La Ronde under fire for scanning visitors' fingerprints

La Ronde, the Montreal amusement park owned by Six Flags, is scanning biometric data from its users to admit them to the park. The only problem is, it hasn't been cleared to do so.

Quebec privacy commissioner says La Ronde has not been cleared to have biometric database

This year, La Ronde started scanning season-pass holders’ index fingers to admit them to the amusement park. (CBC)

La Ronde, the Montreal amusement park owned by Six Flags, is scanning biometric data from its users to admit them to the park. The only problem is, it hasn't been cleared to do so.

This year, the park brought in measures to scan what it calls “fingerpoints." The scans of season-pass holders’ index fingers are then used to admit them to the amusement park.

“So what happens is season-pass owners come to the park, they have two options. Either they can do a traditional way, so they can get a season pass with picture or they can go through our new system, which is quicker,” La Ronde’s communications officer Jules Hébert told CBC Daybreak on Wednesday.

La Ronde distributes this information leaflet to visitors to the park. (Radio-Canada)

He said a person can gain access to the park in just nine seconds using this method.

However, according to Quebec privacy commissioner spokeswoman Isabelle St-Pierre, in order to operate a biometric database, a company or institution needs to first make a request to do so to the Commission d’accès à l’information du Québec — a step she said La Ronde has not yet taken.

“Six Flags has not declared this database yet,” St-Pierre said.

She said that the privacy commission looks at what the applying company wants to do with the information and how it will preserve, consult and destroy it.

But Hébert from La Ronde said the park, which is owned by Six Flags, sought legal advice before implementing the finger-scanning procedure. 

"We’re working within the law, so we feel very comfortable," he said.

Difference between fingerpoints and fingerprints

La Ronde's policy is part of parent company Six Flags' new biometric pass

Hébert tried to argue semantics on Daybreak on Wednesday, saying that the finger-scanning picked up fingerpoints, and not fingerprints.

Six Flags has not declared this database yet.-Isabelle St-Pierre, privacy commission spokeswoman

“It will identify points on your finger and it’ll generate a mathematical formula. That formula will be saved on our local servers, and every time you come and scan your finger we’ll try to coordinate these points with your fingerpoints. So this is the process. There are no fingerprints, we don’t say fingerprints,” he told host Mike Finnerty.

But Boris Perron, an investigator specialized in information technology with the Quebec privacy commission, said fingerpoints are the biometric measure of fingerprinting — and both fingerpoints and fingerprints are subject to privacy laws governing biometric databases.

Perron explained that when a scanner reads a person's finger, it picks up points, or characteristics, that identify a person. A database can store those points and not a direct image of the fingerprint, but it's sort of six of one and half-dozen of the other.

He said of fingerpoints, "That's what the biometric measure is."

Law says offer alternative

Part of the law on information technology stipulates that citizens must be given the option of not supplying their biometric data.

“You can’t refuse a service or good to a person because they refuse to give their biometric data,” St-Pierre said.

Hébert said the park does offer an alternative option to its users, even if an information leaflet it distributes describing how to enter the park doesn’t make that clear. 

Disney theme parks in the U.S. have already introduced biometric screening.

Comments

To encourage thoughtful and respectful conversations, first and last names will appear with each submission to CBC/Radio-Canada's online communities (except in children and youth-oriented communities). Pseudonyms will no longer be permitted.

By submitting a comment, you accept that CBC has the right to reproduce and publish that comment in whole or in part, in any manner CBC chooses. Please note that CBC does not endorse the opinions expressed in comments. Comments on this story are moderated according to our Submission Guidelines. Comments are welcome while open. We reserve the right to close comments at any time.