Block access to English private schools: PQ
Last Updated: Friday, November 13, 2009 | 9:23 PM ET
CBC News
PQ culture critic Pierre Curzi is calling on the Quebec government to invoke the notwithstanding clause. (CBC)The Parti Québécois is urging the Quebec government to use the Constitution’s notwithstanding clause to limit access to private English schools after the Supreme Court quashed part of the province’s language legislation.
Bill 104 had closed a loophole allowing children not eligible for the English-language public school system to gain access by first spending time in a private English school.
But last month, the loophole was reopened when the country’s highest court ordered Quebec to review and rewrite the law within a year and to review the parents' requests to send their children to English-language schools.
Students can only gain access to English public schools if their parents have received most of their education in Canadian English schools.
PQ culture critic Pierre Curzi said the best response to the quandary presented by the court is to restrict access to English private schools as well.
"It seems to be the only logical solution to the problem," Curzi said during a news conference Friday at the national assembly.
Bill 101, which became Quebec’s main language law, should have gone further to block access to English education when it was initially drawn up, but Bill 104 was the solution, Curzi said.
Culture Minister Christine St-Pierre agreed something must be done.
Culture Minister Christine St-Pierre says the government is studying its options. (CBC)
While the ruling may have quashed part of the law, St-Pierre said the judges also recognized Quebec’s need to control access to English schools.
"The ruling recognizes that some parents use this as a short cut to get into public schools," she said. "This is what we want to stop."
St-Pierre said the government is looking at its options, including the notwithstanding clause.
Use of the notwithstanding clause, which allows a legislature to declare a particular law beyond the reach of the Charter of Rights and a judicial review, has been controversial.
St-Pierre pointed to the government's use of the clause in 1989 to defend Law 178, which regulates the use of English on signs, was contested before the United Nation’s Human Rights Committee, she said.
Share Tools
Latest Montreal News Headlines
- 2nd Quebec daycare walkout affects 20,000 families
- Thousands of families made alternative child-care arrangements as a result of a one-day strike by workers at publicly funded daycares across Quebec. more »
- McGill asbestos study review criticized
- A group of anti-asbestos activists and scientists are criticizing McGill University's plans for an internal review of a major asbestos research study that has been called into question. more »
- Ex-priest gets 3 years for assaulting children
- A former Catholic priest is sentenced to three years in prison for sexually assaulting more than a dozen boys in his care during the 1970s and 1980s. more »
- Syrian-Montrealers organize for homeland
- Hoping to help family and friends in the crossfire of Syrian protests, three Montreal students are fighting back in their own way. more »
Top News Headlines
- Old Age Security untouched until 2020, Flaherty says
- Finance Minister Jim Flaherty says Canadians should expect no changes to Old Age Security benefits before 2020 or 2025, and details about reform would be outlined over more than one budget. more »
- Emailed rave rape pictures earn teen probation
- A teen convicted of emailing pictures of an alleged rape at a rave in Pitt Meadows, B.C., that were eventually posted by others on Facebook has been sentenced to 12 months probation for distributing obscene material. more »
- Prayer service held for Ontario van crash victims
- More than 300 people gather at a church in Stratford, Ont., to remember and support those affected by the collision that killed 11 people in Hampstead, Ont., earlier this week. more »
- SNC-Lavalin probe sought by Vanier's parents
- The parents of Cyndy Vanier — an Ontario woman jailed in Mexico amid allegations she tried to smuggle in members of Libya's Gadhafi family — want the RCMP to probe the actions of SNC-Lavalin, the company she was working for at the time of her arrest. more »
Most Viewed/Commented
- Quebec man, 76, shot and killed in Florida
- McGill asbestos study review criticized
- Hockey hazing spurs Longueuil school to suspend coaches
- SNC-Lavalin drops 2 executives tied to Gadhafi family
- 5 places where babies have been banned
- Quebec could soon be poorest province
- 2nd Quebec daycare walkout affects 20,000 families
- Syrian-Montrealers organize for homeland
- Woman guilty in Quebec farmer's gruesome murder

