Authority, the leaflets say, Liberals opposed the move and wanted Hezbollah de-listed as a terrorist organization.
Cotler says it was a Liberal government that put Hamas and Hezbollah on the list of terrorist organizations, thereby making them ineligible for funding from any Canadian source.
As for Ignatieff, Cotler noted that the leader has apologized for accusing Israel of war crimes – a gaffe that enraged Jewish groups at the time and prompted Cotler's own wife to renounce her Liberal membership.
Some Jewish groups back Conservatives
Immigration Minister Jason Kenney denied the Tories are accusing Liberals of being anti-Semitic. Rather, he said, the pamphlets simply present a factual account of the Liberal record on issues of interest to Canada's Jewish community.
Immigration Minister Jason Kenney calls the pamphlets 'factual.' (Canadian Press)He scoffed at suggestions the Tories have sunk to a new low in partisan attacks. He maintained nothing Tories have said comes close to former Liberal cabinet minister Elinor Caplan's charge that the Canadian Alliance – predecessor to the Conservative party – was full of "Holocaust-deniers, prominent bigots and racists."
Kenney got some support from one of Canada's most prominent Jewish organizations.
Frank Dimant, CEO of B'nai Brith Canada, said he doesn't interpret the pamphlets as accusing the Liberals of anti-Semitism. Rather, he said, they seem to accurately recount the fact that on several key issues, the Conservatives "were more in tune with the Jewish community" than the Liberals.
The leaflets targeting Jewish voters are only the latest in a barrage of Conservative 10-percenters, most of which have been intensely partisan. A recent analysis by Montreal's Le Devoir found Tory MPs have spent $6.3 million to paper ridings with the brochures.
Liberal MP Bob Rae said parliamentarians should reconsider whether such pamphlets – symptomatic of what he called "a new kind of gutter politics" – are the best use of taxpayers' money. He favours banning MPs from sending mass mailings to voters outside their own ridings.
NDP deputy leader Thomas Mulcair also called for "an examination of conscience as to how much taxpayers' money we're spending on these very partisan attacks."
With files from the Canadian PressShare Tools
Latest Montreal News Headlines
- Champlain Bridge road work blitz this weekend
- Transport Quebec is advising drivers to avoid the Champlain Bridge corridor this weekend as a blitz of major road work closes down some lanes. more »
- Quebec students ready for tuition hike, says one leader
- The president of Quebec's College Student Federation (FECQ), Leo Bureau-Blouin, tells CBC Radio's The House that students "are ready for a compromise on the amount of a tuition hike," as the Quebec government and the province's student associations prepare to resume talks. more »
- IOC's Jacques Rogge encourages Olympic bids for Quebec City, Toronto
- International Olympic Committee president Jacques Rogge believes there is an opportunity for either Quebec City or Toronto to host a future Olympic Games. more »
- Casserole pan-demonium in Quebec
- Residents take to the streets with pots and pans to protest Bill 78. more »
Top News Headlines
- Everest team unable to bring down Toronto woman's body
- Bad weather has hampered the recovery team that is attempting to bring down the body of a Toronto woman who died trying to climb Mt. Everest. more »
- 32 Syrian children die in artillery attack, says UN
- More than 90 people have been killed by regime forces in a district of central Syria, with the head of the UN team in the country confirming at least 32 children and 60 adults were killed the attack. more »
- Woman's remains found in hockey bag on Cape Breton river
- Police in Nova Scotia are investigating after a woman's remains were found in a hockey bag floating on a Cape Breton river Friday night. more »
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges

- The estranged partner of a young mother who was stabbed to death along with her parents at their home in Aylmer, Que., has been charged with first-degree murder Friday. more »
Most Viewed/Commented
- Tornado touchdown confirmed near Montreal
- 32nd night protest in Montreal
- Quebec students challenge Bill 78 in court
- Mysterious photos may shed light on 2004 Quebec homicide
- Quebec faces mounting pressure amid student crisis
- Ottawa man in hospital after lightning strike
- Aylmer triple stabbing leads to first-degree murder charges
- Son testifies on behalf of father accused of killing wife
- Bookies set odds on Quebec student protest
