Montreal police 'not reliable,' says brother of man shot by officers

The decision not to charge Montreal police in the shooting death of Alain Magloire last February suggests officers “are not responsible” for their actions anymore, the man’s brother says.

Alain Magloire was mentally ill when he was shot by Montreal police outside Berri bus station

Alain Magloire, 42, was shot and killed by police on Feb. 3, 2014 after he used a hammer to smash a window near the downtown coach bus terminal. (Facebook)

The decision not to charge Montreal police officers in the shooting death of a homeless, mentally ill man last February suggests police “are not responsible” for their actions anymore, the man’s brother says.

Pierre Magloire spoke to CBC Radio’s Daybreak about yesterday's decision by the Quebec's chief Crown prosecutor not to lay charges in the killing of his brother, Alain Magloire, 41.

Magloire was shot and killed by Montreal police officers outside the Berri bus station in downtown Montreal on Feb. 3.

At the time, officers said he was wielding a hammer in a threatening manner and refused to co-operate.

The shooting was investigated by Quebec’s provincial police force, the Sûreté du Québec. It is standard practice that another police force investigate whenever a police weapon is discharged or a civilian is hurt in the course of a police intervention.

The Crown prosecutor’s decision not to charge the officers who shot Magloire was based on evidence from the SQ investigation.

Brother "sad and mad"

Pierre Magloire said he had "mixed emotions" about the decision not to press charges.

“I’m sad and mad at the same time. I was expecting a trial to seek the truth, to find out what really happened,” he told Daybreak.

He called the decision “strange” – and worrisome.

“Nobody’s responsible anymore. When you’re a doctor or a lawyer, you’re responsible for your actions. You’re liable for what you’re doing. Police are not reliable, they’re not responsible for anything anymore,” he said.

Magloire said the Crown's decision sends the wrong message.

“When you have a policeman shooting four times in a row, in the arm, shoulder and liver and then the heart — but you’re not responsible? Excuse me, you’re responsible. Or at least the system is responsible for teaching you to shoot like that at a person,” he told Daybreak.

Beyond seeking justice, Magloire said he wanted a trial so that police procedures could be brought to light and, if necessary, corrected.

“I wanted Montreal police to change the way they’re acting with homeless people. That’s the only thing I was looking for,” he said.

Alain Magloire had only ended up living on the street in the months just prior to his death, as a result of mental illness.  

He had two daughters and many friends, and before his illness he had been employed in the field of molecular biology research.

In July, Quebec's coroner called for better training for front-line officers in identifying and handling mental health crises.

Coroner Jean Brochu also renewed the call for Montreal police officers to be equipped with Tasers.

Renewed call for independent investigations of police

Pierre Magloire echoed calls for an end to police investigations of other police forces in such cases, a position held by Quebec’s coroner, Quebec’s Human Rights Commission and the province’s ombudsman, among others.

Previous Quebec governments have promised to create an independent police oversight agency, but it has never happened.

“We need a third party to investigate these situations. I would like a commission, an expert inquiry but not policemen investigating other policemen,” he said.


To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.