PQ says Jewish General Hospital’s reaction to Bill 60 is premature

The Parti Québécois government says officials at Montreal’s Jewish General Hospital should take time to reflect on Bill 60, and speak at upcoming public hearings.

Charter minister Bernard Drainville says people should wait for public hearings before passing judgment

PQ charter minister Bernard Drainville says people should share their thoughts about Bill 60 during the public hearings, scheduled for Jan. 14. (CBC)

The Parti Québécois government says officials at Montreal’s Jewish General Hospital should take time to reflect on Bill 60, and speak at upcoming public hearings.

“In all respect for the Jewish hospital, I invite them to tell us what they think,” said Bernard Drainville, the minister responsible for the Quebec charter of secular values.

If Bill 60 were to become law, it would ban all public employees from wearing overt religious symbols.

In a statement released Wednesday, the hospital's executive director Lawrence Rosenberg called the Bill “patently discriminatory” -- and deeply insulting to its staff.

Some staff members say if this charter does become law, they’ll defy it -- saying they believe the government can’t stop them.

Dr. Ronald Schondorf says he'll continue to wear his kippa to work at the Jewish General Hospital, even if Quebec passes a secular charter. (CBC)

“I would like to see that -- I would like to see me hauled away in chains because I come to work in a kippa. I think lawyers would be lining up around the block to defend me,” Dr. Ronald Schondorf said.

Drainville called the reaction premature, and said there will be plenty of time for hospital officials to voice their opinions during upcoming hearings into the Bill - which start on Jan. 14

PQ cabinet minister Jean-FrançoisLisée agreed, and said the hospital's criticism is confusing.

“If there's one institution that we had in mind all through this process, it's the Jewish General hospital,” said Lisée, the minister responsible for the Montreal region.

Lisée said that a special clause  which would exempt some hospitals from the ban  was aimed squarely at the Jewish General.

“We believe that when people go to other hospitals in Quebec, with maybe a couple of exceptions, they go to a public hospital. When they go to the Jewish, they know they’re going to the Jewish,” he said.

Members of the opposition says the PQ is missing the point.

“The message here is the same as we are putting forward: we don't want to trade in our rights and our freedoms. This is a free society in Quebec,” said Liberal French Language Charter Critic Marc Tanguay.

Public hearings into Bill 60 that start in mid-January are expected to last several weeks.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.