Ex-soldier avoids jail time for fatal training accident
Paul Ravensdale convicted of 4 charges related to fatal Afghanistan incident
CBC News
Posted: Mar 19, 2013 11:46 AM CT
Last Updated: Mar 19, 2013 7:34 PM CT
A military judge has handed a retired Manitoba soldier, convicted in a deadly training accident in Afghanistan in 2010, a six-month suspended sentence.
That means retired warrant officer Paul Ravensdale, 43, won't spend any time in jail.
A five-member court martial panel at CFB Shilo found Ravensdale guilty on Feb. 14 of breach of duty causing death, breach of duty causing bodily harm, unlawfully causing bodily harm and negligent performance of military duty.
On Tuesday, Chief Military Judge Col. Mario Dutil sentenced Ravensdale to six months in prison, but suspended the sentence. The judge also handed Ravensdale a $2,000 fine and a demotion in rank to sergeant.
Ravensdale faced a maximum sentence of life in prison.
The charges stem from a military training accident that killed one solder and left four others injured in Afghanistan in February 2010.
Anti-personnel mine misfired
At the time, Ravensdale was leading a test of C-19 anti-personnel mines on a weapons range near Kandahar city when one of the mines misfired, shooting hundreds of steel ball bearings in the wrong direction.
Cpl. Josh Baker, 24, was struck by four projectiles and died of a penetrating wound to the chest. Four other soldiers were wounded.
Ravensdale, who was responsible for safety on the range that day, becomes the first in Canadian history to be convicted under Section 80 of the Criminal Code of breach of duty related to the use of an explosive substance that causes death or injury.
He was originally charged with manslaughter, but he was found not guilty of that charge.
Military prosecutors had asked for four years of jail time, while Ravensdale's defence team argued it was a tragic accident and that he has suffered enough already. They asked his sentence be limited to a demotion in rank.
"The prosecution and defence had [significantly] different views on how to approach the sentence in this case," Ravensdale's lawyer, Maj. Philippe-Luc Boutin, told reporters. "We feel that our approach has prevailed, and we are very satisfied with this."
Prosecutors say they have not decided whether they will appeal.
Ravensdale will be able to serve his suspended sentence in the community as long as he exhibits good behaviour.
Set himself for failure
In his ruling, Dutil said Ravensdale had "set himself up for failure" because he failed to consult safety manuals for the training exercise.
"The mere fact that he thought he knew what he was doing is insufficient … the situation was taken too lightly," Dutil said.
Paul Ravensdale walks to his court martial on Jan. 28 at CFB Shilo. (Aadel Haleem/CBC)At the same time, the judge added, Ravensdale "should not have been put in this situation in the first place" by his superiors, who shared a "high level of responsibility" in what happened.
Two of his superiors have already been demoted in connection with the incident.
Darryl Watts was demoted to lieutenant from major and given a severe reprimand following his conviction on charges of unlawfully causing bodily harm and negligent performance of duty. Watts is appealing his conviction.
Watts's commanding officer, Christopher Lunney, pleaded guilty in September to negligent performance of duty and was demoted to captain from major and given a severe reprimand.
Dutil said Lunney and Watts were aware that Ravensdale's platoon had no formal or informal pre-deployment training with C-19s, but they did not communicate this to Ravensdale.
Suffers from PTSD
Dutil said while he wanted to give Ravensdale a year behind bars, he noted that the sentences Lunney and Watts received were on the "very low end" of the spectrum, so it was only appropriate to adjust Ravensdale's sentence accordingly.
Dutil noted Ravensdale's distinguished record — he served for almost 25 years in the military and had what the judge described as a stellar record — and his diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder as factors in the decision not to give him jail time.
Ravensdale, who retired from the Canadian Forces in January 2012, said during his sentencing hearing on March 5 that he has had to seek family counselling, and he suffers from PTSD and depression.
"I can't move on," he told the hearing. "Every day, I relive Feb. 12 like Groundhog Day."
Dutil said Ravensdale, a father of four who coaches hockey in the community, is currently pursuing full-time college studies towards a career in human resources.
Ravensdale and his family did not speak to reporters after the sentence was handed down on Tuesday.
With files from CBC's Chris Glover and The Canadian PressShare Tools
Latest Manitoba News Headlines
- Taylor Swift concert plan targets stadium traffic woes
- Plans are being made to improve traffic flow to the new stadium this weekend in time for the Taylor Swift concert. more »
- More seniors dying in bedrail accidents, reports show
- More seniors have died in Manitoba after becoming trapped in their bed rails, despite years of warnings from U.S. and Canadian health authorities. more »
- Lick It List resurrected for second dying dog
- An 11-year-old boy from Shilo, Man., is embarking on his second tribute to a dying dog in one year. more »
- Search continues for Jennifer Catcheway 5 years later
- One of Manitoba's most high-profile cases of missing or murdered women is now five years old. more »
Must Watch
Top News Headlines
- Neil Macdonald: Washington's obsession with leakers
- Julian Assange and Edward Snowden are just the most prominent targets in an all-out legal and propaganda campaign that America's security apparatus is mounting against leakers everywhere, Neil Macdonald writes. more »
- 30,000 Canadians are homeless every night
- A new national report into homelessness in this country tells a grim story — at least 200,000 Canadians experience homelessness in any given year and least 30,000 Canadians are homeless on any given night. more »
- Who's who in the Senate expense controversy
- Keeping track of the names popping up in the ongoing Senate expenses controversy — from the investigators to the four senators themselves — could be a difficult task for even the most seasoned political observers. more »
- How open is Ottawa's new 'open data' website?
- Treasury Board President Tony Clement is touting the federal government's revamped data portal as a "new natural resource." But that online window for previously published data arrives at the same time the government faces controversy over just how open it really is. more »
- Has the lost bell of Batoche been found in Manitoba?
- Girl, 3, critical after car hits building in West End
- Thousands of caterpillars descend on Lake Manitoba
- Lick It List resurrected for second dying dog
- Manitoba math classes going back to the basics
- Tory MP bows to Elections Canada in fight over expenses
- More seniors dying in bedrail accidents, reports show
- Judge rules on brothers’ testimony in archbishop sex trial
- Dustin Paxton's outstanding assault charges stayed


A New Home for the Bombers